Bill S. — Writing the Big Book: Chapter 19 The Family Afterword (April 28, 2022)

Bill S. — Writing the Big Book: Chapter 19 The Family Afterword (April 28, 2022)

Workshop Recording

Listen to Audio Recording

Transcript

[00:00:02.280 – 00:00:02.900] Good evening, everyone. [00:00:02.900 – 00:00:09.980] My name is David, I'm an alcoholic, and you're all very welcome to this reading book meeting on Zoom, hosted by the Growing and Understanding A Group. [00:00:09.980 – 00:00:20.040] And we're on chapter 19: The Family Afterword and the Authorship Q., and we're in October to November 1938 of Writing the Big Book: The Creation of A, written by [00:00:20.040 – 00:00:21.220] Bill S.. [00:00:21.220 – 00:00:25.440] And our guest reader today is none other than Bill S.. [00:00:25.440 – 00:00:25.550] Yay. [00:00:25.550 – 00:00:26.740] Delighted to have you here, Bill.

[00:00:26.740 – 00:00:27.840] Yay. [00:00:27.840 – 00:00:38.420] Now, the audio of these meetings are being recorded and can be found on recoveryspeakers.com, and I'd like to thank Mike K- Mike K. for doing that for us, and I'll put a link as we go through the meeting [00:00:38.420 – 00:00:39.820] into the chat. [00:00:39.820 – 00:00:42.560] Now, we're gonna go over to Connie in Cleveland. [00:00:42.560 – 00:00:45.860] Connie is gonna mention something for us about some upcoming event. [00:00:45.860 – 00:00:46.560] Is that right, Connie? [00:00:46.560 – 00:00:47.520] Hi, yes.

[00:00:47.520 – 00:00:48.560] Hi, uh, group. [00:00:48.560 – 00:00:51.200] Uh, my name's Connie, I'm an alcoholic from Cleveland. [00:00:51.200 – 00:00:51.690] Hi. [00:00:51.690 – 00:00:59.500] I live about an hour away from Akron, Ohio, and every year there's a Founder's Day celebration in Akron, Ohio. [00:00:59.500 – 00:01:05.700] This year it is June 10th, 11th and 12th, which is Friday, Saturday and Sunday. [00:01:05.700 – 00:01:07.880] Now, the last two years have been virtual. [00:01:07.880 – 00:01:12.880] This year is going to be in person, and they're expecting about 10,000 people.

[00:01:12.880 – 00:01:16.920] It's $30 for the registration for the weekend. [00:01:16.920 – 00:01:26.260] If you'd like to stay in the dorms, uh, which I've done before and is a lot of fun, it's $175 for that package. [00:01:26.260 – 00:01:32.280] If you'd like the registration, the dorm and the meal plan, that's $250. [00:01:32.280 – 00:01:34.720] So that's a lot of bang for the buck. [00:01:34.720 – 00:01:39.539] Um, there's meetings all day, there's dances, there's plays, there's panels. [00:01:39.539 – 00:01:44.480] Um, and you get to meet your, uh, friends from all over the world. [00:01:44.480 – 00:01:48.020] The information is at, at…

[00:01:48.020 – 00:01:49.480] Well, where'd it go? [00:01:49.480 – 00:01:57.280] Akron- I put it, I- Www.akron, A-K-R-O-N, a-a.org. [00:01:57.280 – 00:01:58.570] Thank you, Connie. [00:01:58.570 – 00:02:00.400] And, um, I'm already registered. [00:02:00.400 – 00:02:06.320] Um, the local clubs have, uh, buses and vans, um, in the area. [00:02:06.320 – 00:02:07.840] The intergroup is open. [00:02:07.840 – 00:02:09.020] You can visit Dr.

[00:02:09.020 – 00:02:11.640] Bob's grave, the Mayflower H., Dr. [00:02:11.640 – 00:02:12.780] Bob's house. [00:02:12.780 – 00:02:15.290] Um, there's barbecues- Thank- … [00:02:15.290 – 00:02:16.380] and it's fabulous. [00:02:16.380 – 00:02:18.060] Thank you, Connie, for that. [00:02:18.060 – 00:02:18.780] Brilliant. [00:02:18.780 – 00:02:29.300] So T. Five, the long form, "Each A group ought to be a spiritual entity having but one primary purpose, and that of course is carrying its message to the alcoholics who are unfortunately still suffering

[00:02:29.300 – 00:02:39.410] from alcoholism." The main purpose of these reading book meetings is to improve our understanding of the fellowship of Alcoholics Anonymous and the A message contained in the book titled Alcoholics [00:02:39.410 – 00:02:43.440] Anonymous, and of course the creation of Alcoholics Anonymous. [00:02:43.440 – 00:02:47.120] Now, I have every week, as I said, we have a guest reader. [00:02:47.120 – 00:02:48.350] Well, this week we have Bill S.. [00:02:48.350 – 00:02:51.860] I'm just gonna put Bill's, uh, anyone's listening, contact Bill S.. [00:02:51.860 – 00:03:01.880] I'm gonna put writingthebigbook.com if you'd like to get in contact with Bill S., and also bill@athenarearebooks.com, and I put that right into the chat [00:03:01.880 – 00:03:02.100] now.

[00:03:02.100 – 00:03:05.359] Now, before we start these meetings and get into the… [00:03:05.359 – 00:03:11.860] We'll go and put up, um, a version of the set aside prayer, and if you'd like to join in, please do so. [00:03:11.860 – 00:03:14.420] And we're using obviously God as you understand him. [00:03:14.420 – 00:03:16.540] So can you unmute? [00:03:16.540 – 00:03:17.640] I believe you can unmute. [00:03:17.640 – 00:03:20.240] So G.- God … [00:03:20.240 – 00:03:29.860] please help me to set aside everything I think I know for an open mind- Open mind and a new experience …

[00:03:29.860 – 00:03:29.870] new experience. [00:03:29.870 – 00:03:30.620] Amen. [00:03:30.620 – 00:03:30.630] Amen. [00:03:30.630 – 00:03:31.960] Thank you. [00:03:31.960 – 00:03:38.980] And we just have a few moments silence to gather our thoughts, obviously reflect on why we're here, and to think of those who are still suffering from alcoholism and our family members. [00:03:38.980 – 00:03:40.500] Thank you. [00:03:40.500 – 00:03:50.120] Thank you, everyone.

[00:03:50.120 – 00:03:56.490] Um, I will put up a copy of the Kindle edition up on the screen, and we will be following, um, Mr. [00:03:56.490 – 00:03:57.140] S.. [00:03:57.140 – 00:04:02.080] It's always great to have you in the room, Bill, but now the fact that I, I get really excited when you're reading the chapter itself. [00:04:02.080 – 00:04:03.480] So B., over to you. [00:04:03.480 – 00:04:04.080] Bill S.. [00:04:04.080 – 00:04:07.000] Good afternoon, good evening. [00:04:07.000 – 00:04:09.460] Um, Bill S..

[00:04:09.460 – 00:04:13.340] Chapter 19: The Family Afterwords and the Authorship Q.. [00:04:13.340 – 00:04:16.440] October to November, 1938. [00:04:16.440 – 00:04:21.019] Okay, David's got it up. [00:04:21.019 – 00:04:21.260] Hold on. [00:04:21.260 – 00:04:24.900] I gotta, I gotta squeeze it down a little bit. [00:04:24.900 – 00:04:25.280] Okay. [00:04:25.280 – 00:04:35.320] "For the next chapter in the Big Book, The Family Afterwords, Bill W. shifted gears and assumed a new persona, speaking in the voice of the families of

[00:04:35.320 – 00:04:36.480] Alcoholics Anonymous. [00:04:36.480 – 00:04:46.820] Under this thin guise, he goes beyond talking about just the wife's role in her husband's recovery and describes at length the changing dynamics in a family confronted with [00:04:46.820 – 00:04:56.620] father's sudden adoption of the sober life, mentioning specific problems they will likely face, and offering some solutions based on A's collective experience up to that time. [00:04:56.620 – 00:05:06.880] Given that Bill authored both of these chapters, it's almost comical to see him open The Family Afterwords by backpedaling and undercutting the overprotective [00:05:06.880 – 00:05:10.920] suggestions the wives of Alcoholics Anonymous had offered in the previous chapter. [00:05:10.920 – 00:05:16.660] 'Our womenfolk have suggested certain attitudes a wife may take with a husband who is recovering. [00:05:16.660 – 00:05:22.480] Perhaps they created the impression that he is to be wrapped in cotton wool and placed on a pedestal-

[00:05:23.448 – 00:05:25.788] Successful readjustment means the opposite. [00:05:25.788 – 00:05:31.827] All members of the family must meet upon the common ground of tolerance, understanding, and love. [00:05:31.827 – 00:05:39.568] So finally, we're gonna learn something about the newly sober husband's responsibilities, along with those of the other family members. [00:05:39.568 – 00:05:49.708] W. warns that everyone in this newly reconfigured family unit, the alcoholic, his wife, his children, and even his in-laws, will have their own [00:05:49.708 – 00:05:52.088] idea about how the new arrangement should work. [00:05:52.088 – 00:05:59.568] But if anyone demands that the other concede to their particular vision, it will only result in discord and unhappiness. [00:05:59.568 – 00:06:09.888] Instead, each family member must give up the desire to have his or her wishes respected, and abandon all attempts to arrange the family show to his liking.

[00:06:09.888 – 00:06:19.948] Rather than each member contentiously trying to manage these new changes, it is now a question of what each person can give to the family rather than what they [00:06:19.948 – 00:06:21.708] can take under the new setup. [00:06:21.708 – 00:06:23.788] The obstacles ahead. [00:06:23.788 – 00:06:34.308] With this perilous warning of the pitfalls that lay before each family member, including the newly sober father, W. makes a promising proposal. [00:06:34.308 – 00:06:38.408] Suppose we tell you some of the obstacles a family will meet. [00:06:38.408 – 00:06:45.388] Suppose we suggest how they may be avoided, even converted to good use for others. [00:06:45.388 – 00:06:54.828] All family members, he cautions, will remember when father was romantic, thoughtful, and successful, and now that he is sober, family confidence in dad is riding high.

[00:06:54.828 – 00:06:57.998] Everyone thinks the good old days will soon be back. [00:06:57.998 – 00:07:02.228] But W. states in graphic terms that nothing could be farther from the truth. [00:07:02.228 – 00:07:09.108] The head of the house has spent years in pulling down the structures of business, romance, friendship, health. [00:07:09.108 – 00:07:11.548] These things are now ruined or damaged. [00:07:11.548 – 00:07:19.548] It will take time to clear away all that wreckage, and perhaps even years to complete the construction of what needs to be built in its place. [00:07:19.548 – 00:07:22.708] Confronting the past. [00:07:22.708 – 00:07:27.328] So what was the biggest obstacle the family will face on this new road of sobriety?

[00:07:27.328 – 00:07:29.228] It is the past. [00:07:29.228 – 00:07:39.618] Now a nana family will be pa- plagued by specters from the past, for the drinking career of almost every alcoholic has been marked by escapades funny, humiliating, [00:07:39.618 – 00:07:41.628] shameful, or tragic. [00:07:41.628 – 00:07:46.268] The first impulse will be to bury these skeletons in a dark closet and padlock the door. [00:07:46.268 – 00:07:59.468] The family may be obsessed with the idea that- Someone [00:07:59.468 – 00:08:00.748] needs to mute there, okay? [00:08:00.748 – 00:08:02.048] Got to, got to be mute.

[00:08:02.048 – 00:08:02.888] Got to be mute. [00:08:02.888 – 00:08:09.108] The family may be obsessed with the idea that future happiness can be based only upon forgetfulness of the past. [00:08:09.108 – 00:08:13.748] Such a view is quite self-centered and in direct conflict with the new way of life. [00:08:13.748 – 00:08:23.768] Quoting H. F., who famously extolled experience as the thing of supreme value in life, Bill notes that this maxim is true [00:08:23.768 – 00:08:26.168] only if one is willing to turn the past to good account. [00:08:26.168 – 00:08:34.888] But with proper and judicious use, the alcoholic's past thus becomes the principal asset of the family, and frequently it is the only one. [00:08:34.888 – 00:08:38.927] As such, it must be honestly acknowledged and then used wisely.

[00:08:38.927 – 00:08:48.948] Such an attitude not only allows the alcoholic to grow in willingness to face and rectify errors and convert them to, into assets, it is also helpful to [00:08:48.948 – 00:08:52.848] other family, families who are struggling under similar circumstances. [00:08:52.848 – 00:08:59.248] We think each family which has been relieved owes something to those which have not. [00:08:59.248 – 00:09:09.547] And when the occasion requires, each member of it who has found God should be only too willing to bring former mistakes, no matter how grievous, out of their hiding place, for [00:09:09.547 – 00:09:16.108] in God's hands the dark past is the greatest possession you have, the key to life and happiness for others. [00:09:16.108 – 00:09:26.148] But before exploring the ways in which the sharing of intimate information between the families of Alcoholics Anonymous actually operates, Bill offers a word of [00:09:26.148 – 00:09:29.208] caution about confessing past sexual indiscretions.

[00:09:29.208 – 00:09:32.748] There are limits to what should and should not be revealed. [00:09:32.748 – 00:09:42.968] Sometimes, he says, in the first flush of spiritual experience, partners will confess to extramarital affairs and then forgive each other, only to have the agreed party [00:09:42.968 – 00:09:47.228] later unearth the old affair and angrily cast its ashes about. [00:09:47.228 – 00:09:54.508] These kind of growing pains can hurt a great deal, and they are, have driven more than one alcoholic back to the bottle. [00:09:54.508 – 00:10:03.968] Given that potentially disastrous result, our rule is that unless some good and useful purpose is to be served, past occurrences are not discussed. [00:10:03.968 – 00:10:07.748] Some parts of the past are just better left buried. [00:10:07.748 – 00:10:12.668] However, among members of the fellowship, we have few secrets.

[00:10:12.668 – 00:10:14.828] Everyone knows about everyone else. [00:10:14.828 – 00:10:22.088] W. acknowledges that in ordinary, ordinary life such intimacy would likely produce untold grief. [00:10:22.088 – 00:10:32.608] But it would invariably lead to scandalous gossip, because it would invariably lead to scandalous gossip, laughter at the, the expense of other people, [00:10:32.608 – 00:10:35.268] and a tendency to take advantage of intimate information. [00:10:35.268 – 00:10:40.188] But among ourselves, he confidently states, these are rare occurrences. [00:10:40.188 – 00:10:44.898] We do talk about each other a great deal, he says, but this talk is tempered [00:10:45.416 – 00:10:48.136] By an attitude of love and tolerance.

[00:10:48.136 – 00:10:54.476] We are also careful to keep whatever confidences someone might share with us to ourselves, unless we are sure he would approve. [00:10:54.476 – 00:11:03.975] This is critical but, is critical because if we do not, the criticism or ridicule that may result has been known to raise the very devil. [00:11:03.975 – 00:11:10.216] We alcoholics are sensitive people, and it takes some of us a long time to outgrow this serious handicap. [00:11:10.216 – 00:11:15.076] I'm surprised that wasn't in italics, but that's over to addictive there. [00:11:15.076 – 00:11:16.896] Economic problems. [00:11:16.896 – 00:11:26.996] Having spent the first third of the chapter on these preliminaries, W. devotes the middle third to explaining the two basic ways in which a recently sober man typically reacts [00:11:26.996 – 00:11:27.896] to his new life.

[00:11:27.896 – 00:11:32.996] At the beginning of recovery, a man will, as a rule, take one of two directions. [00:11:32.996 – 00:11:43.016] He may either plunge into a frantic attempt to get on his feet in business, or he may be so enthralled by his new life that he talks of noth- think talks and thinks [00:11:43.016 – 00:11:43.876] of little else. [00:11:43.876 – 00:11:50.155] Bill warns that whichever of these two paths he might choose, certain family problems will arise. [00:11:50.155 – 00:12:00.276] Here, the members of Alcoholics Anonymous think they can be helpful because they have a hard-won experience with both of these roads so commonly taken by recently sober men, [00:12:00.276 – 00:12:01.776] men. [00:12:01.776 – 00:12:10.016] If a new man elects the first course and rushes headlong at his economic problems, W. suggests it will likely prove to be a mixed blessing.

[00:12:10.016 – 00:12:16.556] At first, the family members will be delighted because they feel their financial troubles are about to be solved. [00:12:16.556 – 00:12:22.476] But they quickly become less pleased as they find themselves neglected by the now tired and preoccupied father. [00:12:22.476 – 00:12:29.796] Dad pays little attention to the children, he is inattentive to his wife, and frequently acts out irritably. [00:12:29.796 – 00:12:39.836] When the wife and children, expecting a much happier home life, react critically to these unpleasant changes, resentments grow between [00:12:39.836 – 00:12:40.596] family members. [00:12:40.596 – 00:12:46.206] Nobody is getting what they wanted and what they think they deserve from Dad's new life of sobriety. [00:12:46.206 – 00:12:50.366] "This sort of thing must be stopped," Bill states emphatically.

[00:12:50.366 – 00:12:55.636] Both father and the family are wrong, though each side may have some justification. [00:12:55.636 – 00:13:00.496] It is of little use to argue and only makes the impasse worse. [00:13:00.496 – 00:13:03.976] To the wife and children, he recommends patience. [00:13:03.976 – 00:13:09.016] The family must realize that Dad, though marvelously improved, is still a sick man. [00:13:09.016 – 00:13:17.436] They should thank God, they should thank God he is sober and be able, and, and able to be of this world once more. [00:13:17.436 – 00:13:19.056] Let them praise his progress. [00:13:19.056 – 00:13:24.256] Let them remember that his drinking wrought all kinds of damage that may take long to repair.

[00:13:24.256 – 00:13:34.256] If they sense these things, they will not take so seriously his periods of crankiness, depression, or apathy, which will disappear where there is tolerance, [00:13:34.256 – 00:13:36.056] love, and spiritual understanding. [00:13:36.056 – 00:13:41.116] But the husband too must make some significant cha- concessions and changes. [00:13:41.116 – 00:13:46.605] The head of the house ought to remember that he is mainly to blame for what befell his home. [00:13:46.605 – 00:13:49.636] He can scarcely square the account in his lifetime. [00:13:49.636 – 00:13:54.016] But he must see the danger of over-concentration on financial success. [00:13:54.016 – 00:14:00.246] Although financial recovery is on the way for many of us, we found we could not place money first.

[00:14:00.246 – 00:14:05.636] For us, material well-bili- being always followed spiritual progress. [00:14:05.636 – 00:14:07.536] It never preceded. [00:14:07.536 – 00:14:13.436] Since the home has suffered more than anything else, it is well that a man exerts himself there. [00:14:13.436 – 00:14:20.476] He is not likely to get far in any direction if he fails to show unselfishness and love under his own roof. [00:14:20.476 – 00:14:30.476] With the proper amount of attentive consideration and mutual concern, each member of a resentful family begins to see his shortcomings and admits them [00:14:30.476 – 00:14:34.296] to the other, thereby laying the basis for helpful discussion. [00:14:34.296 – 00:14:40.196] Little by little, mother and children will see they ask too much, and father will see he gives too little.

[00:14:40.196 – 00:14:43.956] Giving rather than getting will become the guiding principle. [00:14:43.956 – 00:14:46.996] Spiritual intoxication. [00:14:46.996 – 00:14:57.236] But what if the husband chooses the second path, completely embracing his recent spiritual experience, and overnight becomes a religious enthusiast? [00:14:57.236 – 00:15:02.306] This can be even more disruptive for the family than the man obsessed with financial recovery. [00:15:02.306 – 00:15:06.906] Bill describes how this can play out in an alcoholic's freshly minted sobriety. [00:15:06.906 – 00:15:10.076] He is unable to focus on anything else. [00:15:10.076 – 00:15:13.796] There's talk about spiritual matters morning, noon, and night.

[00:15:13.796 – 00:15:22.256] He may demand that the family find God for themselves in a hurry or exhibit amazing indifference to them and say he is above worldly considerations. [00:15:22.256 – 00:15:31.916] He tells mother, who has been religious all her life, that she doesn't know what it's all about, and that she had better get his brand of spirituality while there is yet time. [00:15:31.916 – 00:15:42.036] The family will probably react to this by looking at their strange new dad with apprehension, even with irritation, and they may become [00:15:42.036 – 00:15:44.636] jealous of a God who has stolen Dad's affection. [00:15:44.636 – 00:15:50.976] They become critical, and in their neglected state, begin to wonder if Dad really is so spiritual after all. [00:15:50.976 – 00:15:53.956] Why all this concern for everyone in the world but his family? [00:15:53.956 – 00:15:57.196] They may even begin to suspect that father is a little barmy.

[00:15:57.196 – 00:16:07.216] Under these circumstances, W. pleads for the family's understanding, pointing out that many AA members, members of AA have gone through just this sort of [00:16:07.216 – 00:16:07.536] a lay… [00:16:07.904 – 00:16:10.444] and, and indulged in spiritual intoxication. [00:16:10.444 – 00:16:20.824] Given time, such men will come to their senses and realize he, and realize he has been suffering from a distortion of values, and that his spiritual growth is lopsided. [00:16:20.824 – 00:16:23.904] The wife and children must be patient. [00:16:23.904 – 00:16:30.024] With the help of a sympathetic family, these vagaries of dad's spiritual infancy will quickly disappear. [00:16:30.024 – 00:16:40.124] If, however, the family rest- relentlessly condemns and criticizes him, this fallacy will take a still greater hold on father, and he will retreat

[00:16:40.124 – 00:16:45.704] farther into himself, believing he has now become a superior person with God on his side. [00:16:45.704 – 00:16:56.184] Despite his neglect and irresponsibility towards the family, the proper response is to accept these alarming and disagreeable manifestations of his new spiritual life, [00:16:56.184 – 00:16:59.104] and let him go as far as he likes in helping other alcoholics. [00:16:59.104 – 00:17:05.304] In the long run, working with others will do more to ensure his sobriety than anything else. [00:17:05.304 – 00:17:15.843] The man who takes the spiritual path is building a much firmer foundation for his sobriety than the man who is placing business or professional success ahead of spiritual development. [00:17:15.843 – 00:17:21.164] He will be less likely to drink again, and anything is pref- preferable to that. [00:17:21.164 – 00:17:31.164] W. assures the family that an early overemphasis on the spiritual life is common among newly sober men, but just as

[00:17:31.164 – 00:17:36.744] common is the eventual recognition of the childishness of this world of spiritual make-believe. [00:17:36.744 – 00:17:46.924] Once that happens, this dream world is replaced by a great sense of purpose, accompanied by a growing consciousness of the power of God in our lives and of His desire [00:17:46.924 – 00:17:51.864] for us to keep our feet firmly planted on the ground where our work must be done. [00:17:51.864 – 00:17:59.964] In short, we have found nothing in- incompatible between a powerful spiritual experience and a life of sane and happy usefulness. [00:17:59.964 – 00:18:01.724] Just be patient. [00:18:01.724 – 00:18:11.004] Bill's final advice to the wife facing this kind of challenge is to forgo any opposition to her husband's new spiritual life and simply join him. [00:18:11.004 – 00:18:13.364] It may prove to be the best defense.

[00:18:13.364 – 00:18:23.564] Nothing will help the man who is off on a spiritual tangent so much as the wife who adopts the sel- the self-sane, the self-sane program, making a better practical [00:18:23.564 – 00:18:24.204] use of it. [00:18:24.204 – 00:18:27.584] Eight more changes to face. [00:18:27.584 – 00:18:37.804] In the final third of The Family Afterwards, Bill spends the first 12 paragraphs addressing eight of the other profound changes that the family may face once father has gotten [00:18:37.804 – 00:18:38.284] sober. [00:18:38.284 – 00:18:48.284] Struggles over who now wears the family trousers, and liquor incapacitated father for so many years that mother became head of the family, head of [00:18:48.284 – 00:18:48.684] the house.

[00:18:48.684 – 00:18:52.404] Dad's new outside interest and his resulting absences. [00:18:52.404 – 00:18:55.304] Mother and children may demand that he stay home. [00:18:55.304 – 00:18:59.144] The need to balance alcoholic and non-alcoholic friends. [00:18:59.144 – 00:19:07.144] The couple ought to frankly face the fact that each will have to yield here and there if the family is going to play an effective part in the new life. [00:19:07.144 – 00:19:10.244] The possibility of becoming church members. [00:19:10.244 – 00:19:12.573] A helpful suggestion only. [00:19:12.573 – 00:19:14.184] There's nothing obligatory about it.

[00:19:14.184 – 00:19:16.644] Each individual must consult his own conscience. [00:19:16.644 – 00:19:20.024] The insistence on laughter and enjoying life. [00:19:20.024 – 00:19:22.084] We aren't a glum lot. [00:19:22.084 – 00:19:25.844] We are sure that God wants us to be happy, joyous, and released. [00:19:25.844 – 00:19:28.443] Recovery of bodily health. [00:19:28.443 – 00:19:34.264] We are convinced that a spiritual mode of living is a most powerful health restorative. [00:19:34.264 – 00:19:38.644] But this does not mean that we discourage human health measures.

[00:19:38.644 – 00:19:41.904] The possibility of sexual impotence. [00:19:41.904 – 00:19:47.344] Some of us had this experience, only to enjoy, in a few months, a finer intimacy than ever. [00:19:47.344 – 00:19:51.744] We do not know of any case where this difficulty lasted long. [00:19:51.744 – 00:19:56.424] And finally, the need for dad to reclaim his children's love and respect. [00:19:56.424 – 00:20:02.824] In time, they will see that he is a new man, and when this happens, they can be invited to join in morning meditation. [00:20:02.824 – 00:20:09.444] Additional helpful advice based on a member's past experience is offered for each of these problems. [00:20:09.444 – 00:20:18.844] In summation, W. notes that however the family may respond to the obstacles they meet, the alcoholic must continue to live his own life on a spiritual basis.

[00:20:18.844 – 00:20:24.924] The others m- must be convinced by his changed life beyond a shadow of a doubt. [00:20:24.924 – 00:20:27.204] They must lead the way. [00:20:27.204 – 00:20:30.794] Seeing is believing to most families who have lived with a drinker. [00:20:30.794 – 00:20:33.804] Sobriety is primary. [00:20:33.804 – 00:20:43.144] This might have served as an effective ending for the chapter, but W. is unable to let this stirring conclusion stand on its own. [00:20:43.144 – 00:20:53.144] Instead, he ends with a real-life story that seems strikingly out of place here and sounds contrary to much of what he has just been said, reverting to the tone and tenor of two wives, [00:20:53.144 – 00:20:58.553] and once again emphasizing just how much responsibility the wife bears for her husband's sobriety.

[00:20:58.553 – 00:21:01.044] Here's a case in point. [00:21:01.044 – 00:21:04.624] One of our friends is a heavy smoker and coffee drinker. [00:21:04.624 – 00:21:07.384] There was no doubt he overindulged. [00:21:07.384 – 00:21:12.204] Seeing this and meaning to be helpful, his wife commenced to admonish him about it. [00:21:12.204 – 00:21:17.364] He admitted he was overdoing these things, but frankly said that he was not ready to stop. [00:21:17.364 – 00:21:27.404] His wife is one of those persons who really feel there is something real- rather sinful about these commodities, so she nagged, and her intolerance finally threw him in [00:21:27.404 – 00:21:28.244] a fit of anger.

[00:21:28.244 – 00:21:29.424] He got drunk [00:21:30.832 – 00:21:32.872] Of course, our friend was wrong, dead wrong. [00:21:32.872 – 00:21:37.452] He had a pain- he had to painfully admit that and amend his spiritual offenses. [00:21:37.452 – 00:21:47.592] Though he is now a most effective member of Alcoholics Anonymous, he still smokes cigarettes and drinks coffee, but neither his wife nor anyone else stands in judgment. [00:21:47.592 – 00:21:54.872] She sees she was wrong to make a burning issue out of such a matter when his more serious ailments were being rapidly cured. [00:21:54.872 – 00:21:56.632] First things first. [00:21:56.632 – 00:22:00.492] We have two little mottos which are apropos.

[00:22:00.492 – 00:22:04.952] Here they are: live and let live, and easy does it. [00:22:04.952 – 00:22:15.042] Bill is admonishing that if the wife had only realized that her husband's sobriety was pri- of primary importance, first things first, and therefore allowed him [00:22:15.042 – 00:22:21.572] to continue indulging in his sinful behaviors, live and let live, he would never have gotten drunk again. [00:22:21.572 – 00:22:24.332] Love and tolerance must be the wife's code. [00:22:24.332 – 00:22:30.832] Easy does it, or she will pay the terrible price of finding her husband once more back in the bottle. [00:22:30.832 – 00:22:35.292] The myth of collective authorship. [00:22:35.292 – 00:22:45.812] With six of the 10 general chapters now available in rough format, it might be time to pause and consider one of the most pervasive

[00:22:45.812 – 00:22:54.612] myths in Alcoholics Anonymous, namely that the writing of The Big Book was a completely collaborative affair, the collective work of the first 100 men who got sober. [00:22:54.612 – 00:22:58.952] But that was certainly not true at this point of the story. [00:22:58.952 – 00:23:09.052] By the time we have completed the first draft of the family afterwards, Bill W. had single-handedly written more than half of what eventually make up the front portion of the book, and he had [00:23:09.052 – 00:23:14.652] done so with little or no substantive input from members of the fellowship other than Hank P.'s. [00:23:14.652 – 00:23:24.852] Recapping what we have already seen from contemporary records, Akron's respri- response right up into the middle of November was simply to say that they liked [00:23:24.852 – 00:23:26.692] the six chapters already sent to them. [00:23:26.692 – 00:23:31.372] Given this disappointing lack of response, Bill complained to Dr.

[00:23:31.372 – 00:23:41.411] Bob that he wished he would be more critical of them, for I think they can be improved a lot, and he elsewhere noted that despite the fact that each of these chapters was sent to Ohio, quote, "for debate [00:23:41.412 – 00:23:42.972] and inspection," end quote, Dr. [00:23:42.972 – 00:23:49.352] Bob, quote, "never passed them around very much, merely writing me saying he thought they were all right," end quote. [00:23:49.352 – 00:23:56.652] In 1957, Bill tried to soften this indictment by, a bit by writing that, quote, "Copies were sent to Dr. [00:23:56.652 – 00:24:02.932] Bob for checking and criticism in Akron where they had nothing but the warmest support," end quote. [00:24:02.932 – 00:24:11.092] A judgment that uses faint praise to veil the fact that Akron may have sent back lots of warm support, but no checking or criticism. [00:24:11.092 – 00:24:20.072] Things in New York were a bit different, but not different enough to generate any kind of serious criticism for what Bill had written so far.

[00:24:20.072 – 00:24:30.172] "I find it pretty hard," he told Bob in early November, "to get people to voice their real opinions, as they are too much afraid of hurting the author's feelings." Whatever reason [00:24:30.172 – 00:24:38.432] there might have been for this New York reticence, the result was that W. was writing in a virtual vacuum with little substantive feedback from the group about what he had written. [00:24:38.432 – 00:24:48.452] Given this overwhelming evidence for W.'s sole authorship of the book up to this point, along with his explicit complaints about the lack of input from others, [00:24:48.452 – 00:24:57.732] it is perfectly reasonable to wonder where this popular and persistent creation story of an elaborate collaborative writing process for the text of The Big Book came from. [00:24:57.732 – 00:25:08.232] No one was more complicit in promoting this collective writing myth than Bill W. himself, who after the book was published, increasingly minimized his own responsibility [00:25:08.232 – 00:25:18.232] for the text and began to actively circulate the fiction that the book had been written by "we of Alcoholics Anonymous." One reason for the du- this duplicity was the [00:25:18.232 – 00:25:28.552] need to bolster the illusion that the book was a report of the collective experience of 100 men and women who have recovered from a singularly hopeless state, rather than being just a condensed

[00:25:28.552 – 00:25:36.372] version of W.'s personal experiences and observations during the first four years of his sobriety, which for the most part is what it was. [00:25:36.372 – 00:25:46.372] The power of communal- of the power of the communal experience rather than that of any one in- individual was increasingly recognized as one of the most important [00:25:46.372 – 00:25:56.392] parts of the message promoted by Alcoholics Anonymous, and it was therefore vitally important that the story of the book's origins be presented as a participatory group effort rather than the [00:25:56.392 – 00:25:57.712] work of just one man. [00:25:57.712 – 00:26:07.512] In addition to that larger par- this larger purpose, Bill had an important personal reason for making light of his authorship of The Big Book. [00:26:07.512 – 00:26:17.652] As the new method of recovery spread across the country, W. grew increasingly uncomfortable with the mantle of sanctity that was constantly being foisted off onto him [00:26:17.652 – 00:26:19.252] by these new groups and members.

[00:26:19.252 – 00:26:29.472] Knowing how much this kind of hero worship played directly into his desire to be the number one man, Bill realized he needed to put a number of serious checks on his ego, [00:26:29.472 – 00:26:34.612] and one of the ways he did this was to regularly downplay his central importance in the writing of the book. [00:26:34.612 – 00:26:37.552] The role of the New York group. [00:26:37.552 – 00:26:47.652] When talking about the time The Big Book was written, Bill consistently minimized his own part by offering some variation on the fact [00:26:47.652 – 00:26:52.602] that every paragraph of the book originally dictated was torn to shreds and put back toge- [00:26:52.720 – 00:26:54.700] Again, by the members of the New York group. [00:26:54.700 – 00:26:59.580] "We fought, bled, and died our way through one chapter after another," he claimed.

[00:26:59.580 – 00:27:09.480] Emphasizing the early origins of this process, W. later wrote about how the hassling over the four chapters already finished had been really terrific. [00:27:09.480 – 00:27:11.000] "I was exhausted. [00:27:11.000 – 00:27:14.860] On many a day I felt like throwing the book out the window." Footnote. [00:27:14.860 – 00:27:21.840] Riley, where are you? [00:27:21.840 – 00:27:29.580] Riley? [00:27:29.580 – 00:27:31.840] You need to unmute. [00:27:31.840 – 00:27:35.520] There you go, Riley.

[00:27:35.520 – 00:27:40.440] Well, I'll read it, Riley. [00:27:40.440 – 00:27:50.080] Bill, Bill mistakenly implies here that How It W. was written immediately after the four chapters that precede it in the published version of the book. [00:27:50.080 – 00:27:59.840] Jim B., the only other attendee to leave a record of these chapter-by-chapter review meetings, always told a similar story. [00:27:59.840 – 00:28:09.680] Reporting, for instance, that Bill would take one copy of each new chapter to the Tuesday night meeting, and he would read it over, and we would chop it apart, w- give our suggestions. [00:28:09.680 – 00:28:14.640] After work, after which W. would make notes in the margin with the changes he would need to make. [00:28:14.640 – 00:28:15.660] Footnote. [00:28:15.660 – 00:28:17.740] Here I am, yeah.

[00:28:17.740 – 00:28:27.780] In this same talk, Jim also erroneously claimed that Akron did the same thing, that is made notes for corrections in the margins of the copies that Bill [00:28:27.780 – 00:28:35.940] sent to them, and then mailed these back to New York, where the original and these two sets of suggested changes were brought together by Bill. [00:28:35.940 – 00:28:46.320] Based on contrary evidence from both contemporary sources and several of Bill W.'s later accounts, B.'s report of detailed [00:28:46.320 – 00:28:56.580] annotated critiques of each chapter coming back from Ohio is just another piece of blatantly bad information that must be added to his already [00:28:56.580 – 00:28:59.560] long list of gross inaccuracies. [00:28:59.560 – 00:29:03.029] How then can th- Here you go. [00:29:03.029 – 00:29:11.020] How then can this frequently presented picture of exhaustive substantive editing of the six earliest chapters be squared with Bill's complaint to Dr.

[00:29:11.020 – 00:29:19.600] Bob in early November that he found it pretty hard to get people in New York to voice their real opinion because they are too much afraid of hurting the author's feelings? [00:29:19.600 – 00:29:20.920] It can't. [00:29:20.920 – 00:29:30.939] The stories Bill and Jim told after the fact were the ones that created the mythology of how the Big Book was written, but those stories are overwhelmingly contradicted by [00:29:30.940 – 00:29:32.060] contemporary records. [00:29:32.060 – 00:29:42.120] While there was some group criticism later on, and it was not ha- but, uh, it was not happening at this stage of the writing process, no matter what W. or Bill [00:29:42.120 – 00:29:43.260] later said about the matter. [00:29:43.260 – 00:29:51.540] Bill's difficulty in getting people to voice their real opinion about these six chapters was certainly real, and it had several sources.

[00:29:51.540 – 00:30:01.560] One course of the New York members' restraint was the fact that W. was such a dominant force in the weekly Brooklyn meeting where, as he once candidly admitted, admitted, "I did [00:30:01.560 – 00:30:10.800] most of the talking." He was, after all, the founder of the movement, the leader of the group, and the man who was fundamentally responsible for each of these men's sobriety. [00:30:10.800 – 00:30:16.570] Who else was qualified to speak about alcoholism with such conclusive and uncontested authority? [00:30:16.570 – 00:30:27.120] Bill's honest admission of his control over these meetings is consistent with Jim B.'s recollection of how a typical AA meeting operated in New York during 1938. [00:30:27.120 – 00:30:27.620] Footnote. [00:30:27.620 – 00:30:37.660] We can accept B.'s report on these meetings with some measure of credibility because it serves as a second source confirmation [00:30:37.660 – 00:30:42.360] for W.'s own admission that he did most of the talking in New York meetings.

[00:30:42.360 – 00:30:49.880] So according to Jimmy, "There were seven or eight men sitting around in a circle," he said, "and, and Bill W. sat in the center. [00:30:49.880 – 00:30:59.900] He, he would do all the talking, and we would do all the listening and answering the questions because he had all the book sense." Elsewhere, Jim elaborated on this picture by noting that, "It was a [00:30:59.900 – 00:31:07.820] round table discussion with Bill in the center, and everybody was shooting at him and giving what in- and getting what information he had gotten from his books. [00:31:07.820 – 00:31:11.920] We thought he was really a walking encyclopedia on alcohol. [00:31:11.920 – 00:31:22.340] There were only four or five books, and B- Bill had read them all." This hardly sounds like an open forum meeting with multiple opportunities to offer significant criticism [00:31:22.340 – 00:31:28.600] of what the founder had just written on the nature of alcoholism and the problem facing a newly o- a newly sober man. [00:31:28.600 – 00:31:38.760] Another problem with the scenario painted by both W. and B. is the sheer difficulty of having Bill read each new chapter out loud from the only available

[00:31:38.760 – 00:31:45.980] copy, and then expecting each member to make substantive and helpful critiques, paragraph by paragraph, after he was finished. [00:31:45.980 – 00:31:50.300] It is worthwhile to pause and think about exactly how this might have worked. [00:31:50.300 – 00:31:56.020] Did the members make notes about what they thought could or should be changed as Bill read? [00:31:56.020 – 00:32:02.360] Or did they rely on their memories to recall those things that needed improvement, bring them up individually once he had finished reading? [00:32:02.360 – 00:32:09.800] Or, or did they just interrupt W. as he was, uh, going along, stopping him whenever they heard something objectionable or they thought needed to be changed? [00:32:09.800 – 00:32:15.010] It is, quite frankly, hard to imagine any of these scenarios being the least bit plausible or- [00:32:15.328 – 00:32:18.468] More fruitful given the known dynamics of the Brooklyn meeting.

[00:32:18.468 – 00:32:22.428] And finally, how much did they really care? [00:32:22.428 – 00:32:30.928] Were they so concerned about Bill W. had written that they were willing to openly challenge him on any of these seemingly incidental issues? [00:32:30.928 – 00:32:41.328] Everything he had written in the six chap- six chapters up to the family afterwards could be characterized as either a detailed diagnosis of the disease of alcoholism [00:32:41.328 – 00:32:46.608] or a summary of the problems the alcoholic would face in getting and staying sober. [00:32:46.608 – 00:32:56.928] These were, as Bill noted, general chapters covering a wide variety of topics, and it is unlikely that members of the Tuesday night group would find any of this so questionable that they would challenge [00:32:56.928 – 00:33:02.668] the man who was not only their leader, but also the man they readily acknowledged of having the most knowledge of the disease. [00:33:02.668 – 00:33:08.968] The first six chapters probably gener- generated little more criticism in New York than they did out in Ohio.

[00:33:08.968 – 00:33:18.068] Bill's comprehensive explanation of the alcoholic's problem just wasn't controversial enough to generate critical attacks from these New York members. [00:33:18.068 – 00:33:28.068] Whatever group criticism he did receive, which W. claims he had been looking for all along, did not begin in earnest until December when he rolled out two [00:33:28.068 – 00:33:35.648] new chapters, How It W. and In A., with the 12 steps, his numbered solution to the alcoholic's problems. [00:33:35.648 – 00:33:42.548] Bill's concise articulation of what must be done to get and stay sober was something the New York members were willing to argue about. [00:33:42.548 – 00:33:52.648] Whatever truth there may be in the supposed real mauling given to every paragraph by the New York contingent, it would have to wait for the appearance of these chapters containing the 12 [00:33:52.648 – 00:33:57.828] steps, along with W.'s detailed instructions on how to go about applying them to your life. [00:33:57.828 – 00:34:07.408] But even here, as we shall see later, the group was not the main source of this criticism, nor did most of it come during the Tuesday night meeting.

[00:34:07.408 – 00:34:17.448] Hank P., along with, to a lesser degree, F., were the primary critics, and their objections or suggestions for changes occurred in private discussions [00:34:17.448 – 00:34:25.168] with Bill, most surely in Brooklyn, but most, but most in the Nor- Nor- Newark O. of Honor D.. [00:34:25.168 – 00:34:33.228] Other than this, there is no credible evidence for any such significant participatory group criticism of what W. had so far written for the book. [00:34:33.228 – 00:34:36.948] Input three months before printing. [00:34:36.948 – 00:34:47.428] However, there is one plausible scenario for some plausible scenario for some significant group input that may have been at work before mid-November [00:34:47.428 – 00:34:54.068] and was part of the review process during the final three months before the multi-lith copy was printed in mid-February 1939. [00:34:54.068 – 00:35:04.208] Bill W.'s statement about the difficulty of getting people in New York to offer their real opinion does not necessarily mean there was absolutely no suggestions for changes during these final

[00:35:04.208 – 00:35:06.328] months as the book moved towards completion. [00:35:06.328 – 00:35:16.548] Given B.'s specific claim that there were no S. criticisms that might hurt the author's feelings being voiced at this time, we can be fairly confident [00:35:16.548 – 00:35:26.578] that no one was standing up in the Tuesday night meeting saying things like, "Bill, that's, that's just wrong," or, "But you can't say that," or even the less personal, "So, so what is that supposed [00:35:26.578 – 00:35:37.048] to mean?" But this does not preclude the possibility that people would listen attentively to Bill W. read each new chapter and then offer thoughtful suggestions for additional [00:35:37.048 – 00:35:39.608] material that might be added to what he- they had just heard. [00:35:39.608 – 00:35:50.028] Given B.'s stature and recognized primacy within the N- Brooklyn group, this scenario presents a much more believable picture of how the editing process may have actually operated [00:35:50.028 – 00:35:52.208] in New York City in late 1938.

[00:35:52.208 – 00:36:02.408] Rather than a free-for-all in which each paragraph was violently pulled apart and suggestions added by all those present, readings most likely concluded [00:36:02.408 – 00:36:12.448] with one or more members making an observation all along the lines of, "Hey, hey, Bill, how come you didn't say anything about X, Y, or Z in there?" Or, "You know what else [00:36:12.448 – 00:36:22.448] might fit into this chapter?" This easier, softer way of reviewing the chapters and respectfully offering suggestions for additional text would have avoided hurting the [00:36:22.448 – 00:36:29.048] author's feeling while still allowing members to make reasonable contributions to the growing, to the rapidly growing text. [00:36:29.048 – 00:36:39.068] Because we have neither the once corrected dictations mailed to Akron in September and November, nor any of the interim versions between [00:36:39.068 – 00:36:48.348] then and the following February, it's impossible to say exactly when the New York group might have started offering these kind of recommendations and requests for additional material. [00:36:48.348 – 00:36:58.408] In early November, when W. bemoaned the lack of significant input, he may have been specifically referring to criticism of what he had already written rather than these

[00:36:58.408 – 00:37:00.348] sorts of suggested additions. [00:37:00.348 – 00:37:09.568] But as noted above, if this less critical add-on process was not operative before mid-November, it did come into play sometime soon after that. [00:37:09.568 – 00:37:19.668] The notion that the New York input was more about adding material than criticizing what had already been written is supported by a careful reading of the text in these [00:37:19.668 – 00:37:21.918] earliest chapters, earlier chapters. [00:37:21.918 – 00:37:31.968] For instance, there are a number of places in the three chapters just considered where paragraphs or sections seem to have been tacked on or feathered into the chapter Bill was reading to the group [00:37:31.968 – 00:37:32.888] on Tuesday night. [00:37:32.888 – 00:37:37.637] These suspected add-ons stand out as abrupt and unexpected changes in-

[00:37:37.736 – 00:37:38.116] Direction. [00:37:38.116 – 00:37:47.536] At times almost non sequiturs, or because they sound more like a misplaced afterthought rather than a logical extension of what comes immediately before it. [00:37:47.536 – 00:37:57.806] Consider, for example, the final 11 paragraphs of Working W. Others, which shifts the chapter's perspective from detailed instructions on how to properly [00:37:57.806 – 00:38:08.096] deliver the message of recovery to a man, a new man, and suddenly begins to extol the benefits that come to the sober man who is now spiritually fit, elaborating on the fact that he can [00:38:08.096 – 00:38:11.296] do all sorts of things alcoholics are not supposed to do. [00:38:11.296 – 00:38:21.356] As noted earlier, the purpose of this section is to differentiate the sober out AA members from all of the noisy temperance and prohibition preachers that have preceded him, [00:38:21.356 – 00:38:31.396] and to detail the many strengths and opportunities availa- available to him now that he has God on his side, keeping him safe from the first drink, even in a

[00:38:31.396 – 00:38:34.216] variety of pre- previously dangerous situations. [00:38:34.216 – 00:38:44.556] While it may have been W- W.'s original plan to have a section such as this close the chapter, the subject matter shifts so dramatically from the presentation [00:38:44.556 – 00:38:54.016] to the presenter, all but abandoning the topic of working with others, that it sounds distinctly like something added later. [00:38:54.016 – 00:39:04.016] The shift here may be because Bill couldn't think of a more effective close for Working W. Others, but it's just as likely that it appears here because someone suggested this type of [00:39:04.016 – 00:39:08.636] information should be included somewhere in this chapter, so W. just added it in at the end. [00:39:08.636 – 00:39:18.676] The same premise might explain the inc- the inclusion of those two strident paragraphs that appear so abruptly just before the conciliatory conclusion [00:39:18.676 – 00:39:19.436] of Two W..

[00:39:19.436 – 00:39:29.916] The "even your hatred must go" paragraph just doesn't flow logically from the talk of spirituality that immediately precedes it, and this is followed by an even more abrasive [00:39:29.916 – 00:39:33.716] admonition to never, never try to arrange his life. [00:39:33.716 – 00:39:43.816] Both of these paragraphs so- show a significant shift in tone, and seem distinctly out of place in relation to what the wife has just been told, making it probable they [00:39:43.816 – 00:39:53.816] were written after the fact and then dropped in here to satisfy the suggestions that the closing needed to be much more forceful, dramatic, and explicit if it, if it was ever going to make [00:39:53.816 – 00:39:55.896] the real, make a real impression on the wife. [00:39:55.896 – 00:40:05.916] Similarly, The Family Afterwards ends with the unfortunate case in point story of the man who drinks after being nagged by his wife about his sinful [00:40:05.916 – 00:40:08.096] overindulgence in cigarettes and coffee.

[00:40:08.096 – 00:40:18.296] How this story relates to what immediately precedes it, the well-organized and detailed explanation of eight profound changes that can be anticipated when a man first [00:40:18.296 – 00:40:20.536] gets sober, is something of a mystery. [00:40:20.536 – 00:40:26.436] Most likely it was W.'s response to some New Y. insisting that this instructive story be included. [00:40:26.436 – 00:40:34.176] Each of these examples displays a sudden change of direction, disrupting the logic and the flow of what came before it. [00:40:34.176 – 00:40:42.116] Readers confronted with this kind of jumbled presentation in the Big Book frequently conclude that Bill W. just wasn't a very good writer. [00:40:42.116 – 00:40:50.936] But perhaps the fault lies less in the lack of writing skills on the part of the book's primary author, and more on the much touted collaborative creation process of the Big Book. [00:40:50.936 – 00:40:55.236] Hank P.'s contributions.

[00:40:55.236 – 00:40:59.886] Hank P.'s was, however, another story completely. [00:40:59.886 – 00:41:06.376] Unlike the other New York members, Hank did not have to wait until Tuesday night for a first look at what Bill W. was writing. [00:41:06.376 – 00:41:15.636] He was sitting right there in the small Honor D.' Newark office, listening, criticizing, and offering his opinion as Bill and Ruth created first drafts of each new chapter. [00:41:15.636 – 00:41:25.776] Ruth tells us Bill would arrive at the office with yellow scratch pad sheets, with a few notes to guide him on the whole chapter, and that these notes were the result of long [00:41:25.776 – 00:41:30.136] thought on his part after hours of discussion pro and con with everyone who might be interested. [00:41:30.136 – 00:41:40.396] Ruth's choice of words here about Bill consulting with everyone who might be interested is worth noting, because it's probable, uh, it provides at least some evidence [00:41:40.396 – 00:41:48.016] that not everyone was interested in talking about the book, at least not all in relation to these early six chapters.

[00:41:48.016 – 00:41:58.036] Having arrived in Newark with these few notes in hand, it's hard to believe Will, Bill would, or even could, have avoided a discussion with Hank about them before he began dictating to Ruth, [00:41:58.036 – 00:42:03.956] who besides W. himself was more interested in what was going into each new chapter of the book than Parker's. [00:42:03.956 – 00:42:13.996] Hank was genuinely passionate about the contents of the book, and deeply committed to creating something that would effectively present their message of recovery to the world, and do so [00:42:13.996 – 00:42:17.096] in such a way that the book would become an instant bestseller. [00:42:17.096 – 00:42:26.836] His own financial future, and the all-important ability of Alcoholics Anonymous to become self-supporting through large sales of the book absolutely depended on it. [00:42:26.836 – 00:42:37.556] Parker's was the person closest to W. as he composed these critical first dictations, a fact that Bill later free- frequently, freely acknowledged, [00:42:37.556 – 00:42:45.216] calling Hank his partner in the book enterprise, a partnership that was not limited to their mutual involvement in the business side of the project.

[00:42:45.216 – 00:42:55.536] Parker's continual presence during the actual writing of the book in Newark provides him with the more chances to influence W. than anyone else in the fellowship, and he seized that opportunity [00:42:55.536 – 00:42:58.596] by arguing with Bill for his own particular point of view on recovery. [00:42:58.596 – 00:43:00.126] And we have seen- [00:43:00.712 – 00:43:03.472] Parker's was never bashful about offering his own thoughts. [00:43:03.472 – 00:43:13.612] On the all-important talk on of what should go into the book he wanted, he wasted no time in emphatically a- advocating for his own perspective, first by submitting his contrary [00:43:13.612 – 00:43:19.392] ideas to Bill in early June, and then by creating his prophetic outline for the book a couple of weeks later. [00:43:19.392 – 00:43:24.572] A lively dialogue between the two, two men surely continued over the next three months.

[00:43:24.572 – 00:43:34.152] But when Bill finally returned to writing the book in mid-September, Hank was given the golden opportunity of speaking his mind with specific regularity. [00:43:34.152 – 00:43:43.592] Beyond B.'s own testimony, the fact that Hank made substantive contributions to the book is confirmed by Ruth H., the only other person who was an eyewitness to this process. [00:43:43.592 – 00:43:53.592] When specifically asked about Parker's input, she readily admitted he was present throughout the Newor- Newark writing period, and claimed that he contributed a lot of ideas [00:43:53.592 – 00:44:03.072] to the book, and then added emphatically, "He really did." However, Bill was not very receptive to most of Hank's comments and suggestions. [00:44:03.072 – 00:44:07.692] Beyond the running argument over content, style was also an issue. [00:44:07.692 – 00:44:15.652] As noted earlier, Hank had recently taken a writing school course, after which he was constantly advising Bill how to improve his prose style. [00:44:15.652 – 00:44:25.552] These suggestions did not sit particularly well with W., who later noted rather bluntly that he regarded that, that in this regard, he didn't go for Hank's advice very much.

[00:44:25.552 – 00:44:29.231] Hank loses the God argument. [00:44:29.231 – 00:44:36.032] But much more confrontational were Parker's contrary opinions about what should and should not be going into the book. [00:44:36.032 – 00:44:40.572] He had S. convictions that W. had been unable to change over the past several months. [00:44:40.572 – 00:44:50.632] For example, Hank was still opposed to the S. religious slant Bill was giving to their solution, and he continued to advocate for his June position that religion, et cetera, [00:44:50.632 – 00:44:54.452] should not be brought into the picture when describing their method for getting sober. [00:44:54.452 – 00:45:03.032] W. claims that during this early period, Parker even went so far as to dema- to demand the word God be deleted from the book entirely. [00:45:03.032 – 00:45:09.432] It's hard to imagine a position any farther from what Bill was then writing for the Big Book.

[00:45:09.432 – 00:45:19.432] But Hank decisively lost that argument, and he clearly did so early on, as can be seen from even a cursory reading of the first six chapters so far written. [00:45:19.432 – 00:45:29.432] A quick search of those chapters, as printed on just 39 pages of the Mulvihill copy, finds 69 instances of the word God, and that does not take [00:45:29.432 – 00:45:38.322] into account any of the references to the divine He or Him, nor to any of the other names for the providential deity that appear so frequently in these pages. [00:45:38.322 – 00:45:48.432] Given the ubiquity of the word God, and the similar, and similarly regular references to the Supreme B., it is hard to imagine Bill made any effort at all to tone [00:45:48.432 – 00:45:53.172] down the number of explicit references to God in response to Hank's criticisms. [00:45:53.172 – 00:46:03.612] On this issue, he completely dismissed Hank's arguments for a purely irreligious approach, and remained faithful to his original plan of presenting a basically religious [00:46:03.612 – 00:46:05.612] solution to the problem of alcoholism.

[00:46:05.612 – 00:46:15.932] As with Parker's critical comments about his writing style, obvi- Bill obviously didn't go for Hank's advice very much when it came to his suggestion for a basically non-religious [00:46:15.932 – 00:46:17.592] approach. [00:46:17.592 – 00:46:20.992] God plus moral psychology. [00:46:20.992 – 00:46:31.052] In opposition to Bill's S. emphasis on God, Hank had lobbied for a purely psychological explanation of their solution, one that was firmly based on the moral [00:46:31.052 – 00:46:35.512] psychology of ego reduction and a life of increased usefulness to others. [00:46:35.512 – 00:46:40.052] "We are actually irreligious," he said, "but we are trying to be helpful. [00:46:40.052 – 00:46:48.392] We have learned to be quiet, to be more truthful, to be more honest, to, to try to be more unselfish, to make the other fellow's troubles our troubles.

[00:46:48.392 – 00:46:52.892] And by following four steps, we most of us have a re- have a religious experience. [00:46:52.892 – 00:47:00.952] The fellowship, the unselfishness appeals to us." Bill actually agreed with most of this, recognizing Dr. [00:47:00.952 – 00:47:06.512] S.'s ideas on moral psychology as a critical element in any meaningful and sustained recovery. [00:47:06.512 – 00:47:13.252] But he didn't feel it was sufficient by itself for keeping anyone so- for keeping someone sober. [00:47:13.252 – 00:47:23.472] W.'s model for gaining and maintaining society was a much more balanced approach, incorporating spiritual, psychological, and physical parts, but with the greatest emphasis being placed [00:47:23.472 – 00:47:24.792] firmly on the spiritual. [00:47:24.792 – 00:47:34.832] Still, his agreement with the real need for ego reduction and a life of redirected, and a life firmly, and a life di- redirected towards usefulness to others made it easy

[00:47:34.832 – 00:47:39.572] for Bill to include any number of references to the importance of moral psychology in what he wrote. [00:47:39.572 – 00:47:46.732] Noting in just one dramatic example that the recovered man's main job was to be of maximum helpfulness to others. [00:47:46.732 – 00:47:56.822] Beyond frequent references throughout these six chapters to the need to get outside of oneself and to become a useful participant of society, one chapter, Working [00:47:56.822 – 00:48:02.112] With Others, was devotus- was devoted almost exclusively to usefulness and little else. [00:48:02.112 – 00:48:12.112] Under these circumstances, it's impossible to say how much of the moral psychology and the regular emphasis on usefulness to others found in Bill W.'s [00:48:12.112 – 00:48:14.432] writing should be credited to Hank P.'s. [00:48:14.432 – 00:48:22.522] But with Bill's lavis- lavish inclusion of Hank's beloved psychological and altruistic elements in the text, it would-

[00:48:22.800 – 00:48:28.560] It would hardly be fair to say that P. lost all of his arguments with W. about the content and the tone of the Big Book. [00:48:28.560 – 00:48:38.720] Bill was willing to emphasize the psychological aspect Hank considered so singularly important, agreeing that it was indispensable for recovery, but he just wasn't willing to abandon [00:48:38.720 – 00:48:46.420] his belief in the central importance of religion, or to remove the constant mentions of God as a critical and essential element of that solution. [00:48:46.420 – 00:48:56.680] In the end, Bill clung to these spiritual elements, but he did blend them with a psychological solution that can be found so gene- generously sprinkled throughout each of the chapters he wrote. [00:48:56.680 – 00:49:06.440] With this fundamental de- disagreement raging between them, these ongoing arguments could not have been easy for either, either man to navigate. [00:49:06.440 – 00:49:12.540] The Honor Dealers office in Newark became the battleground where the biggest fights over the Big Book were actually waged. [00:49:12.540 – 00:49:22.680] More than in meetings, this is certainly the place where Bill W. and Hank P., quote, "Fought, bled and died their way through one chapter after another," end quote, and perhaps

[00:49:22.680 – 00:49:28.780] even where, quote, "Every paragraph in that book as originally dictated was torn in shreds and put back again," end quote. [00:49:28.780 – 00:49:36.090] Hank was that sort of combative guy, and he was hardly likely to restrain himself for fear of hurting the author's feelings. [00:49:36.090 – 00:49:46.460] Within the confines of their small office, the outright rejection of both his stylistic suggestions and his exclusively non-religious solution must have caused more than a little anguish. [00:49:46.460 – 00:49:56.540] Under these circumstances, it is not hard to imagine why Bill later claimed that, "On many a day I felt like throwing the book out the window," and perhaps Henry G. [00:49:56.540 – 00:49:57.940] P. along with it. [00:49:57.940 – 00:50:00.940] But Hank was nothing if not tenacious. [00:50:00.940 – 00:50:11.000] Despite the fact that Bill consistently ignored so many of his ideas, P. would continue to fight for the inclusion of his own perspective and presentation, wherever they might fit in, right up until

[00:50:11.000 – 00:50:13.860] the final hours before the book actually went to press. [00:50:13.860 – 00:50:17.400] Addressing marital infidelity. [00:50:17.400 – 00:50:27.420] Besides the three suspicious tacked on endings already mentioned, there are several other places where paragraphs appear to have been incorporated into what was [00:50:27.420 – 00:50:28.780] already written for the Big Book. [00:50:28.780 – 00:50:35.820] One further example found in the Family afterwards should be mentioned in this regard for its multifaceted importance. [00:50:35.820 – 00:50:46.280] In that chapter, Bill says that sober members and their wives who have wrestled with marital problems should be only too willing to bring forward mistakes, [00:50:46.280 – 00:50:51.180] no matter how grievous, out of their hiding places, and to share them with the new members and his wife.

[00:50:51.180 – 00:51:01.590] These revelations, along with the story of their successful resol- resolution, are essential for showing newcomers how they too can gain victory over such terrible family problems. [00:51:01.590 – 00:51:11.620] However difficult and counterintuitive it may sound, counterintuitive it may sound, W. encourages sober members to speak openly and candidly [00:51:11.620 – 00:51:22.260] with others about these delicate family matters because in God's hand, the dark past is our greatest poss- is the greatest possession you have, the key to life and happiness for others. [00:51:22.260 – 00:51:26.380] With it, you can avert death and misery for them. [00:51:26.380 – 00:51:36.440] Skipping the next paragraph for a moment, Bill opens the following paragraph by noting that AAs have few secrets and that everyone knows all about [00:51:36.440 – 00:51:42.960] everyone else, an observation that flows smoothly and logically from the dark past is the greatest possession you have comment just noted. [00:51:42.960 – 00:51:53.350] It continues the thought and fits perfectly into the point Bill is trying to make about the need for group members to be open and candid with each other, up to and including the sharing of their darkest secrets.

[00:51:53.350 – 00:52:02.400] Complete openness and honesty about past family difficulties is, he says, one of the important and critical ways we can be truly useful and helpful to each other. [00:52:02.400 – 00:52:11.460] However, sandwiched between these two paragraphs, there is another that takes a sudden and unexpected turn into the question of marital infidelity. [00:52:11.460 – 00:52:17.720] It is possible to dig up past misdeeds so they become a blight, a veritable plague. [00:52:17.720 – 00:52:23.580] For example, we know of solutions in which the alcoholic or his wife have had love affairs. [00:52:23.580 – 00:52:29.140] In the first flush of spiritual experience, they forgive each other and dra- and drew closer together. [00:52:29.140 – 00:52:32.400] The miracle of re- reconciliation was at hand. [00:52:32.400 – 00:52:40.880] Then under one provocation or another, the aggrieved one would unearth the old affair and angrily, angrily cast its ashes about.

[00:52:40.880 – 00:52:45.060] A few of us have had these growing pains and they have hurt a great deal. [00:52:45.060 – 00:52:53.900] Husbands and wives have sometime been o- obligated to separate for a time until new, uh, m- till new perspective, new victory over hurt pride could be re-won. [00:52:53.900 – 00:53:00.340] In most cases, the alcoholics survived this ordeal without relapse, but not always. [00:53:00.340 – 00:53:06.860] So our rule is that unless some good and useful purpose is to be served, past occurrences are not discussed. [00:53:06.860 – 00:53:15.440] This small self-contained side trip is directly contrary to the prior advice of being candid about the dark past. [00:53:15.440 – 00:53:25.560] It abruptly interrupts the argument being made about the necessity of talking openly about difficult family problems within the group, and introduces an entirely different scenario, [00:53:25.560 – 00:53:31.000] the question of how to talk or not talk with your spouse about past marital infidelities.

[00:53:31.000 – 00:53:41.100] This is certainly important information, but it is distracting to Bill's point about one couple helping another, and it really does not fit in here, although it might be [00:53:41.100 – 00:53:45.200] good as any other pl- it, it might be as good as any other place to drop this delicate [00:53:45.448 – 00:53:46.628] subject into the chapter. [00:53:46.628 – 00:53:56.848] The question on how to deal with the admit- admission of past infidelities or the revelation of details should those infidelities already be known is certainly a common [00:53:56.848 – 00:54:01.467] problem with many newly sober men, and it is mentioned several times in the Big Book. [00:54:01.467 – 00:54:04.808] This being perhaps the most direct and explicit. [00:54:04.808 – 00:54:13.988] As a caution to the new man, it makes sense that this point should be made somewhere in this discussion, but its appearance here is more of a distracting aside than an element to Bill's main point.

[00:54:13.988 – 00:54:24.048] It's almost as if someone had said, "Hey, listen, Bill, if you're gonna talk about couples making re- revelations about the dark past, then you had better make sure people understand you're not [00:54:24.048 – 00:54:27.788] talking about that part of the dark past," and W. complied. [00:54:27.788 – 00:54:37.988] If this plausible, if this explanation is as plausible as it seems, then the next question would be who or what might have prompted [00:54:37.988 – 00:54:38.808] this insertion? [00:54:38.808 – 00:54:47.628] The suggestion may well have come from someone at the Tuesday meeting making a comment similar to the one noted above, but there are a number of other possible candidates. [00:54:47.628 – 00:54:50.788] Bill's sexual past a factor? [00:54:50.788 – 00:54:57.468] For instance, Bill W. himself may have decided after the fact that just such a paragraph was needed here.

[00:54:57.468 – 00:55:00.168] Certainly, he was no stranger to the problem. [00:55:00.168 – 00:55:09.268] The question of his own possible infidelities while drinking was one he had addressed, however circumspectly, in each of the three versions of Bill's story. [00:55:09.268 – 00:55:11.488] And now we have three different versions. [00:55:11.488 – 00:55:20.048] "Though I managed to avoid serious scrapes, and partly out of extreme drunkenness, I had not become involved with the fair sex. [00:55:20.048 – 00:55:24.968] There were many unhappy scenes in my apartment." That's from the original story version. [00:55:24.968 – 00:55:29.708] Then the next version is, "There were many unhappy scenes in our apartment. [00:55:29.708 – 00:55:32.268] There had been no great infidelity.

[00:55:32.268 – 00:55:39.968] Loyalty to my wife and sometimes extreme drunkenness kept me out of those scrapes." That's from the May/June 1938 version. [00:55:39.968 – 00:55:45.668] And then in the Multilith version it said, "There were many unhappy scenes in our sumptuous apartment. [00:55:45.668 – 00:55:55.808] There had been no real infidelity, for loyalty to my wife, helped at times by extreme drunkenness, kept me out of those scrapes." There is an interesting progression here [00:55:55.808 – 00:56:05.908] from extreme drunkenness being partly the reason for not becoming involved with other w- women, to indulging in no great infidelity out of loyalty to Lois, and [00:56:05.908 – 00:56:12.448] sometimes extreme drunkenness, to no real infidelity because of loyalty, and at times extreme drunkenness. [00:56:12.448 – 00:56:22.308] Whatever indiscretions may have committed while drinking, he was clearly not about to omit them in print, nor is it likely he ever made any admission of guilt beyond this when talking to his wife, Lois. [00:56:22.308 – 00:56:32.748] Still, the careful reader has to wonder just how far a potential relationship would have to go before extreme drunkenness, that is, either passing out or impotence,

[00:56:32.748 – 00:56:37.208] becomes the saving factor, preventing the betrayal of one's marriage vows. [00:56:37.208 – 00:56:47.248] It is equally interesting to speculate on exactly what kind of behavior short of intercourse, or even including intercourse, might still allow the claim of no [00:56:47.248 – 00:56:52.827] great infidelity or no real infidelity in the mind of a 1938 American male. [00:56:52.827 – 00:56:58.768] One must wonder, too, about Lois' reaction when she first read each of these different versions. [00:56:58.768 – 00:57:08.918] But whatever stories Bill had been telling Lois about his relationships with other women during his drunken years, she was clearly not buying it, for in each of these stories there is only [00:57:08.918 – 00:57:18.368] one phrase that repeats in each of these versions, namely the many unhappy scenes that were played out between Bill and Lois at home whenever he finally did get home. [00:57:18.368 – 00:57:28.538] In short, Bill W., if Bill W. had been unfaithful during his drinking years, he was obviously following his own advice about non-disclosure,

[00:57:28.538 – 00:57:32.088] for he clearly never owned or disclosed that behavior to his wife. [00:57:32.088 – 00:57:33.228] Footnote. [00:57:33.228 – 00:57:40.818] This brings up a question that's outside the scope of this study, but certainly relevant to these comments. [00:57:40.818 – 00:57:50.838] Namely, the persistent AA rumor that in his later years Bill W. was a serial adulterer, or as Susan C. would have it in [00:57:50.838 – 00:57:53.748] her book, My N. Is B., a sex addict. [00:57:53.748 – 00:58:02.827] Despite the frequency with which this story has been retold by AA people who are critical of Bill, the claim has never been verified. [00:58:02.827 – 00:58:12.828] AA's preeminent professional historian, Ernie K., was intrigued by the persistence of these rumors, and he spent considerable time and

[00:58:12.828 – 00:58:20.008] effort during the last few years of his life trying to determine the truth or falsity of these allegations. [00:58:20.008 – 00:58:30.128] Drawing on his close ties with other students of AA history, and speaking directly with both Cheever and Francis T., two writers who had made [00:58:30.128 – 00:58:40.428] accusations a- along these lines, Kurtz determined that in every instance he could find and trace back the source for the stories of Bill's serial [00:58:40.428 – 00:58:46.518] infidelities, it relied on the testimony of just one man, Tom P.. [00:58:46.518 – 00:58:56.628] Powers had been a close friend of W.'s during s- the 1940s and 1950s, but in the mid-'50s they had a tumultuous falling out, [00:58:56.628 – 00:59:03.748] and it was then that he began spreading stories about Bill's repeated illicit sexual conduct. [00:59:03.748 – 00:59:07.638] Kurtz was significantly skeptical about the-

[00:59:08.096 – 00:59:18.446] these accusations because, as he noted in a recorded interview made on October 22nd, 2013, Powers had offered this as an item of his knowledge, [00:59:18.446 – 00:59:22.256] but there is no evidence beyond that for W.'s misbehavior. [00:59:22.256 – 00:59:32.456] Kurtz believed that if Bill had been as indiscriminate and flagrant in his behavior as Powers alleged, then there would certainly be other sources [00:59:32.456 – 00:59:34.916] willing and able to provide supporting evidence. [00:59:34.916 – 00:59:45.016] Now, this in- interview, Ernest K.: A Reverence F. History, can be streamed from the home page of Page 124 Production, [00:59:45.016 – 00:59:48.536] and there's a UL- URL to, uh, follow that link. [00:59:48.536 – 00:59:58.716] The quote here is from a section entitled The Gold Standard: Two I. Sources, which begins at minute 14,

[00:59:58.716 – 01:00:00.116] uh, 53. [01:00:00.116 – 01:00:10.456] This lack of a second source does not, of course, disprove these rumors, but it should give one significant pause before wholeheartedly [01:00:10.456 – 01:00:11.316] believing them. [01:00:11.316 – 01:00:14.556] That was certainly Ernest K.'s conclusion. [01:00:14.556 – 01:00:24.736] Note, that none of this is meant to deny the fact that Bill W. did have a long-term extramarital affair with Helen W. in the closing [01:00:24.736 – 01:00:25.976] decades of his life. [01:00:25.976 – 01:00:36.236] See the sensitive but candid treatment of this topic in the documentary film, Bill W., released by Page 124 Productions in

[01:00:36.236 – 01:00:36.996] 2012. [01:00:36.996 – 01:00:45.396] Ruth and Hank have a vested interest in this topic. [01:00:45.396 – 01:00:55.536] Another possible candidate is Ruth H., who had taken a semester-long short story writing course at NYU, along with Hank P.- P. around this time. [01:00:55.536 – 01:01:02.156] Having done so, she may have naturally felt qualified to offer comments and suggestions to Bill W. as he wrote. [01:01:02.156 – 01:01:09.816] Actually, it would be hard to imagine her not doing this to some degree throughout the freeform writing process in which she played such a prominent role. [01:01:09.816 – 01:01:18.916] The question of whether or not to discuss past indiscretions was certainly something that Ruth had heard more than a, a little office talk about over the years. [01:01:18.916 – 01:01:28.936] In fact, 40 years later, she was still able to recount one har- harrowing Oxford Group story she had overheard about the pitfalls, the real pitfalls inherent in

[01:01:28.936 – 01:01:30.436] these delicate situations. [01:01:30.436 – 01:01:40.716] One of the Oxford Group's basic tenets was that if you had ever, ever harmed anyone, anyone at all in any way, you were to go to that person, [01:01:40.716 – 01:01:42.436] confess everything, and apologize. [01:01:42.436 – 01:01:44.776] Do your best to make it up for whatever happened. [01:01:44.776 – 01:01:52.176] The only trouble Bill found with that was that, and this happened actually twice in the New York area, where a man had done this. [01:01:52.176 – 01:02:01.496] In one case, a man explained to his wife that he'd been unfaithful with this lovely girl who lived right across the street, but it would never happen again, and he was sorry, and so on. [01:02:01.496 – 01:02:05.896] Well, the first thing that happened, of course, overcome the husband of the lovely girl.

[01:02:05.896 – 01:02:12.816] Then this story began to go from whisper to whisper, from one to another, and you don't keep that kind of thing secret. [01:02:12.816 – 01:02:18.056] The min- the minute you spread it in any way, in any way, there was a great deal of trouble about it. [01:02:18.056 – 01:02:24.816] And that's when they began to realize that maybe it wasn't the best thing in the world to be so candid if it hurts the other person. [01:02:24.816 – 01:02:34.825] While the awareness of these Oxford Group feelings may have prompted a suggestion from Ruth about including the cautionary paragraph in The Family Afterwards, there might've been another, [01:02:34.825 – 01:02:40.176] more personal reason for her wanting to plead for secrecy about extramarital affairs to be included in the book. [01:02:40.176 – 01:02:46.616] Hank P. was known to have considerable toble- troubles with marital infidelities throughout his life. [01:02:46.616 – 01:02:56.696] While details about his past and future dalliances are frequently anecdotal, Hank's marriage to Kathleen was deteriorating severely at this time, so much

[01:02:56.696 – 01:03:04.736] so that they would separate several months later, several months after this, and she would successfully file for divorce on September 23rd, 1939. [01:03:04.736 – 01:03:09.976] As L. wrote, "For some time, Hank's marriage had not been going well. [01:03:09.976 – 01:03:19.976] He'd had many arguments with Kathleen, and they were planning to get a divorce." Lois actually, uh, Lois was actually part of that divorce filing, an unexpected thing given [01:03:19.976 – 01:03:22.336] her clo- husband's close relationship with Hank. [01:03:22.336 – 01:03:33.206] But Lois did submit an affidavit at Kathleen's urging, in which she noted, among other things, that Hank had been separated for his wife, from his wife for 10 weeks in early 1939 [01:03:33.206 – 01:03:38.736] and had been living with the W. at 138 Clinton, uh, 182 Clinton S. during that time. [01:03:38.736 – 01:03:40.616] Footnote.

[01:03:40.616 – 01:03:50.656] Merton M., who unearthed these details while writing his Black S. manuscript, admits that there is contradictory information presented in these primary [01:03:50.656 – 01:04:01.016] documents, most especially the fact that Lois's dates don't correspond to Kathleen's sworn statement that they were separated from May 9th, 1939. [01:04:01.016 – 01:04:11.276] This last date is also compromised by other contemporary documents, strongly implying that the Parkhursts did not completely separate until sometime [01:04:11.276 – 01:04:12.576] in June at the earliest. [01:04:12.576 – 01:04:19.376] Of course, all of these ag- al- allegations could be, and most likely are, true. [01:04:19.376 – 01:04:24.036] The end of a marriage is rarely a neat and tidy affair. [01:04:24.036 – 01:04:30.256] As H. atten- Hank's attention wandered from Kathle-

[01:04:31.054 – 01:04:35.424] he began to focus more and more on his own secretary, the very attractive Ruth H.. [01:04:35.424 – 01:04:45.504] In support of Lois' story about Hank moving in with them for 10 weeks in early 1939, Ruth later claimed that P. had broken up with his [01:04:45.504 – 01:04:54.224] wife just prior to the Cornwell press trip, that would be the final week of March 1939, and soon thereafter began making overtures to me. [01:04:54.224 – 01:05:02.824] This date for the start of their affair is most likely self-serving because Hank had almost certainly been pursuing Ruth for several months at this point. [01:05:02.824 – 01:05:11.764] Lois, for instance, mentions that his marriage had not been going well for some time, implying the affair had been well before the Cornwell trip took, took place. [01:05:11.764 – 01:05:20.264] In addition, Hank being thrown out of his own house in early January would strongly suggest that the affair started some time prior to that. [01:05:20.264 – 01:05:26.764] In this regard, it's important to note that P.'s overtures were not unwelcome at first.

[01:05:26.764 – 01:05:28.804] Ruth was very open to them. [01:05:28.804 – 01:05:38.884] "I thought highly of Hank at one time," she said, "and we were very interested in each other." While the exact date of their affair start w- their, [01:05:38.884 – 01:05:49.564] the exact date their affair started is unknown, Ruth said that throughout this time Hank was just an unhappy man, and as Bill used to say, "When you're unhappy, be careful because you're getting into trouble," [01:05:49.564 – 01:05:52.604] and Hank was doing just that with Ruth H.'s encouragement. [01:05:52.604 – 01:05:55.404] "Hank wanted her to become his wife," she said. [01:05:55.404 – 01:06:00.604] And she can- and she candidly admitted, "I had one time seriously considered marrying him. [01:06:00.604 – 01:06:09.444] But once he started drinking again, marriage became an impossible thing for us," and the entire affair was over and done with by the fall of 1939.

[01:06:09.444 – 01:06:19.544] Since H. had pursued his divorce with Ha- Kathleen with every intention of marrying Ruth, this reversal of her affection caused some serious problems with both [01:06:19.544 – 01:06:25.184] of them, and also for Bill W., who found himself caught squarely in the middle of this illicit affair. [01:06:25.184 – 01:06:35.264] Under these circumstances, both Hank P. and Ruth H. would've had a vested interest in making this addition to the text, one which explicitly absolved [01:06:35.264 – 01:06:41.824] the adulterous P. from the need to candidly confess these transgressions to his wife or to, or, or… [01:06:41.824 – 01:06:47.644] And either or both of them may well have lobbied for the insertion of this new paragraph into the Family A.. [01:06:47.644 – 01:06:57.744] But whoever may have been responsible for the addition of this particular paragraph, it will have to serve here as just one, but far from the only, example of the type [01:06:57.744 – 01:07:05.584] of ongoing edits being done to the text of The Big Book before it was finalized for the multi-lith printing in mid-February 1939.

[01:07:05.584 – 01:07:07.684] Bill S., thank you ever so much. [01:07:07.684 – 01:07:09.004] More has definitely been revealed. [01:07:09.004 – 01:07:12.004] Please unmute if you'd like to, uh, acknowledge Bill's reading. [01:07:12.004 – 01:07:12.504] Thank you. [01:07:12.504 – 01:07:13.784] And of course he's waiting a bit. [01:07:13.784 – 01:07:14.814] Thank you, Bill. [01:07:14.814 – 01:07:14.815] Thank you.

[01:07:14.815 – 01:07:15.524] Bill, thank you very much. [01:07:15.524 – 01:07:17.554] Thank you, Riley. [01:07:17.554 – 01:07:17.714] Thank you. [01:07:17.714 – 01:07:18.204] Thank you, Bill. [01:07:18.204 – 01:07:20.104] Thank you. [01:07:20.104 – 01:07:20.754] Thank you. [01:07:20.754 – 01:07:20.774] Thank you, Bill.

[01:07:20.774 – 01:07:21.133] Good stuff. [01:07:21.133 – 01:07:21.424] Excellent. [01:07:21.424 – 01:07:22.224] Thank you, Riley. [01:07:22.224 – 01:07:22.944] Thank you, Bill. [01:07:22.944 – 01:07:23.663] Thanks, Bill. [01:07:23.663 – 01:07:24.444] Thanks, Riley. [01:07:24.444 – 01:07:25.644] Thanks, Bill.

[01:07:25.644 – 01:07:28.034] Wow, Bill S.. [01:07:28.034 – 01:07:29.724] Uh, I have to apologize. [01:07:29.724 – 01:07:31.644] It was me that muted Riley during that. [01:07:31.644 – 01:07:35.464] I, really, I didn't give Riley s- permission to unmute, so it wasn't Riley's fault. [01:07:35.464 – 01:07:37.203] It was my fault. [01:07:37.203 – 01:07:38.793] Apologies, Riley. [01:07:38.793 – 01:07:44.154] I, before we go to J- Jim W. with the Q&A, remember we have Q&A for, uh, about half an hour.

[01:07:44.154 – 01:07:44.724] We have Mr. [01:07:44.724 – 01:07:45.534] Shareburg first. [01:07:45.534 – 01:07:55.844] So I just want to mention this meeting again tomorrow night, um, a History of Orthodoxy in AA: From the Orthodox M. to the White P., and that's gonna be presented [01:07:55.844 – 01:07:58.644] by Jackie B out of San Francisco. [01:07:58.644 – 01:08:04.764] Uh, she's gonna be speaking about three ways of working the 12-step program, and S., medium, and weak. [01:08:04.764 – 01:08:12.484] And if you have never heard a presentation by Jackie B, you are, you are, you are less than. [01:08:12.484 – 01:08:15.624] I mean, that, that woman is just, she's an amazing AA historian.

[01:08:15.624 – 01:08:17.624] She's, and she's a great, great presenter. [01:08:17.624 – 01:08:18.364] Jackie B. [01:08:18.364 – 01:08:19.524] Yeah. [01:08:19.524 – 01:08:20.684] Absolutely. [01:08:20.684 – 01:08:24.504] She presented last week on, uh, special composition groups. [01:08:24.504 – 01:08:25.644] Really good. [01:08:25.644 – 01:08:27.144] Oh, it was good.

[01:08:27.144 – 01:08:34.734] Uh, and she's mentioning Gresham's Law and Alcoholics Anonymous, so I guess you need to start looking into your search engine for that. [01:08:34.734 – 01:08:37.684] We're going, we're going over to, uh, Jim W.. [01:08:37.684 – 01:08:39.844] Jim, do you want to mention for us about the discussion thing? [01:08:39.844 – 01:08:41.344] Sorry I didn't introduce you in the beginning. [01:08:41.344 – 01:08:41.614] Certainly. [01:08:41.614 – 01:08:42.424] Absolutely. [01:08:42.424 – 01:08:43.104] Good afternoon.

[01:08:43.104 – 01:08:45.144] My name's Jim, and I'm an alcoholic. [01:08:45.144 – 01:08:45.174] Jim. [01:08:45.174 – 01:08:55.224] And before we start the Q&A here, um, this, uh, Q&A is for, uh, questions about what we read today, [01:08:55.224 – 01:09:06.004] the Family A. and the authorship and the topics that we're, uh, we're concerned with in this particular chapter, while we have the author [01:09:06.004 – 01:09:06.784] here with us. [01:09:06.784 – 01:09:16.504] Uh, if you want to discuss other topics, we have, uh, a meeting after the meeting in the parking lot, or car park if you prefer. [01:09:16.504 – 01:09:24.324] Uh, and, uh, uh, a- and we, we're, we're open to all kinds of discussion.

[01:09:24.324 – 01:09:28.704] But for right now let's keep it to, uh, what we, uh, what we read today. [01:09:28.704 – 01:09:33.584] Who would like to, uh, get s- Um, I got one question, uh, for you, Bill. [01:09:33.584 – 01:09:35.194] Was… [01:09:35.194 – 01:09:41.084] The first question is, was the, uh, was Hank a member of the Oxford Group? [01:09:41.084 – 01:09:49.264] Well, Hank P. got sober in September of 1935 when Bill W…. [01:09:49.264 – 01:09:52.794] He was the first guy who got sober when he came back to New York City after- [01:09:53.052 – 01:09:53.352] Get Dr.

[01:09:53.352 – 01:09:55.652] Bob and a couple of guys sober out in, in Akron. [01:09:55.652 – 01:10:06.352] And, and they went to, they went to, they went to, uh, Oxford Group meetings and, uh, un- until they broke with the Oxford Group in, uh, in the spring of 1937. [01:10:06.352 – 01:10:09.752] So, so he was definitely a member of the Oxford Group. [01:10:09.752 – 01:10:18.012] There's also this great letter, um, that he wrote to, uh, Sam S. when he was like, I don't know, eight weeks sober or something. [01:10:18.012 – 01:10:20.652] In F. and I- a couple of months sober. [01:10:20.652 – 01:10:30.692] And, and, and he, he basically told, told, uh, Sam S. that he was, you know, he was, he was the spark plug that, that, that, that the Oxford Group needed so that it [01:10:30.692 – 01:10:34.192] could really take over the United States of America and then the world.

[01:10:34.192 – 01:10:37.542] And, uh, it was, it was ju- It's, it's a great, great, great letter. [01:10:37.542 – 01:10:39.272] But anyhow, yeah. [01:10:39.272 – 01:10:40.832] Yeah, he was definitely a member of the OG. [01:10:40.832 – 01:10:42.452] Thank you. [01:10:42.452 – 01:10:43.632] Thank you very much, Bill. [01:10:43.632 – 01:10:51.232] And, uh, uh, just raise your hand on the participants, Zoom participants page if you would like to ask a question. [01:10:51.232 – 01:10:52.932] We're gonna start off with Hugh.

[01:10:52.932 – 01:10:55.812] Hey, everyone. [01:10:55.812 – 01:10:56.692] I'm an alcoholic. [01:10:56.692 – 01:10:57.652] My name's Hugh. [01:10:57.652 – 01:11:07.712] Um, Bill, you mentioned both, uh, Hank and Ruth taking that writing course, which that they then [01:11:07.712 – 01:11:12.012] seemed to make them feel qualified to improve on Bill's writing. [01:11:12.012 – 01:11:16.592] Did B. write much before this? [01:11:16.592 – 01:11:26.872] I've actually heard it speculated that he got a lot of guidance from Sam S., who had published several books before this

[01:11:26.872 – 01:11:29.512] and was meeting with Bill regularly. [01:11:29.512 – 01:11:33.972] Do you, do you know if there's any evidence one way or the other on that? [01:11:33.972 – 01:11:42.042] The only evidence I've heard is negative evidence, and somewhere in the book here I, I quote Sam saying, "I look, I hate… [01:11:42.042 – 01:11:44.372] People keep saying I had something to do with the 12 steps. [01:11:44.372 – 01:11:46.312] I had nothing to do with the 12 steps. [01:11:46.312 – 01:11:55.672] Just nothing to do with it." Um, I have not seen the writing that Bill W. did in the 1920s when he was taking, you know, the motorcycle tour and all that. [01:11:55.672 – 01:11:56.622] He, um…

[01:11:56.622 – 01:12:07.012] Kevin H., uh, my good friend who with Dan C. made the documentary Bill W., has read some of those reports, and he swears that w- he can't bel- [01:12:07.012 – 01:12:17.052] He, he's so impressed with W.'s writing skills and talents when he's doing something that's just, you know, kind of a, a dry factual, uh, report on a [01:12:17.052 – 01:12:20.032] company and its, and its potential to make money for people. [01:12:20.032 – 01:12:24.592] Um, Kevin swears that, that they're just, they're brilliant analysis of stuff. [01:12:24.592 – 01:12:27.372] So, which I would believe, but, but no. [01:12:27.372 – 01:12:28.492] The, the whole… [01:12:28.492 – 01:12:37.412] Sam S. was, you know, whispering in Bill's ear all the time about what should be going into the Big Book is, is…

[01:12:37.412 – 01:12:39.072] There's no evidence for that whatsoever. [01:12:39.072 – 01:12:49.372] And Sam, Sam literally dis- disowned all those, those kind of, uh, urban legends about him being the, uh, the motive force for the writing of the book and the 12 steps [01:12:49.372 – 01:12:51.372] in a couple of speeches he gave. [01:12:51.372 – 01:13:00.892] So, uh- And from what I know of Sam, if he said that, it's probably true . [01:13:00.892 – 01:13:00.962] Yeah. [01:13:00.962 – 01:13:01.092] Yeah. [01:13:01.092 – 01:13:01.881] To understate it.

[01:13:01.881 – 01:13:02.452] All right. [01:13:02.452 – 01:13:02.832] Thank you. [01:13:02.832 – 01:13:03.672] Tha- thank you, Hugh. [01:13:03.672 – 01:13:05.692] And thank you for writing the book, Bill. [01:13:05.692 – 01:13:06.672] Thank you. [01:13:06.672 – 01:13:08.912] Thank you, uh, Hugh. [01:13:08.912 – 01:13:10.172] And, uh, Kit.

[01:13:10.172 – 01:13:14.232] Thank you. [01:13:14.232 – 01:13:14.712] I'm Kit. [01:13:14.712 – 01:13:15.612] I'm an alcoholic. [01:13:15.612 – 01:13:18.462] Um, I have a question for Bill. [01:13:18.462 – 01:13:28.512] On page 368 of your book, um, you had written, uh, a, from a quote, "Happy, joyous and released." And in my Big Book on page [01:13:28.512 – 01:13:33.912] 133 it says, "Happy, joyous and free." I'm wondering, was that from an earlier, the earlier printing? [01:13:33.912 – 01:13:36.672] That would have been from the Multilith printing.

[01:13:36.672 – 01:13:37.112] Okay. [01:13:37.112 – 01:13:37.562] Thank you. [01:13:37.562 – 01:13:38.532] Uh, yeah, that, that's exactly right. [01:13:38.532 – 01:13:45.552] The, the stuff that I quote here is from the, from, from, from the Multilith because that's the earliest version we have of this particular chapter. [01:13:45.552 – 01:13:46.772] Okay, great. [01:13:46.772 – 01:13:47.291] Thank you. [01:13:47.291 – 01:13:49.332] Thank you, Kit.

[01:13:49.332 – 01:13:50.012] Good question. [01:13:50.012 – 01:13:52.032] And we'll go to Priscilla now. [01:13:52.032 – 01:13:55.412] Hi, I'm Priscilla, alcoholic. [01:13:55.412 – 01:13:59.272] Um, this is the first I've heard about Tom P.. [01:13:59.272 – 01:14:04.192] What else do we know about him and his feud with, uh, Bill W.? [01:14:04.192 – 01:14:07.772] Well, Priscilla, that's a great question. [01:14:07.772 – 01:14:17.912] You know, one of the things is, um, I've learned recently, I mean, it says here that they, they had a falling out in the '50s, but, but it was really, really cl- it was some

[01:14:17.912 – 01:14:22.932] time, I think it was in s- late '60 or '61 on, based on some evidence I've seen. [01:14:22.932 – 01:14:31.252] And, and, and I'm not sure what was going on, but Tom P. went away and he, he formed a, a, a group. [01:14:31.252 – 01:14:32.912] It's almost like a commune. [01:14:32.912 – 01:14:35.932] It's still working over in, over in New York State someplace. [01:14:35.932 – 01:14:43.632] Uh, he, he, he had a, he set up a program called All A. Anonymous, and, uh, had his whole thing. [01:14:43.632 – 01:14:49.352] And I think the thing that Jackie's talking about tomorrow about Gresham's Law of Sobriety is one of… [01:14:49.352 – 01:14:50.992] I thi- that could, that could actually be I…

[01:14:50.992 – 01:14:52.572] Jim's nodding his head. [01:14:52.572 – 01:14:58.892] I, I think that's something that, that, that, that Tom P. actually wrote, but if he didn't write it, he, he certainly circulated it. [01:14:58.892 – 01:15:00.832] His people circulated that all the time. [01:15:00.832 – 01:15:06.852] So what, what they fought about, I was just talking to my friend Jay S. about this. [01:15:06.852 – 01:15:09.352] Jay was, uh, Jay was here a couple of weeks ago. [01:15:09.352 – 01:15:15.322] And, um, and I, we really think that, at the moment we think that what they ended up fighting about- [01:15:15.440 – 01:15:21.320] It was something, something to do with the whole LSD experiments they were doing in the late '50s and, and very, very early '60s.

[01:15:21.320 – 01:15:29.320] As opposed to the urban legend is that he got so mad at Bill because Bill, Bill was screwing women left and right, and he couldn't get Bill to stop. [01:15:29.320 – 01:15:34.200] So, so he just cut Bill off and left, you know, and, uh, and did that. [01:15:34.200 – 01:15:36.980] So I, I, I don't really know. [01:15:36.980 – 01:15:38.959] I, I, uh, I need to… [01:15:38.959 – 01:15:46.520] I, I, I should be talking to Kevin H. about that a, a little bit and seeing what, what, what his theory is on, on what that fight was all about that they broke up. [01:15:46.520 – 01:15:51.980] But, but I've never seen anything in writing, any documentation about that. [01:15:51.980 – 01:16:02.300] Now I know, I know, uh, Tom P. gave interviews, um, to Susan C., which is where she got this information about Bill being a serial adulterer.

[01:16:02.300 – 01:16:14.120] And also, uh, I know that Jay, uh, before Susan did about a year before that, Jay had interviewed him and, uh, and didn't really get any substantive evidence [01:16:14.120 – 01:16:17.140] for, for th- what that was and what was going on with that. [01:16:17.140 – 01:16:27.280] Which is really too bad because, you know, when Hank, uh, drank, all of a sudden Bill had nobody that he could lean on anymore, that, that, that, that he knew he could trust, that just cared for [01:16:27.280 – 01:16:32.080] him as, as Bill W., as opposed to Bill W., you know. [01:16:32.080 – 01:16:41.479] And, and, uh, and, and, and Powers was a guy that they were, they were joined at the hip in the same way that, that, that Bill was joined at the hip with Hank P.. [01:16:41.479 – 01:16:49.820] Throughout, throughout the '40s they were doing all this spiritualism stuff, and then in, as they got into the late '50s they started doing the LSD stuff together. [01:16:49.820 – 01:16:55.000] And, uh, you know, it was, it was a really, really important relationship for Bill W..

[01:16:55.000 – 01:17:00.900] And again, it, it, this guy didn't drink the way Hank P. drank, but, but the whole relationship blew up. [01:17:00.900 – 01:17:04.100] And, uh, and I, I wish I knew more about that. [01:17:04.100 – 01:17:07.040] I wish somebody knew more about that, that they could tell us about it. [01:17:07.040 – 01:17:07.880] But I don't know. [01:17:07.880 – 01:17:12.540] Maybe, maybe there's documents over in, uh, East R. or whatever it's called. [01:17:12.540 – 01:17:15.480] I can't remember exactly what that group is called that's still over there. [01:17:15.480 – 01:17:19.040] Tom died 15 years ago maybe.

[01:17:19.040 – 01:17:21.300] Maybe 15 years ago, I'm guessing. [01:17:21.300 – 01:17:23.640] Uh, thank you, Bill. [01:17:23.640 – 01:17:30.200] Before we go on, uh, let me fill Bill in with what we did while he was missing in action last week. [01:17:30.200 – 01:17:40.360] We had, I saw Kit and that reminded me, uh, uh, Kit and five other people shared their experience, uh, strength and hope with your [01:17:40.360 – 01:17:40.780] book. [01:17:40.780 – 01:17:51.180] Uh, and, uh, I did not hear anybody say, "I think I wasted my money on the book." Uh, on the contrary, uh, everyone, [01:17:51.180 – 01:18:01.300] uh, uh, talked about how that book has affected them and their recovery and their ways of thinking, uh, about their recovery and about history

[01:18:01.300 – 01:18:02.220] and AA. [01:18:02.220 – 01:18:12.480] And, uh, and so yeah, we had six people share, uh, including Jay, and, uh, on, uh, on the book and how it has affected them. [01:18:12.480 – 01:18:16.480] And, uh, so that was a great, uh, great experience. [01:18:16.480 – 01:18:24.580] And then we had a, a little presentation that's not nearly as good as what you do, but, uh, we had another presentation on Bill W. [01:18:24.580 – 01:18:26.420] versus Bill S., you know. [01:18:26.420 – 01:18:28.140] But- And he's being very modest, Bill. [01:18:28.140 – 01:18:29.120] He was awesome.

[01:18:29.120 – 01:18:30.680] I, I, I've, I've seen the presentation. [01:18:30.680 – 01:18:32.400] It's an outstanding presentation. [01:18:32.400 – 01:18:37.700] I'm really happy to hear that none of those six people came on and said my book is gonna kill alcoholics, you know? [01:18:37.700 – 01:18:38.219] No. [01:18:38.219 – 01:18:40.020] No, not one of them. [01:18:40.020 – 01:18:41.260] Not one of them. [01:18:41.260 – 01:18:43.540] Now let's go on to, uh, Azell.

[01:18:43.540 – 01:18:50.300] Thank you, Jim. [01:18:50.300 – 01:18:54.219] Uh, thank you, David. [01:18:54.219 – 01:18:56.020] Uh, and thank you, Bill. [01:18:56.020 – 01:19:07.620] On that, on that note about Bill's in- uh, fidelities and [01:19:07.620 – 01:19:18.400] his, um, big disagreement with Tom, do you think there's any connection between [01:19:18.400 – 01:19:28.520] Tom and what they call the Orange P. that came out that talked exclusively [01:19:28.520 – 01:19:35.120] about the other women that Bill was, uh, allegedly involved with?

[01:19:35.120 – 01:19:39.840] Uh, Azell, I've, I've, I've read the Orange P.. [01:19:39.840 – 01:19:40.700] Are, are they still up? [01:19:40.700 – 01:19:42.240] I, I think I went looking for them recently. [01:19:42.240 – 01:19:42.930] I couldn't find them. [01:19:42.930 – 01:19:50.730] But anyhow, um, I, I, I think they were feeding off of stuff that Tom said and then, you know, people just… [01:19:50.730 – 01:19:57.829] There are a whole slew of people in Alcoholics Anonymous just loved to, to put Bill W. down. [01:19:57.829 – 01:20:08.020] And, uh, and so, you know, there are people just that I think it's human nature, not just alcoholics, it's human nature to, uh, to wanna take people

[01:20:08.020 – 01:20:09.180] down a peg, you know? [01:20:09.180 – 01:20:14.640] A- and, and if you c- we can do that, and we think we can do that plausibly, I think a lot of people buy into that. [01:20:14.640 – 01:20:23.080] I can't tell you how many times over my decades in Alcoholics Anonymous I'd heard people talk about how Bill W. was just screwing women left and right. [01:20:23.080 – 01:20:25.200] Just screwing women left and right. [01:20:25.200 – 01:20:28.800] And, and Ernie really got after that. [01:20:28.800 – 01:20:34.560] Really in the last two years of his life he got after that, and he put a thing up on AA History L., and he did… [01:20:34.560 – 01:20:37.850] And I was, I went out to visit Ernie when I first started writing this book-

[01:20:38.488 – 01:20:43.348] And, and he had never responded to, uh, never said what, what had happened with that research. [01:20:43.348 – 01:20:46.408] I said, "Ernie," so it was like six or nine months later, you know. [01:20:46.408 – 01:20:47.788] I said, "What, Ernie, what the hell happened? [01:20:47.788 – 01:20:52.448] What'd you get back from that?" And he said, "Well, I got this and that." You know, I said, "You need to, you need to put that up on A.A. [01:20:52.448 – 01:20:59.198] History L. again so that people know what the results of your search were," because he was more well-connected in the A.A. [01:20:59.198 – 01:21:01.147] history community than anybody that ever was. [01:21:01.147 – 01:21:02.968] And, uh, so he did.

[01:21:02.968 – 01:21:03.508] He did that. [01:21:03.508 – 01:21:06.008] Uh, so I don't know. [01:21:06.008 – 01:21:16.348] I just, I have, I have a hard time with, uh, I have a hard time with the, the, with, with the massive a- number of urban legends we seem to just propagate in Alcoholics Anonymous [01:21:16.348 – 01:21:17.128] that keep going. [01:21:17.128 – 01:21:18.608] They just, they… [01:21:18.608 – 01:21:23.348] I mean, sometimes I can kinda laugh at them, but sometimes I get smoke coming out of my ears. [01:21:23.348 – 01:21:23.568] So…

[01:21:23.568 – 01:21:27.828] Eh, thank you, Bill, and thanks, Azel T. you … [01:21:27.828 – 01:21:36.828] hey, uh, next week Azel is going to be our reader for, uh, chapter 20, which is Hank P., managing editor. [01:21:36.828 – 01:21:38.988] And the chapter to employers. [01:21:38.988 – 01:21:41.477] We'll be reading chapter 20 next week. [01:21:41.477 – 01:21:48.168] And of course our, uh, famous footnoter par excellence will be with us, Riley K. [01:21:48.168 – 01:21:50.848] And now we'll go to Anna. [01:21:50.848 – 01:21:52.308] Anna, do you have a question?

[01:21:52.308 – 01:21:54.168] I do. [01:21:54.168 – 01:21:56.028] Thank you, um, Jim. [01:21:56.028 – 01:21:59.328] And thank you, Bill, for, um, all that reading. [01:21:59.328 – 01:22:03.208] I didn't know how you survived keeping your voice together. [01:22:03.208 – 01:22:13.688] Um, with regards to the topic of Bill's infidelities and, and whatever the extent of those infidelities were, [01:22:13.688 – 01:22:16.648] how difficult does that make the job of a historian? [01:22:16.648 – 01:22:27.428] What's the responsibility of historians to state the facts, and what ethically does not need to be said by historians?

[01:22:27.428 – 01:22:35.308] Well, ethically is like a moral minefield thrown down there. [01:22:35.308 – 01:22:35.648] You know? [01:22:35.648 – 01:22:37.348] Like, what, what does that actually mean? [01:22:37.348 – 01:22:44.568] I think, I think a historian's job is to, is to relate the facts insofar as they can discover the facts. [01:22:44.568 – 01:22:46.867] 'Cause nobody ever has all the facts. [01:22:46.867 – 01:22:57.108] You know, I, I say a couple of places in the book, and in some of the presentations I do, you know, I think a historian's job is to get as close as possible to, quote, [01:22:57.108 – 01:22:58.407] what really happened.

[01:22:58.407 – 01:23:06.788] But you know, my wife and I had one of the guys over from our, our meditation Zoom meeting. [01:23:06.788 – 01:23:10.478] We, we've been talking to him on Zoom four times a week for two years. [01:23:10.478 – 01:23:20.518] He came over for lunch yesterday, and I'll guarantee you that if m- if my wife was on another, another box here on this Zoom call, and we described what happened at lunch yesterday, [01:23:20.518 – 01:23:22.088] we would get two different stories. [01:23:22.088 – 01:23:23.778] 'Cause… [01:23:23.778 – 01:23:25.408] And that was yesterday, you know? [01:23:25.408 – 01:23:29.248] You just, you have to be so careful about what you actually have.

[01:23:29.248 – 01:23:39.288] Now, one of the beauties is when you've got something on paper, something that somebody actually wrote, that, that they, they, they wrote in 1938, I can at least say that in 1938, [01:23:39.288 – 01:23:41.668] this is what, this is what was going on. [01:23:41.668 – 01:23:44.248] This is what he, this is what he said was going on, at least. [01:23:44.248 – 01:23:46.628] It was his interpretation of what was going on at the time. [01:23:46.628 – 01:23:49.088] Gotta be so careful about that stuff. [01:23:49.088 – 01:23:59.108] And, um, I m- if I had hard evidence that Bill W. was a multiple adulterer, and he was chasing women all over Alcoholics Anonymous meetings every time he left [01:23:59.108 – 01:24:04.128] Brooklyn, I, I think that's important information about the man and his character.

[01:24:04.128 – 01:24:15.188] Just as the whole story about, about the LSD thing is, is incredibly important to know who Bill W. was and what he was doing in the 1950s and in the early 1960s. [01:24:15.188 – 01:24:19.388] I, it's just I, I don't have a problem with any of that stuff. [01:24:19.388 – 01:24:28.408] Um, I have a very, well, I have a very high opinion of Bill W. despite all this stuff that I've researched and all the stories I've heard. [01:24:28.408 – 01:24:36.778] And, uh, um, so I, I, I don't, I don't know that, I, I don't know that I would withhold some sort of information, you know? [01:24:36.778 – 01:24:46.888] The whole deal with Helen W. is so interesting to me in the sense that, in the sense that, you know, when Bill's dying, and in the last month and a half [01:24:46.888 – 01:24:52.888] of his life, who's at his bedside up in Bedford H. before they take him to Florida where he dies? [01:24:52.888 – 01:24:54.108] Who's at his bedside?

[01:24:54.108 – 01:24:57.568] His wife, Nell W., and Helen W.. [01:24:57.568 – 01:25:03.168] Those are the three people that are at Bill W.'s bedside during the month, last month that he's dying. [01:25:03.168 – 01:25:13.368] So obviously, I don't know wha- I don't know what was going on in his marriage and what was going on with his wife, but, but clearly there'd been some sort of arrangement [01:25:13.368 – 01:25:19.608] agreed to or gotten to, otherwise that woman would never have been at his bedside when he was dying, you know? [01:25:19.608 – 01:25:23.768] So I don't know what was going on in, in their marriage, but I, I would, I would love to know. [01:25:23.768 – 01:25:31.688] But those, those kind of arrangements are made, uh, privately and confidentially, and people don't talk about those things afterwards. [01:25:31.688 – 01:25:35.148] So we get into speculation, and I don't wanna be a speculation guy.

[01:25:35.148 – 01:25:35.768] I wanna try and… [01:25:35.768 – 01:25:45.808] I mean, sometimes you got evidence that, that, that doesn't quite fit this way or that way, so you gotta, you gotta say, "The only way I can make this fit is to speculate that this is what was going on." And if [01:25:45.808 – 01:25:49.148] you wanna disagree with my speculation, I'm perfectly okay with that. [01:25:49.148 – 01:25:51.048] Uh, matter of fact, I encourage it. [01:25:51.048 – 01:26:00.218] But, uh, so- Yeah, just, I just wanna quickly say that, um, I, and I wanna put it on the record because this is being recorded, that I would not, was not- [01:26:00.453 – 01:26:02.224] implying that you were holding back anything. [01:26:02.224 – 01:26:12.634] In fact, I, um, appreciate your dedication to how you're piecing this all together, um, considering how many gaps there are

[01:26:12.634 – 01:26:13.474] in information. [01:26:13.474 – 01:26:19.924] Because we don't have the facts from the people straight because they're no longer here, or we don't have anything documented. [01:26:19.924 – 01:26:29.964] And I just wanna say, I, I, you know, when I came into the program, I was bombarded with the extremes of what people felt, uh, Bill did [01:26:29.964 – 01:26:30.824] and didn't do. [01:26:30.824 – 01:26:37.424] And that's a hard place to be when you're a newcomer coming in and you're hearing all this kind of information. [01:26:37.424 – 01:26:38.404] It's, it's… [01:26:38.404 – 01:26:43.904] I, I have settled with the fact that I am comfortable with just enough of…

[01:26:43.904 – 01:26:50.924] I know enough of B- Bill's foibles to know that he's human just like me, and that's as much as I need to know. [01:26:50.924 – 01:26:56.384] If there's anything else, I, I'm not sure I, I need to add any more of a… [01:26:56.384 – 01:26:59.524] I don't need to add any more to his junk-a-log. [01:26:59.524 – 01:27:01.804] Thank you, Anna. [01:27:01.804 – 01:27:02.464] Thank you. [01:27:02.464 – 01:27:02.884] Yeah. [01:27:02.884 – 01:27:03.704] Thanks, Anna.

[01:27:03.704 – 01:27:07.124] And, uh, I, I just wanna make, uh, one quick note. [01:27:07.124 – 01:27:17.244] You know, the thing that I, I admire, for example, usually the K. table story, uh, where you, "Uh, okay, here's what Bill [01:27:17.244 – 01:27:17.644] said. [01:27:17.644 – 01:27:27.814] Well, now Ebby said something else, and here's what Lois said." You know, to present all of the, the quotable, documentable, [01:27:27.814 – 01:27:37.864] uh, options a- and to say, "Here's everything that we know about the situation." And, and that's, that's g- not trying to hide anything, you know, or put one [01:27:37.864 – 01:27:38.484] over the other. [01:27:38.484 – 01:27:43.884] But to present the different situations and say, "Here's what we know," and put them in context.

[01:27:43.884 – 01:27:45.564] So thank you. [01:27:45.564 – 01:27:46.624] Let's go back to Hugh. [01:27:46.624 – 01:27:48.124] Have another question? [01:27:48.124 – 01:27:50.304] Uh, it's not actually a question. [01:27:50.304 – 01:27:53.344] Bill said he was having trouble finding the Orange P.. [01:27:53.344 – 01:28:01.344] Um, if you can't find something that used to be on the internet, try archive.org, which is the internet archive. [01:28:01.344 – 01:28:04.304] You'll have a history- Oh, by the way, the new, the new, uh…

[01:28:04.304 – 01:28:07.304] They did change, uh, uh, the… [01:28:07.304 – 01:28:13.404] It's orange-papers.info now, and that's where they're, uh- Okay … [01:28:13.404 – 01:28:16.243] they've changed a new, uh, new one, so thank you. [01:28:16.243 – 01:28:20.444] And, and like I- Well, that's a, that, that's a good technique for any pages that you can't… [01:28:20.444 – 01:28:20.984] They're Yeah. [01:28:20.984 – 01:28:20.993] Absolutely. [01:28:20.993 – 01:28:21.164] No.

[01:28:21.164 – 01:28:28.824] If, if, if you don't know what the Orange P. are, they're just, they're just rabid screeds against everything about Alcoholics Anonymous is. [01:28:28.824 – 01:28:30.544] I mean, w- just- Yeah … [01:28:30.544 – 01:28:34.164] every person in AA, every, every step in AA. [01:28:34.164 – 01:28:35.384] It's just, just… [01:28:35.384 – 01:28:36.044] But you know what? [01:28:36.044 – 01:28:38.404] We gotta have all voices. [01:28:38.404 – 01:28:40.264] Gotta listen to everybody, so.

[01:28:40.264 – 01:28:41.684] Yeah. [01:28:41.684 – 01:28:45.404] Even the Orange P. conspiracy theories. [01:28:45.404 – 01:28:48.564] Anyway, let's go to Tomorrow in Australia. [01:28:48.564 – 01:28:48.964] Dan? [01:28:48.964 – 01:28:50.504] Hey. [01:28:50.504 – 01:28:51.343] Good day, Jim. [01:28:51.343 – 01:28:51.784] Thank you.

[01:28:51.784 – 01:29:01.804] Bill, uh, j- just, uh, to my, to my small understanding, the, uh, the Oxford Group and, and their absolutes [01:29:01.804 – 01:29:11.824] and that, it seems to be, uh, the way I see it is, uh, part of the deal is that y- you hang the dirty, hang the dirty washing out [01:29:11.824 – 01:29:15.624] on the line for everybody else to, uh, do a bit of laundry work on it. [01:29:15.624 – 01:29:24.444] And it becomes quite obvious that, that, uh, that's, uh, not the go in, in this outfit. [01:29:24.444 – 01:29:33.364] And, yeah, you said that, uh, Bill mistakenly says that How it Works was written after the first four chapters. [01:29:33.364 – 01:29:44.064] Given, you know, step five, we admitted to God, to ourselves, and to another human being, not the, uh, the collective fellowship or getting up and [01:29:44.064 – 01:29:45.744] in meetings with the loud hailer.

[01:29:45.744 – 01:29:52.644] And step nine, as is touched on here, uh, except when to do so would harm them or others. [01:29:52.644 – 01:29:53.304] Mm-hmm. [01:29:53.304 – 01:29:55.984] Those, those steps, were they… [01:29:55.984 – 01:30:04.744] Is, were they amended after, uh, reflection and, and writing of a few other chapters, especially this one? [01:30:04.744 – 01:30:06.004] No. [01:30:06.004 – 01:30:10.364] There were, there were very, very few changes to the 12 steps, and we'll see that as we go along. [01:30:10.364 – 01:30:13.824] Really, we're, we're, we're gonna, we're gonna do that in four-part harmony, Dan.

[01:30:13.824 – 01:30:16.463] Beautiful. [01:30:16.463 – 01:30:17.043] Thanks, Bill. [01:30:17.043 – 01:30:18.783] Thank you, Dan. [01:30:18.783 – 01:30:23.644] And, uh, yeah, that, uh, that the… [01:30:23.644 – 01:30:29.984] Moving away from the Oxford Group is, uh, is an interesting, uh, part of the, the history. [01:30:29.984 – 01:30:31.944] Things that were too groupie. [01:30:31.944 – 01:30:35.144] So, uh- …

[01:30:35.144 – 01:30:40.584] has a question, uh, for Bill while, uh, while he's here with us. [01:30:40.584 – 01:30:41.924] Dan, uh, Dan, go ahead. [01:30:41.924 – 01:30:43.564] No, sorry, mate. [01:30:43.564 – 01:30:44.784] I was trying to put it down. [01:30:44.784 – 01:30:50.264] Okay. [01:30:50.264 – 01:30:54.784] Uh, and anyone else? [01:30:54.784 – 01:30:57.184] Anyone else have a question?

[01:30:57.184 – 01:31:01.104] No other questions? [01:31:01.104 – 01:31:02.424] Oh, there's Marsha. [01:31:02.424 – 01:31:03.324] Hello, Marsha. [01:31:03.324 – 01:31:06.304] Do you have a question about today? [01:31:06.304 – 01:31:07.414] Hello. [01:31:07.414 – 01:31:07.784] Hi. [01:31:07.784 – 01:31:08.084] Hi.

[01:31:08.084 – 01:31:10.543] Hi, everyone, and hi, Bill. [01:31:10.543 – 01:31:12.144] Go M.. [01:31:12.144 – 01:31:12.524] Hi. [01:31:12.524 – 01:31:12.904] Hi. [01:31:12.904 – 01:31:22.874] Um, there, there was reference in the reading, I believe, to, uh, critic- [01:31:23.772 – 01:31:29.271] of Bill as a writer or, or there's inferences about that. [01:31:29.271 – 01:31:32.892] And in this discussion there has been, you know, a little mention of that.

[01:31:32.892 – 01:31:42.972] Uh, and I hear criticisms of him as a writer fairly often by, um, s- [01:31:42.972 – 01:31:48.812] a certain kind of snarkly strata of the program, I'll put it that way. [01:31:48.812 – 01:31:53.572] And, uh, I personally have found… [01:31:53.572 – 01:31:55.372] I think that Bill W. [01:31:55.372 – 01:31:57.022] is a beautiful writer. [01:31:57.022 – 01:32:01.982] Uh, in the 12 and 12, I just think that is a masterpiece. [01:32:01.982 – 01:32:12.092] Uh, even if it isn't, uh, uh, in a, in a literary sense, uh, perfection, I just think it is a masterpiece

[01:32:12.092 – 01:32:14.352] of human communication. [01:32:14.352 – 01:32:24.592] And I think he writes in the, in the style, the kind of fluid dramatic style like of Jack L. and, uh, [01:32:24.592 – 01:32:34.602] some of the writers, uh, that directly preceded him, uh, in e- in the eras preceding him, uh, of the 1920s and really of [01:32:34.602 – 01:32:35.252] his era. [01:32:35.252 – 01:32:44.972] And I would like to know, what do you, uh, think about that and the criticisms of him as a writer? [01:32:44.972 – 01:32:50.352] Well, now we're into personal opinion here, Marsha. [01:32:50.352 – 01:33:00.452] And I, I've gotta, gotta be, be very, uh, honest that when I read Bill W. when I first got sober, uh, in 1981, I,

[01:33:00.452 – 01:33:03.072] I was not fond of his writing at all. [01:33:03.072 – 01:33:03.792] You know? [01:33:03.792 – 01:33:09.072] But, but of course I've been reading that book for 40 years now, and, uh, it's all familiar to me. [01:33:09.072 – 01:33:09.392] You know? [01:33:09.392 – 01:33:13.112] So when people have trouble with it I'm like, "What's your problem?" Mm-hmm. [01:33:13.112 – 01:33:14.452] "What's your problem?" But you know what? [01:33:14.452 – 01:33:17.072] That was 40 years ago.

[01:33:17.072 – 01:33:17.652] We've been, we have… [01:33:17.652 – 01:33:22.042] People, I think, I understand who people have, have, have problems with some of the writing. [01:33:22.042 – 01:33:24.852] It's just, it's just, it's just dated. [01:33:24.852 – 01:33:25.352] You know? [01:33:25.352 – 01:33:30.932] It's dated in, in its style, and it's dated in its content, and it's dated in its word selection. [01:33:30.932 – 01:33:34.752] And, uh, and, and so people, people tend to struggle with it. [01:33:34.752 – 01:33:45.512] Um- Well, you know, you know, Bill, that's what I love about it, the fact that it is so dated, that it is such a, um, uh, an exemplar

[01:33:45.512 – 01:33:54.401] of the writing of that time, of the post, uh, 1920s, uh, genre of, of American letters. [01:33:54.401 – 01:33:54.932] You know? [01:33:54.932 – 01:34:04.392] Uh- And it is almost corny, you know, a lot of it, but that is the style of that time, and I just love being transported into that time- Mm-hmm … [01:34:04.392 – 01:34:05.852] and that way of communicating. [01:34:05.852 – 01:34:06.901] So that's all. [01:34:06.901 – 01:34:07.932] Thank you. [01:34:07.932 – 01:34:08.372] All right.

[01:34:08.372 – 01:34:09.072] Thank you, Marsha. [01:34:09.072 – 01:34:10.432] Thank, thank you Marsha. [01:34:10.432 – 01:34:12.292] And we'll go to Bill L.. [01:34:12.292 – 01:34:14.252] Yes. [01:34:14.252 – 01:34:15.292] Thank you, Bill. [01:34:15.292 – 01:34:25.362] Um, my, my question is, uh, I believe it was Tom P. who, uh, took dictation when Bill was writing [01:34:25.362 – 01:34:26.401] the 12 and 12.

[01:34:26.401 – 01:34:27.362] Is that true? [01:34:27.362 – 01:34:30.862] Tom, I don't know that he took dictation. [01:34:30.862 – 01:34:35.592] Tom P. certainly was involved in, in, in editing of that, that particular book. [01:34:35.592 – 01:34:37.432] To what degree? [01:34:37.432 – 01:34:40.852] There are people, there are people online who say Tom P. wrote that book. [01:34:40.852 – 01:34:42.952] I mean, it just, it's, it's one… [01:34:42.952 – 01:34:47.832] I think that's, I, I chalk that up as an urban leg- But I haven't done any research on the 12 and 12.

[01:34:47.832 – 01:34:51.132] So I, I'm, I'm the wrong guy to ask about that. [01:34:51.132 – 01:34:58.372] But yeah, I, I certainly think he had, I think he, I think he was looking over Bill's shoulder the same way Hank P. was looking over Bill's shoulder. [01:34:58.372 – 01:35:01.932] Uh, how much, how much of his input was taken? [01:35:01.932 – 01:35:03.952] I suspect more so than P.. [01:35:03.952 – 01:35:08.472] But I also think, I think Ed D. was looking over Bill's shoulder when he was doing that also. [01:35:08.472 – 01:35:12.952] So F. Ed had a, had a, had a piece of the action on that, I, I suspect. [01:35:12.952 – 01:35:14.991] Again, I, I don't really know about that.

[01:35:14.991 – 01:35:19.272] But I don't, I don't, I don't think he wrote it or, or dictated it or… [01:35:19.272 – 01:35:23.632] He may have done, you know, some people say, "Well, he did that chapter." It's like, "Well, that's cool. [01:35:23.632 – 01:35:24.632] Where did you get that from? [01:35:24.632 – 01:35:26.792] Where, where does it say that?" You know? [01:35:26.792 – 01:35:29.092] I, I can sign off on that. [01:35:29.092 – 01:35:33.412] I'm, I'm- Well, he- As, as opposed to Marsha, I'm not a big fan of the 12 and 12. [01:35:33.412 – 01:35:35.992] So we do not wanna get into that discussion here.

[01:35:35.992 – 01:35:36.902] No. [01:35:36.902 – 01:35:40.082] What was, w- what was Tom P.' back- All right. [01:35:40.082 – 01:35:45.692] Um, and are there any other questio- Uh, Da- Bill, go ahead, Bill. [01:35:45.692 – 01:35:45.852] Yeah. [01:35:45.852 – 01:35:47.502] What was Tom P.' background? [01:35:47.502 – 01:35:48.422] Was he a writer? [01:35:48.422 – 01:35:49.572] Or…

[01:35:49.572 – 01:35:53.972] Uh, Bill, I, I don't know. [01:35:53.972 – 01:35:56.332] I, again, we're, we're outside my area of expertise. [01:35:56.332 – 01:35:56.381] Okay. [01:35:56.381 – 01:36:04.012] I've been, I, I know I've been told things, but, uh, I've just, stuff just goes out of my head, and that's one of those things that went out of my head just now, so… [01:36:04.012 – 01:36:05.631] Thank you. [01:36:05.631 – 01:36:07.792] All right. [01:36:07.792 – 01:36:09.332] No other questions for the author.

[01:36:09.332 – 01:36:19.472] I'll, uh, remind you that, uh, uh, after, we'll have a meeting after the meeting if you have any other, uh, topics that you would like to talk about. [01:36:19.472 – 01:36:22.062] And, uh, as… [01:36:22.062 – 01:36:26.632] We'll go to Floyd to see if he, you have a question for, uh, Bill? [01:36:26.632 – 01:36:34.892] Floyd, do you have a question about this chapter? [01:36:34.892 – 01:36:36.232] Oh, there we go. [01:36:36.232 – 01:36:36.692] Thanks. [01:36:36.692 – 01:36:38.672] Uh, well, yes, I do.

[01:36:38.672 – 01:36:42.272] Uh, uh, as, as sort of, uh, I just, uh… [01:36:42.272 – 01:36:44.992] My question, Bill, is, uh, uh- [01:36:45.680 – 01:36:56.040] How much can I re- d- rely on Susan C.'s, uh, biography of Bill, uh, from, uh, published in [01:36:56.040 – 01:36:56.880] 2004? [01:36:56.880 – 01:36:59.560] Um, I'm just … [01:36:59.560 – 01:37:05.320] I, I did look at the, her, um, bibliography, and you're right. [01:37:05.320 – 01:37:07.940] It's just secondary or whatever.

[01:37:07.940 – 01:37:13.180] A few primary sources of information. [01:37:13.180 – 01:37:20.500] So, um, I, I, I'm a little at a, a loss here too, because a lot of my information comes from that book. [01:37:20.500 – 01:37:25.440] Uh, so what kind of thin ice am I on? [01:37:25.440 – 01:37:31.420] I don't want to put you on the- Again, we're, we're, we're into, we're into opinion here, Floyd. [01:37:31.420 – 01:37:31.529] Yeah. [01:37:31.529 – 01:37:39.300] But, uh, I've never read, I've never read the book because it, it's almost, almost exclusively secondary regurgitation of secondary information. [01:37:39.300 – 01:37:41.460] Although, you know, she did a …

[01:37:41.460 – 01:37:46.260] I mean, that whole thing about Bill asking for a drink when he was dying at the very end. [01:37:46.260 – 01:37:48.960] You know, that was, that was a really, that was a big reveal. [01:37:48.960 – 01:37:49.640] That was a big … [01:37:49.640 – 01:37:52.820] And, and that's based on documentation she found in Stepping S.. [01:37:52.820 – 01:37:53.250] Yeah. [01:37:53.250 – 01:37:53.660] But you're right. [01:37:53.660 – 01:37:57.940] If you look at her footnotes and her bibliography, it's all just same old, same old.

[01:37:57.940 – 01:38:00.000] It's just a r- it's a repackaging job. [01:38:00.000 – 01:38:09.280] And I, I think the, the days of repackaging AA's old time worn stories, hallowed stories, is long gone. [01:38:09.280 – 01:38:12.020] We need to be doing primary document research. [01:38:12.020 – 01:38:20.160] And, uh, and I, I'm, I'm trying to do that myself, and I'm applauding anybody else who's doing it, like Jackie, who's coming to talk tomorrow night. [01:38:20.160 – 01:38:23.160] A fabulous, fabulous AA historian. [01:38:23.160 – 01:38:24.820] That woman's just really great. [01:38:24.820 – 01:38:26.260] So we need to do a wrap.

[01:38:26.260 – 01:38:27.920] All right. [01:38:27.920 – 01:38:28.920] Thank you. [01:38:28.920 – 01:38:29.840] Thank you, uh, thank you, Bill. [01:38:29.840 – 01:38:33.280] And, uh, uh, like I said, we'll have a meeting after the meeting later. [01:38:33.280 – 01:38:36.760] But for now I'm gonna turn the meeting back over to David. [01:38:36.760 – 01:38:37.780] Thank you. [01:38:37.780 – 01:38:38.620] Thank you, everyone.

[01:38:38.620 – 01:38:46.479] Like, just a reminder, next week we're on chapter 20, Hank P., managing editor, and To E., and that's going to be readen by Azell. [01:38:46.479 – 01:38:48.700] And if you'd like to contact Mr. [01:38:48.700 – 01:38:50.880] Scherberg, I'll put those details in the chat again. [01:38:50.880 – 01:38:52.880] But for now I'm gonna turn the meeting back to Bill. [01:38:52.880 – 01:38:58.840] And Bill, will you close for us in, um, maybe use a prayer of your choice or something? [01:38:58.840 – 01:39:01.720] Well, is this the right one? [01:39:01.720 – 01:39:02.690] Have I got the right one up?

[01:39:02.690 – 01:39:08.880] First, before you do it, let me, let me just do this, Bill, before you, before you, um, say it, 'cause I just copied this off the internet. [01:39:08.880 – 01:39:11.020] Oh, there you go. [01:39:11.020 – 01:39:12.000] Bill, is this the right one? [01:39:12.000 – 01:39:14.220] That looks pretty good. [01:39:14.220 – 01:39:16.200] This is what I… [01:39:16.200 – 01:39:19.880] This is when, when, when we close our meetings in- It is … [01:39:19.880 – 01:39:26.660] any AA meeting I go to, you know, people say what they say, and they say, "Or a silent prayer of your choice." This is the silent prayer of my choice that I do.

[01:39:26.660 – 01:39:29.160] It's the evening gatha. [01:39:29.160 – 01:39:31.160] It's a Buddhist prayer. [01:39:31.160 – 01:39:32.929] Floyd, beg your pardon, beg your pardon, beg your pardon. [01:39:32.929 – 01:39:34.400] I'm pressed the wrong… [01:39:34.400 – 01:39:34.910] There you go. [01:39:34.910 – 01:39:34.989] Can you hear? [01:39:34.989 – 01:39:35.160] Sorry.

[01:39:35.160 – 01:39:35.540] Can you hear it in? [01:39:35.540 – 01:39:43.070] So we'll have a moment of silence followed by the evening gatha or the silent prayer of your choice. [01:39:43.070 – 01:39:49.860] Let me respectfully remind you that life and death are of supreme importance. [01:39:49.860 – 01:39:53.760] Time swiftly passes by and opportunity is lost. [01:39:53.760 – 01:39:57.300] Each of us should strive to awaken, awaken. [01:39:57.300 – 01:39:58.900] Take heed. [01:39:58.900 – 01:40:01.940] This night your days are diminished by one.

[01:40:01.940 – 01:40:04.360] Do not squander your life. [01:40:04.360 – 01:40:09.350] Thank you, Bill. [01:40:09.350 – 01:40:09.920] Thank you, Bill S.. [01:40:09.920 – 01:40:10.800] Thank you, everyone. [01:40:10.800 – 01:40:12.450] Thank you, Bill. [01:40:12.450 – 01:40:13.520] If you'd like to unmute. [01:40:13.520 – 01:40:14.020] Thank you.

[01:40:14.020 – 01:40:15.520] Okay, guys. [01:40:15.520 – 01:40:16.040] Thank you. [01:40:16.040 – 01:40:17.100] Thank you. [01:40:17.100 – 01:40:17.460] Thank you, Bill. [01:40:17.460 – 01:40:18.480] Thank you, Jim. [01:40:18.480 – 01:40:19.900] Thanks for the ride. [01:40:19.900 – 01:40:20.030] Thank you.

[01:40:20.030 – 01:40:20.290] Thank you. [01:40:20.290 – 01:40:20.799] Thank you, Bill. [01:40:20.799 – 01:40:21.520] Great. [01:40:21.520 – 01:40:22.860] Thank you so much, Bill. [01:40:22.860 – 01:40:24.110] Thank you so much, Bill. [01:40:24.110 – 01:40:24.111] Yeah, thank you. [01:40:24.111 – 01:40:24.220] Thank you, Bill.

[01:40:24.220 – 01:40:25.260] Thanks a lot, Bill. [01:40:25.260 – 01:40:26.899] Thank you, Jim. [01:40:26.899 – 01:40:28.860] Sure. [01:40:28.860 – 01:40:29.780] Wow. [01:40:29.780 – 01:40:31.209] Thank you, Bill. [01:40:31.209 – 01:40:31.800] Thank you, Riley. [01:40:31.800 – 01:40:33.560] Thank you, Bill.

[01:40:33.560 – 01:40:38.300] I think Bill has just left. [01:40:38.300 – 01:40:41.720] For information purpose. [01:40:41.720 – 01:40:43.760] Well, hopefully he'll be back next week. [01:40:43.760 – 01:40:46.640] How lucky are we? [01:40:46.640 – 01:40:46.850] Hopefully. [01:40:46.850 – 01:40:47.740] How lucky are we? [01:40:47.740 – 01:40:49.340] Mm-hmm.

[01:40:49.340 – 01:40:49.920] Wow. [01:40:49.920 – 01:40:53.120] I think it's akin to having Arnie K. in the room. [01:40:53.120 – 01:40:54.989] Yeah. [01:40:54.989 – 01:41:01.880] There were so many interesting topics that were not directly related to the chapter that I wanted to talk about. [01:41:01.880 – 01:41:02.720] Go for it, Hugh. [01:41:02.720 – 01:41:03.519] You're gonna kick it off. [01:41:03.519 – 01:41:05.820] And Jim Wortley is gonna chair this, I believe.

[01:41:05.820 – 01:41:06.730] Jim- What? [01:41:06.730 – 01:41:06.731] … [01:41:06.731 – 01:41:07.900] am I taking over your role? [01:41:07.900 – 01:41:08.760] Jump in. [01:41:08.760 – 01:41:09.979] No, no, no, no. [01:41:09.979 – 01:41:12.200] Who wants to, who wants to start something? [01:41:12.200 – 01:41:14.800] Who wants to start some stuff?

[01:41:14.800 – 01:41:16.980] Are we in the car park yet, or where are we? [01:41:16.980 – 01:41:18.000] Are we just finishing coffee? [01:41:18.000 – 01:41:18.680] Where are we, Jim? [01:41:18.680 – 01:41:19.500] Parking lot. [01:41:19.500 – 01:41:19.950] Parking lot. [01:41:19.950 – 01:41:20.240] Parking lot. [01:41:20.240 – 01:41:21.600] But anyway.

[01:41:21.600 – 01:41:25.540] Well, are we on the way out to the parking lot, or are we just finished? [01:41:25.540 – 01:41:26.510] Or are we out of the parking lot. [01:41:26.510 – 01:41:30.360] Actually, here in Mexico, we're in the estacionamiento. [01:41:30.360 – 01:41:31.200] Okay. [01:41:31.200 – 01:41:32.100] That sounds nice. [01:41:32.100 – 01:41:42.100] But anyway, whether you're in the car park or the parking lot or the estacionamiento or wherever [01:41:42.100 – 01:41:52.940] you are, uh, if you would like to, uh, bring up a topic to discuss, um, uh, this meeting is

[01:41:52.940 – 01:41:53.820] open, I guess. [01:41:53.820 – 01:41:57.230] And we keep the hands, we keep the hands up, if people wouldn't mind doing that. [01:41:57.230 – 01:41:57.909] We, we put up- Yeah. [01:41:57.909 – 01:41:58.140] Yeah. [01:41:58.140 – 01:42:06.960] If you wanna share, uh, yeah, raise your hand on the participants page so we don't get completely out of hue or- [01:42:08.068 – 01:42:13.328] This, that I have absolutely no evidence for this whether it's true or not. [01:42:13.328 – 01:42:18.528] But early on in sobriety- Hugh, before you start, Hugh, before you start, could I just tell people that you're being, still being recorded?

[01:42:18.528 – 01:42:19.668] Just to let people know. [01:42:19.668 – 01:42:19.678] Okay. [01:42:19.678 – 01:42:20.408] Sorry, Hugh. [01:42:20.408 – 01:42:21.348] Yeah, yeah, go ahead. [01:42:21.348 – 01:42:25.848] W- when I was early in sobriety, there was a, a guy I became friends with. [01:42:25.848 – 01:42:29.088] He was actually my first service sponsor before I even knew what that was. [01:42:29.088 – 01:42:36.318] But he had been at the 1976 General S. Conference, and he, uh, had met Bill.

[01:42:36.318 – 01:42:46.368] But he told me that there was actually a group of people at General S- at the General S. office whose job was to s- shadow Bill everywhere [01:42:46.368 – 01:42:48.608] and make sure he didn't get mixed up with women. [01:42:48.608 – 01:42:53.747] Yeah, that's- I would say today I don't believe that, but… [01:42:53.747 – 01:42:54.928] Yeah. [01:42:54.928 – 01:42:56.828] Yeah, I think I've read that too. [01:42:56.828 – 01:42:57.708] I've heard it around. [01:42:57.708 – 01:43:00.168] I think it's- A family story …

[01:43:00.168 – 01:43:01.648] yeah, it, it's around. [01:43:01.648 – 01:43:03.828] Uh, Co- Co- I don't know if it's… [01:43:03.828 – 01:43:05.278] Oh, it's Joel, right? [01:43:05.278 – 01:43:06.928] Yes. [01:43:06.928 – 01:43:08.208] I'm an alcoholic. [01:43:08.208 – 01:43:10.208] I'm an alcoholic, my problem's Joel. [01:43:10.208 – 01:43:13.087] I just, I, I love this meeting.

[01:43:13.087 – 01:43:16.568] I, I, I just wanna re-echo, uh, what Marsha said. [01:43:16.568 – 01:43:22.468] I loved, uh, what Marsha said, um, about the, uh, language in the Big Book. [01:43:22.468 – 01:43:32.568] Uh, for me, the context by, by, by reading and then getting the background from all you guys to, you know, to put it all in context has helped me beautifully to, [01:43:32.568 – 01:43:38.528] to really appreciate the beauty of this program and the, and, and, and the, the inspiration that Bill W. [01:43:38.528 – 01:43:40.668] got, which I believe is divine. [01:43:40.668 – 01:43:42.598] I believe the unseen- Yeah … [01:43:42.598 – 01:43:43.418] you know, chose Bill.

[01:43:43.418 – 01:43:44.308] I really do. [01:43:44.308 – 01:43:54.588] Because of those things which were his defects, which became the ability for him to sell this program to the world by using these stories, which he even [01:43:54.588 – 01:44:00.488] knew, knew enough to exaggerate, and to redefine, and speak for the group, and all these other things. [01:44:00.488 – 01:44:06.367] But as Marsha pointed out, the best thing about it is the language itself which takes you back… [01:44:06.367 – 01:44:06.778] I'm sorry? [01:44:06.778 – 01:44:11.068] You're okay if, Joel, someone has unmuted. [01:44:11.068 – 01:44:11.708] Go ahead, Joel.

[01:44:11.708 – 01:44:12.408] Yeah. [01:44:12.408 – 01:44:12.948] Okay. [01:44:12.948 – 01:44:18.007] So anyway, I love the, the, the context of the language which takes you right into the times. [01:44:18.007 – 01:44:23.848] And the whole beauty of that is you really get to understand the message because the message is… [01:44:23.848 – 01:44:33.928] Part of it is the context of the message, and, and then part of that means the lang- Which is why I just finished attending the, um, the, um, uh, area, area, area, [01:44:33.928 – 01:44:35.948] uh, 15 quarterly, which is my area. [01:44:35.948 – 01:44:38.308] I'm a district, you know, I'm a GSR and I'm a voting member.

[01:44:38.308 – 01:44:48.348] So I, I got to attend that, and we got prepared for, you know, guiding our trustee for the upcoming 72nd conference, which is, which I guess just concluded now or [01:44:48.348 – 01:44:51.767] is about to, about to completely conclude, and all these changes. [01:44:51.767 – 01:45:01.948] And I spoke of course at that conference about how the, my, my group's opinion was clearly do not touch the language in that b- I'm talking about the first 164 pages only, [01:45:01.948 – 01:45:04.088] but please don't touch that language. [01:45:04.088 – 01:45:11.808] Um, a lot of people complain and wanna write a, a, you know, an explanation and a disclaimer to different books and different language Bill used. [01:45:11.808 – 01:45:13.908] And, um, you know, uh, I see, I… [01:45:13.908 – 01:45:17.788] This really worries me, in that now they're writing another version in simple language.

[01:45:17.788 – 01:45:22.508] And of course the minute you change the language and you change the words, you know what happens then. [01:45:22.508 – 01:45:25.128] I mean, that's, that's the path to changing the meaning. [01:45:25.128 – 01:45:27.688] So anyway, I just wanted to echo what Marsha said. [01:45:27.688 – 01:45:28.788] I thought it was important. [01:45:28.788 – 01:45:30.058] Thank you for letting me share. [01:45:30.058 – 01:45:34.508] Anyone else would like to, uh, talk about that topic or any other topic? [01:45:34.508 – 01:45:40.868] Well…

[01:45:40.868 – 01:45:41.388] No? [01:45:41.388 – 01:45:42.237] All right. [01:45:42.237 – 01:45:47.418] Well, there, Hugh, if you wanna share, please raise your hand on the I- … [01:45:47.418 – 01:45:47.928] and speak … [01:45:47.928 – 01:45:50.768] I, I love, I love the Big Book writing too. [01:45:50.768 – 01:45:57.028] However, some of the words don't mean today what they meant back in 1939. [01:45:57.028 – 01:46:00.208] A good example is the word brainstorm.

[01:46:00.208 – 01:46:04.688] A brainstorm has a completely different meaning today. [01:46:04.688 – 01:46:08.568] So- Yep … [01:46:08.568 – 01:46:10.288] the meaning has already changed. [01:46:10.288 – 01:46:11.768] What, what- Yeah … [01:46:11.768 – 01:46:12.838] what, what changed? [01:46:12.838 – 01:46:13.508] Bill, Bill… [01:46:13.508 – 01:46:13.828] Yeah.

[01:46:13.828 – 01:46:14.548] Excuse me. [01:46:14.548 – 01:46:16.828] Bill clarified that later on. [01:46:16.828 – 01:46:26.828] It did, as it did, he noticed that it did change, and he clarified that when he rewrote parts of the, uh, the Big Book and when he wrote, uh, As [01:46:26.828 – 01:46:32.448] Bill S. It, and he took out the word brainstorm and he put in the phrase sudden rage. [01:46:32.448 – 01:46:35.748] Anyway, uh, Marsha, go ahead. [01:46:35.748 – 01:46:43.188] Well, well could I, could I just ask, uh, in response to that qu- uh, statement, uh, what are the differences? [01:46:43.188 – 01:46:45.508] What's the difference in what it meant then and now?

[01:46:45.508 – 01:46:53.328] A brainstorm now, if we sit here and we brainstorm an idea, it means we sit around and we get everybody's idea. [01:46:53.328 – 01:46:54.968] And, uh- Oh. [01:46:54.968 – 01:46:55.588] Oh, I see … [01:46:55.588 – 01:46:57.008] brainstorming an idea. [01:46:57.008 – 01:46:57.688] Yeah. [01:46:57.688 – 01:46:58.348] I get it. [01:46:58.348 – 01:46:59.628] And it, it had more meaning then.

[01:46:59.628 – 01:47:02.728] It meant a storm in your brain, you know? [01:47:02.728 – 01:47:09.448] And Bill, uh, Bill clarified it in As B. Sees It, and he, he says it, he, a, a sudden rage. [01:47:09.448 – 01:47:11.458] And, uh, Elise. [01:47:11.458 – 01:47:17.308] Hi, I'm Elise. [01:47:17.308 – 01:47:18.108] I'm an alcoholic. [01:47:18.108 – 01:47:26.748] Uh, and I wanted to respond to the point just made about, um, uh, not changing the meaning by not giving other words. [01:47:26.748 – 01:47:30.448] Uh, another way we could look at maintaining the meaning, though-

[01:47:30.716 – 01:47:39.576] is that the book clearly says that it is to set forth precisely how we recovered because we are too few to respond to all the inquiries. [01:47:39.576 – 01:47:43.976] So it's supposed to be a self-contained instruction kit. [01:47:43.976 – 01:47:54.256] And as we've all been talking about, it's lovely language from the late 1930s, but that no longer is a self-contained instruction [01:47:54.256 – 01:48:00.056] kit that people can read for themselves and understand for themselves without help. [01:48:00.056 – 01:48:10.116] And as we went through the RIP tab, the Researching I., Problems, um, something or another, uh, uh, of The Big [01:48:10.116 – 01:48:16.296] Book, we learned that the fellowship does not have an adequately literacy level. [01:48:16.296 – 01:48:21.576] The whole country doesn't have an adequate literacy level to understand The Big Book as it is, it's written.

[01:48:21.576 – 01:48:31.756] So if we're going to maintain that original goal stated in The Big Book of being, um, you know, a self-contained instruction [01:48:31.756 – 01:48:37.636] manual that people are supposed to be able to read by themselves, we have to reword it. [01:48:37.636 – 01:48:45.896] So I think it depends on, you know, which of the conflicting, um, goals you prioritize. [01:48:45.896 – 01:48:55.976] And although I love literature, and I had certainly read enough Edwardian and Victorian literature that I could read the book by myself, I, I very much, um, have compassion [01:48:55.976 – 01:49:05.976] for th- the number of non-college educated, even high school dropout members we have, and observe that a large portion [01:49:05.976 – 01:49:11.716] of our newcomers are high school dropouts when they get here, even if they return for further education after they're sober. [01:49:11.716 – 01:49:21.816] Um, a- and they need to be able to read it while they still have a mush brain, and when they're in prison with no sponsor available to them.

[01:49:21.816 – 01:49:32.116] Um, there are, you know, the whole, the early pandemic was entirely locked down and it's, lockdowns have been really an increasing use [01:49:32.116 – 01:49:32.916] ever since. [01:49:32.916 – 01:49:36.356] Um, and then we have our remote communities to consider. [01:49:36.356 – 01:49:46.856] So I think there are lots of reasons to, uh, counsel us to have a version of the book translated [01:49:46.856 – 01:49:52.736] for supposed English readers, um, and give it to them the way they could read. [01:49:52.736 – 01:49:54.786] Thank you, Elise. [01:49:54.786 – 01:49:54.787] Th- thank you.

[01:49:54.787 – 01:49:54.806] Yeah. [01:49:54.806 – 01:49:55.796] Tha- thank you, Elise. [01:49:55.796 – 01:49:58.416] And, uh, now let's go to John. [01:49:58.416 – 01:50:00.116] Lots of people here. [01:50:00.116 – 01:50:00.166] Oh. [01:50:00.166 – 01:50:01.436] So try and keep it short. [01:50:01.436 – 01:50:01.866] My name is John.

[01:50:01.866 – 01:50:02.716] I'm an alcoholic. [01:50:02.716 – 01:50:04.396] Really brief on this topic. [01:50:04.396 – 01:50:14.466] I, it is my firm opinion and opinion of many people who I've spoken to over decades and decades, the big book should stay as it is written, [01:50:14.466 – 01:50:22.816] and if someone wants to write an, a newer one, write, and this is not an original idea, write a book called More W. Be R.. [01:50:22.816 – 01:50:23.536] Okay? [01:50:23.536 – 01:50:28.476] But I think the big book should be left as it is verbatim, 'cause it is a masterpiece. [01:50:28.476 – 01:50:29.536] Thank you.

[01:50:29.536 – 01:50:30.996] Thank you. [01:50:30.996 – 01:50:31.916] Go on to Marsha. [01:50:31.916 – 01:50:33.456] Yes. [01:50:33.456 – 01:50:43.476] Um, now that the discussion has taken this, uh, this track, um, not to belabor the point, but I, I do agree with [01:50:43.476 – 01:50:45.656] just the just previous speaker. [01:50:45.656 – 01:50:49.136] Uh, as far as, um… [01:50:49.136 – 01:50:57.536] Well, f- first of all, I am a non-educated, non-college educated high school dropout.

[01:50:57.536 – 01:51:02.016] Uh, but I am a lover of literature. [01:51:02.016 – 01:51:12.016] And I, a- and I do have this love for, for, uh, writing and for this literature, the program as [01:51:12.016 – 01:51:12.536] it is. [01:51:12.536 – 01:51:22.556] That being said, I work with a lot of newcomers, many of whom they find some of the, [01:51:22.556 – 01:51:29.536] the terms and the, the wording in the big book in 12 and 12 incomprehensible. [01:51:29.536 – 01:51:31.356] They don't, they don't even… [01:51:31.356 – 01:51:37.336] Young people don't even know what a lot of the things are, uh, that are being referred to.

[01:51:37.336 – 01:51:38.156] They don't even know. [01:51:38.156 – 01:51:40.586] They'd n- they'd never even heard of some of these things, you know. [01:51:40.586 – 01:51:51.196] Um, but I, I feel that, uh, as far as, uh, publishing a revised [01:51:51.196 – 01:51:57.636] big book as another edition, say, say a fifth edition, I would not be in favor of that. [01:51:57.636 – 01:52:03.176] Uh, I believe that the big book's edition sh- should stand the way that they stand. [01:52:03.176 – 01:52:08.696] And just like we have translations in other languages- Right … [01:52:08.696 – 01:52:18.356] we can have a translation in contemporary, uh, wording, uh, that, uh, that could suffice for modern times.

[01:52:18.356 – 01:52:19.196] That's what I feel. [01:52:19.196 – 01:52:20.576] Yeah. [01:52:20.576 – 01:52:30.336] I, I think that the, uh, what, what's being considered is, uh, a fifth edition as is with new stories in the back, blah, blah, blah, you know, as usual. [01:52:30.336 – 01:52:31.136] But- Not what I heard. [01:52:31.136 – 01:52:32.286] That's not what I heard … [01:52:32.286 – 01:52:32.916] with no changes. [01:52:32.916 – 01:52:34.406] Can you let me finish, please?

[01:52:34.406 – 01:52:44.476] And, but, uh, uh, to the fifth edition will stay as it is, the first 164 pages as [01:52:44.476 – 01:52:52.576] it is, and, but they are also considering a plain language, uh, version, uh, much like- [01:52:53.093 – 01:52:53.654] Marsha said. [01:52:53.654 – 01:53:02.994] To keep the, uh, the original as, as a historical document, and that's the way it is and, but then also doing a plain language version. [01:53:02.994 – 01:53:06.284] Go back to, uh, Joel in Miami. [01:53:06.284 – 01:53:07.484] I'm an alcoholic. [01:53:07.484 – 01:53:08.304] My problem is Joel.

[01:53:08.304 – 01:53:08.544] Yeah. [01:53:08.544 – 01:53:13.744] I didn't wanna go into all this, but, but let me just clarify so you, so you know what's going on because we went into all this. [01:53:13.744 – 01:53:22.604] There's 1,100 pages of background material aside from the 97 agenda items that, that have just been considered and will be done in a final report. [01:53:22.604 – 01:53:25.004] And, and you are exactly correct. [01:53:25.004 – 01:53:30.424] Uh, what's happening is the, the rewriting of the Big Book is not to be a new Big Book. [01:53:30.424 – 01:53:33.284] The Big Book will stay at the 164 page level. [01:53:33.284 – 01:53:35.924] The fifth edition will just have other stories.

[01:53:35.924 – 01:53:45.984] But there will be a simplified version of the Big Book, if you will, and that's what I was a little concerned about and referring to because as been, as has [01:53:45.984 – 01:53:49.644] been pointed out, the, the, the need for that is the change in literature level. [01:53:49.644 – 01:53:59.744] What I was shocked to learn was I always thought that the reading level of the American public was the eighth grade reading level, and that's how newspapers were written at the eighth [01:53:59.744 – 01:54:04.044] grade reading level except for the Wall S. Journal, which was a 10th grade reading level. [01:54:04.044 – 01:54:10.684] And that was my understanding up until I got involved in what's going on with this 72nd General S. contract. [01:54:10.684 – 01:54:20.224] It turns out, and hang on to what I'm gonna tell you, the reading level of the American public today is third grade. [01:54:20.224 – 01:54:20.724] Mm-hmm.

[01:54:20.724 – 01:54:29.124] And in the background material they pointed out that when they first started the, this idea and when it first got in there, they thought the reading level was fifth grade. [01:54:29.124 – 01:54:33.104] They have now even changed it to third grade reading level. [01:54:33.104 – 01:54:43.184] And I'm sitting to myself saying, "Talk about dumbing something down." But I do understand the idea of getting the message across, and I promise you very clearly that that [01:54:43.184 – 01:54:46.684] is a separate agenda item and it will not be called the Big Book. [01:54:46.684 – 01:54:52.184] It will be, you know, with a separate title called a simplified version or whatever they come up with exactly. [01:54:52.184 – 01:54:56.444] So it is never meant to, to, uh, replace. [01:54:56.444 – 01:54:57.484] Thank G. for that.

[01:54:57.484 – 01:55:07.504] But as you all know, and George We- Orwell pointed out in the book 1984, the first thing you wanna do is change the language, change the meaning of the words, and w- here [01:55:07.504 – 01:55:08.254] we go, folks. [01:55:08.254 – 01:55:10.633] So that, that, and that's why my- That's… [01:55:10.633 – 01:55:10.934] Thanks. [01:55:10.934 – 01:55:11.214] Let- … [01:55:11.214 – 01:55:11.215] my concern is that … [01:55:11.215 – 01:55:14.724] let's, let's go on to, uh, to, uh, Burt R.

[01:55:14.724 – 01:55:15.724] Thank you. [01:55:15.724 – 01:55:20.944] You have to unmute yourself. [01:55:20.944 – 01:55:25.344] Thank you. [01:55:25.344 – 01:55:26.944] My name is Burt R. [01:55:26.944 – 01:55:27.904] I'm an alcoholic. [01:55:27.904 – 01:55:38.304] Um, so as, uh, as been pointed out here by Marsha very well that this is to be treated as a translation. [01:55:38.304 – 01:55:39.204] Mm-hmm.

[01:55:39.204 – 01:55:40.924] That is what has been passed. [01:55:40.924 – 01:55:43.904] Everything else is simply hearsay. [01:55:43.904 – 01:55:44.624] Mm-hmm. [01:55:44.624 – 01:55:45.184] You know? [01:55:45.184 – 01:55:48.144] And it is not a revision of the Big Book. [01:55:48.144 – 01:55:49.724] I don't care what anyone says. [01:55:49.724 – 01:55:54.064] That is not what's up for offer here.

[01:55:54.064 – 01:56:03.084] It is, it is to be treated just as the 78 other translations of the Big Book of Alcoholics Anonymous. [01:56:03.084 – 01:56:05.104] Now, if it's a third… [01:56:05.104 – 01:56:05.364] It… [01:56:05.364 – 01:56:14.224] What is on now is being written or considered to be written at a fifth grade level. [01:56:14.224 – 01:56:17.124] That was the compromise, you know? [01:56:17.124 – 01:56:23.984] And anything that makes the literature more accessible is perfect by me. [01:56:23.984 – 01:56:33.944] You know, we are closing our doors to people simply by not acknowledging that no one talks like this anymore.

[01:56:33.944 – 01:56:35.084] We can read it. [01:56:35.084 – 01:56:36.144] I can read it. [01:56:36.144 – 01:56:37.244] I'm well-read. [01:56:37.244 – 01:56:45.204] I know what is being said, but someone else coming in the room might not, and that's who we have to think of. [01:56:45.204 – 01:56:49.584] We cannot stay solely thinking of ourselves. [01:56:49.584 – 01:56:55.704] We have to think of the person who is not coming in that room because they're put off by the literature. [01:56:55.704 – 01:56:56.684] You know?

[01:56:56.684 – 01:56:56.834] Yeah. [01:56:56.834 – 01:56:58.264] And, and counting on… [01:56:58.264 – 01:57:04.424] Having to count on another person to translate a book that's going to save their lives? [01:57:04.424 – 01:57:06.224] Nonsense. [01:57:06.224 – 01:57:07.124] Nonsense. [01:57:07.124 – 01:57:07.444] All right. [01:57:07.444 – 01:57:07.704] That…

[01:57:07.704 – 01:57:07.853] Yeah. [01:57:07.853 – 01:57:08.864] So we- Thanks … [01:57:08.864 – 01:57:09.464] we just… [01:57:09.464 – 01:57:11.363] Yeah. [01:57:11.363 – 01:57:12.024] Thank you. [01:57:12.024 – 01:57:12.664] Good. [01:57:12.664 – 01:57:13.164] Thank you, Burt.

[01:57:13.164 – 01:57:14.304] Got a lot of people here. [01:57:14.304 – 01:57:14.944] Uh, Eddie. [01:57:14.944 – 01:57:16.244] Eddie G. [01:57:16.244 – 01:57:18.124] Yes. [01:57:18.124 – 01:57:26.184] Um, I, I, I just found, found out about this process yesterday from a past trustee. [01:57:26.184 – 01:57:29.024] Um, and he mentioned this. [01:57:29.024 – 01:57:31.764] The, the AA World S., Inc.

[01:57:31.764 – 01:57:36.424] looks after translation and copyrights. [01:57:36.424 – 01:57:46.784] So when, when they, when the advisory action was, uh, you know, to translate, uh, to create [01:57:46.784 – 01:57:55.324] a plain and sing- simple language, when it's a translation it doesn't have to be passed as a conference approved literature. [01:57:55.324 – 01:57:57.344] It, it, it… [01:57:57.344 – 01:57:58.964] Just AA World S., Inc. [01:57:58.964 – 01:58:01.364] and the trustees look after it and that's it. [01:58:01.364 – 01:58:11.664] So the discussion at the general service conference this past week will be that it's made sure that the delegates

[01:58:11.664 – 01:58:15.474] and all the other, you know, staff workers and trustees are able- [01:58:15.612 – 01:58:22.392] To discuss this and make it a conference approved book. [01:58:22.392 – 01:58:26.852] Because, uh, i- like I said, when, when the trustee, the guy Billy N. [01:58:26.852 – 01:58:27.512] mentioned that. [01:58:27.512 – 01:58:33.012] When it, when it's a tr- a translation, it doesn't have to be passed at the conference, uh, floor. [01:58:33.012 – 01:58:34.752] So anyways, that's it. [01:58:34.752 – 01:58:35.172] Thanks.

[01:58:35.172 – 01:58:36.612] Tha- thanks, Eddie. [01:58:36.612 – 01:58:37.732] Azell. [01:58:37.732 – 01:58:43.992] Thank you. [01:58:43.992 – 01:58:50.872] Uh, and thank you all for your comments, uh, and this lively discussion. [01:58:50.872 – 01:59:00.892] The, uh, Big Book Plain L. is going to [01:59:00.892 – 01:59:02.072] be a separate book. [01:59:02.072 – 01:59:07.952] That's an ac- that's an action item at the GSO this year.

[01:59:07.952 – 01:59:18.052] The other difference that's going to occur with the fifth edition, or what is an [01:59:18.052 – 01:59:27.372] action item, is placing the doctor's opinion back to page one as it was in the original. [01:59:27.372 – 01:59:36.792] And it speaks to the point of people's ability to read today. [01:59:36.792 – 01:59:46.792] Some people can't read the Roman numerals, don't understand what the Roman numerals mean, and it keeps in [01:59:46.792 – 01:59:56.892] line with what we know about step one, which is supposed to be a part of Bill's [01:59:56.892 – 01:59:59.192] story being step one. [01:59:59.192 – 02:00:06.892] And to separate the doctor's opinion from Bill's story gives us incomplete information.

[02:00:06.892 – 02:00:15.492] Now, when we talk about translations, we have to also talk about having a language. [02:00:15.492 – 02:00:22.472] Some of us in America don't have a language to translate to. [02:00:22.472 – 02:00:32.512] So those are some of the things that people who understand that have to step up to the plate and talk about in terms of [02:00:32.512 – 02:00:34.972] that piece about translation. [02:00:34.972 – 02:00:35.792] Thank you. [02:00:35.792 – 02:00:37.212] Thank you, Azell. [02:00:37.212 – 02:00:39.052] And back to Dan.

[02:00:39.052 – 02:00:41.892] Yeah. [02:00:41.892 – 02:00:42.552] Thanks, Jim. [02:00:42.552 – 02:00:51.992] Uh, yeah, and given the landscape in my head, I could be confused for being either a, an elder statesman or a bleeding beacon. [02:00:51.992 – 02:00:53.892] And on me, though, I'm pretty new to this game. [02:00:53.892 – 02:00:55.612] I didn't come in till about seven years ago. [02:00:55.612 – 02:01:02.792] But, uh, uh, you know, the, the, the… [02:01:02.792 – 02:01:09.752] probably the most dangerous w- words of all time are we've always done it this way, and there's some others too.

[02:01:09.752 – 02:01:12.452] And, and that goes on about change for the sake of change. [02:01:12.452 – 02:01:22.472] But, but something that, uh, that interests me, I've helped a couple of boys wander through this book and, uh, and I [02:01:22.472 – 02:01:28.492] really do believe you, you do not have to understand every word of the song to hear the music. [02:01:28.492 – 02:01:34.912] And, uh, and you know, there's, there's the other side of the coin, of course. [02:01:34.912 – 02:01:37.451] Uh, and that's tradition. [02:01:37.451 – 02:01:41.752] You know, it's about keeping the fire alive. [02:01:41.752 – 02:01:43.972] It's not about worshiping the ashes.

[02:01:43.972 – 02:01:47.892] And if the little twitches need to be done here and there, so be it. [02:01:47.892 – 02:01:48.632] Thanks very much. [02:01:48.632 – 02:01:49.332] Thanks, everyone. [02:01:49.332 – 02:01:50.292] It's been a great meeting. [02:01:50.292 – 02:01:50.912] Thanks, Jim. [02:01:50.912 – 02:01:51.652] Thanks, David. [02:01:51.652 – 02:01:52.532] See you tomorrow.

[02:01:52.532 – 02:01:54.012] Thanks, Dan. [02:01:54.012 – 02:01:56.332] Nick, go ahead. [02:01:56.332 – 02:01:57.932] Yeah, I'm Nick. [02:01:57.932 – 02:01:58.772] I'm an alcoholic. [02:01:58.772 – 02:02:02.752] Well, I, I just don't get this, you know. [02:02:02.752 – 02:02:04.652] I really don't. [02:02:04.652 – 02:02:10.012] You know, there's a, there's a saying that I, I normally use, backward thinking gets backward answers, you know.

[02:02:10.012 – 02:02:14.252] You know, are people not turning up to Alcoholics Anonymous because they can't read the Big Book? [02:02:14.252 – 02:02:16.292] I, I've never come across that. [02:02:16.292 – 02:02:21.152] You know, are people leaving meetings saying that they don't understand the literature? [02:02:21.152 – 02:02:22.272] You know, no. [02:02:22.272 – 02:02:30.392] You know, you know, people are getting well in Alcoholics Anonymous with using the same 164 pages of the book, you know. [02:02:30.392 – 02:02:33.292] And we are the interpreters, you know. [02:02:33.292 – 02:02:34.812] I, I, I live in the UK.

[02:02:34.812 – 02:02:35.092] I… [02:02:35.092 – 02:02:44.552] my language in, in London is very different to someone's language in Newcastle or Coventry or in America or, or other parts around the world. [02:02:44.552 – 02:02:52.392] We are the people that translate the Big Book for our own experiences, and we're the ones that are passing on the message through that means. [02:02:52.392 – 02:02:53.612] And I, and I… [02:02:53.612 – 02:02:56.102] You know, what's this new book gonna be called? [02:02:56.102 – 02:02:57.892] The Dummies Guide to the 12 Steps? [02:02:57.892 – 02:02:59.592] You know, how patronizing is that?

[02:02:59.592 – 02:03:02.212] You know, it's really, really stupid. [02:03:02.212 – 02:03:05.892] You know, is our primary purpose in helping other people? [02:03:05.892 – 02:03:06.752] Yes, it is. [02:03:06.752 – 02:03:08.652] It's not about rewriting literature. [02:03:08.652 – 02:03:10.572] It's not rewriting the story. [02:03:10.572 – 02:03:15.432] It's going out there and doing the legwork and helping other people, you know. [02:03:15.432 – 02:03:17.572] And those peop- You know, it's not about grades.

[02:03:17.572 – 02:03:19.492] You know, I have trouble reading. [02:03:19.492 – 02:03:22.392] Probably the biggest book I've ever read is the Big Book itself. [02:03:22.392 – 02:03:27.271] You know, there's other alternatives, you know, but it's about our service. [02:03:27.271 – 02:03:30.452] It's not about rewriting literature for me, you know. [02:03:30.452 – 02:03:32.372] And I, I just find this is crazy. [02:03:32.372 – 02:03:34.472] It's a crazy discussion to have. [02:03:34.472 – 02:03:37.692] You know, we should be looking to, like, where are we not…

[02:03:37.692 – 02:03:38.021] where can- [02:03:38.140 – 02:03:39.800] We'd be working where we're not working. [02:03:39.800 – 02:03:48.080] I think that's more of a question that we should be asking ourselves, not about literature All right, thank you. [02:03:48.080 – 02:03:49.360] And back to Elise. [02:03:49.360 – 02:03:51.640] Hi. [02:03:51.640 – 02:03:57.960] Um, I, I would, uh, I, I commend you for that perspective on where are we not working. [02:03:57.960 – 02:04:04.340] The problem I would point out is in the prisons we can't get into, what are they supposed to do?

[02:04:04.340 – 02:04:14.740] And I originally wanted to respond to Eddie's comment coming from last night's service manual study that, uh, I believe Billy said that he was hoping that the conference would discuss [02:04:14.740 – 02:04:14.900] it. [02:04:14.900 – 02:04:25.320] Um, in my other conversations with him, though, we've talked about being more proactive, and our district will be taking a motion to area, uh, asking [02:04:25.320 – 02:04:31.200] that the whole conference review the book rather than just the nine members of the literature committee. [02:04:31.200 – 02:04:34.160] And actually, they don't even have to approve it. [02:04:34.160 – 02:04:41.140] Since it's a translation, that's entirely up to GSO unless we get an advisory action in there requiring greater review. [02:04:41.140 – 02:04:42.780] Um, and I've…

[02:04:42.780 – 02:04:52.860] Given some of the things that have, uh, slid by lately, like our new Experience H. Taught Us 12 Traditions pamphlet, [02:04:52.860 – 02:04:57.160] I would certainly hope we're going to have a full conference review. [02:04:57.160 – 02:04:57.800] Thank you. [02:04:57.800 – 02:05:00.220] Thank you, Elise. [02:05:00.220 – 02:05:02.760] Anyone else have any questions? [02:05:02.760 – 02:05:11.880] Um, I'm going to, uh, uh, resign from my position here as, uh, well, Nick wants to talk again. [02:05:11.880 – 02:05:12.760] Go ahead, Nick.

[02:05:12.760 – 02:05:14.440] Yeah, sorry. [02:05:14.440 – 02:05:15.339] Thanks, Jim. [02:05:15.339 – 02:05:18.920] Just on this thing, you know, like, you know, about prisoners and things like that. [02:05:18.920 – 02:05:22.760] Do we assume that all prisoners are thick, they're uneducated? [02:05:22.760 – 02:05:24.800] You know, because that is so patronizing. [02:05:24.800 – 02:05:31.860] You know, and the other thing is, right, if you want to ask people about language, go and ask them what they need, what they want, you know? [02:05:31.860 – 02:05:37.540] And what, uh, most people I come across, like w- with a broad sector of people, what they wanna do is just get well.

[02:05:37.540 – 02:05:40.360] Right? [02:05:40.360 – 02:05:41.950] Uh, uh, Jim, you- All right. [02:05:41.950 – 02:05:42.580] Before, before I… [02:05:42.580 – 02:05:44.260] L- l- I wanna make my opinion. [02:05:44.260 – 02:05:47.059] I wanna- Jim, you can, you can raise your hand now, Jim. [02:05:47.059 – 02:05:48.759] Thank you. [02:05:48.759 – 02:05:49.380] Thank you.

[02:05:49.380 – 02:05:56.900] Uh, but I do not wish to, uh, continue the discussion afterwards, so I want to be the last one. [02:05:56.900 – 02:06:01.340] Not the last word, but I, I just don't wanna, uh… [02:06:01.340 – 02:06:04.159] Anyway, my name is Jim, and I'm an alcoholic. [02:06:04.159 – 02:06:04.720] Jim. [02:06:04.720 – 02:06:16.580] And, um, the, uh, about, uh, 4.83% of the world's population speaks English, 4.83%. [02:06:16.580 – 02:06:26.620] And, uh, a- and of those 4.83%, lots of them don't speak well, and, uh, lots of them [02:06:26.620 – 02:06:29.060] don't understand each other from country to country.

[02:06:29.060 – 02:06:35.380] And what we're talking and arguing about is English translation. [02:06:35.380 – 02:06:42.840] It's just like some people prefer reading the King J. Version of the Bible, and that's just fine if that's what they like. [02:06:42.840 – 02:06:52.200] And some people don't read the Bible, and some people read the New J. or the New A. version, or the, or the Sanskrit version, or whatever. [02:06:52.200 – 02:06:58.349] And, uh, my concern, uh, i- is, uh, primarily the newcomer. [02:06:58.349 – 02:07:07.220] As B. mentioned today, Bill, uh, Schaefer, when he came in in 1981, he didn't care much for the writing in the Big Book. [02:07:07.220 – 02:07:16.040] And I can tell you that a lot of people coming in nowadays, particularly millennials, don't care for it, you know? [02:07:16.040 – 02:07:26.360] And if our concern is the newcomer, and passing the message to the newcomer, then I think that we need to speak the language of the newcomer.

[02:07:26.360 – 02:07:34.600] And, uh, this thing about, uh, the Big Book, uh, is not understandable is not a new idea. [02:07:34.600 – 02:07:35.400] Dr. [02:07:35.400 – 02:07:37.100] Bob said the same thing. [02:07:37.100 – 02:07:39.180] You know? [02:07:39.180 – 02:07:40.380] D- Dr. [02:07:40.380 – 02:07:50.540] Bob, you know, had his group write these, uh, pamphlets, and there were groups all over the country writing pamphlets trying to explain what the Big Book [02:07:50.540 – 02:07:50.940] said.

[02:07:50.940 – 02:08:01.140] Now, we in 2022 are taking our mindset, our, quote, "You gotta take the guy through the," or the gal, "through [02:08:01.140 – 02:08:02.580] the, uh, through the book. [02:08:02.580 – 02:08:05.180] You gotta teach him how to do the steps. [02:08:05.180 – 02:08:11.320] You gotta run him through the steps and get him recovered right away." This is 19- this is 2022 thinking. [02:08:11.320 – 02:08:11.870] Yeah. [02:08:11.870 – 02:08:14.160] This is not historical AA thinking. [02:08:14.160 – 02:08:14.660] Yep.

[02:08:14.660 – 02:08:14.860] Yep. [02:08:14.860 – 02:08:15.520] You know? [02:08:15.520 – 02:08:15.530] Yep. [02:08:15.530 – 02:08:20.160] There was very little step work done in the early days. [02:08:20.160 – 02:08:22.000] You did it, it was done. [02:08:22.000 – 02:08:22.450] It was done. [02:08:22.450 – 02:08:23.200] And that's it.

[02:08:23.200 – 02:08:29.480] And, um, a- and so I, I think, you know, I, I'm not for… [02:08:29.480 – 02:08:31.160] You know, don't change it. [02:08:31.160 – 02:08:31.600] Leave it. [02:08:31.600 – 02:08:38.420] Leave the King J. Version of the Bible or whatever version of whatever book you, you want, you know? [02:08:38.420 – 02:08:48.080] But, uh, none of us, a- and n- I don't think very many Christians in the world today read the Big Book in Aramaic, you know? [02:08:48.080 – 02:08:48.780] Why? [02:08:48.780 – 02:08:52.000] Because they don't understand Aramaic, you know?

[02:08:52.000 – 02:08:53.520] And that was what it was written in. [02:08:53.520 – 02:08:54.900] Or in Greek, you know? [02:08:54.900 – 02:09:00.340] And, uh, we read what we can understand, and we take what we understand- [02:09:00.876 – 02:09:06.176] And we pass it on to someone else in the sa- in the language that they can understand. [02:09:06.176 – 02:09:13.676] I don't need to teach somebody a new language to be able to get that magic, uh, a- across to them. [02:09:13.676 – 02:09:19.436] And i, uh, uh, what, what someone else said, you know, to, to, to teach them the music. [02:09:19.436 – 02:09:23.316] Maybe they don't know all the words, but to teach them the music.

[02:09:23.316 – 02:09:29.495] And, uh, you know, so i- are we ever all gonna agree on this? [02:09:29.495 – 02:09:29.836] No. [02:09:29.836 – 02:09:31.936] And, uh, and that's just fine. [02:09:31.936 – 02:09:39.576] We have probably never agreed on much of anything throughout our history, but we just keep going, and we do it one step at a time. [02:09:39.576 – 02:09:45.876] And if you don't like your group, then you go start another one that, that you do like, and, and that's how AA grows. [02:09:45.876 – 02:09:49.296] It grows more through heresy than it does through orthodoxy. [02:09:49.296 – 02:09:52.396] So I'm going- Well said, Jim M. …

[02:09:52.396 – 02:09:53.036] step down from it. [02:09:53.036 – 02:09:55.956] So- Jim, just- And I turn the meeting back over to you, David … [02:09:55.956 – 02:09:56.716] thank you, Jim. [02:09:56.716 – 02:09:58.436] I just wanna com- Anna to come in. [02:09:58.436 – 02:09:59.256] Jim, that was great. [02:09:59.256 – 02:09:59.676] Thank you. [02:09:59.676 – 02:10:02.156] Anna, would you like to come in?

[02:10:02.156 – 02:10:02.996] Yeah. [02:10:02.996 – 02:10:07.316] Just, just quickly, 'cause I've been sitting here listening, and- Mm-hmm … [02:10:07.316 – 02:10:17.336] one of the things that has come to mind for me w- w- one is that I cannot believe that the conference or, you know, the AAWS, or even [02:10:17.336 – 02:10:27.436] the general service office, or any of the people that are involved in putting our literature together, um, would do something to create [02:10:27.436 – 02:10:30.476] disunity in Alcoholics Anonymous. [02:10:30.476 – 02:10:32.406] I just don't believe that- Mm. [02:10:32.406 – 02:10:32.407] Mm …

[02:10:32.407 – 02:10:34.656] that that's, uh, will be… [02:10:34.656 – 02:10:36.456] That's that's in their hearts- Mm … [02:10:36.456 – 02:10:38.396] and that that's even an intention. [02:10:38.396 – 02:10:43.516] And I'm not saying anyone else has said that, I'm just saying that as a statement. [02:10:43.516 – 02:10:53.636] Um, I'm also a- acutely aware of a statement in my head that I've heard time and time again, particularly in the last two and a half [02:10:53.636 – 02:10:54.076] years. [02:10:54.076 – 02:10:59.396] Um, and I've heard it more then because I, I go to online meetings.

[02:10:59.396 – 02:11:02.536] I don't have access to in-person meetings. [02:11:02.536 – 02:11:09.236] So when COVID hit, I went to online meetings, and that was what was accessible to me. [02:11:09.236 – 02:11:16.596] And one of the things that I've been hearing in the last two and a half years is this idea that if, um, uh, if… [02:11:16.596 – 02:11:21.396] That AA, uh, it, it wouldn't explode, but that it would implode. [02:11:21.396 – 02:11:26.276] That it would end because of the disunity within the fellowship. [02:11:26.276 – 02:11:31.496] And arguments, um- Is that your background noise, Anna? [02:11:31.496 – 02:11:32.336] Yeah.

[02:11:32.336 – 02:11:33.656] Sorry, that's my oven. [02:11:33.656 – 02:11:42.216] Arguments like, um, uh, about the Big Book or the literature, um, makes me a little nervous because, uh- Mm. [02:11:42.216 – 02:11:42.376] Mm … [02:11:42.376 – 02:11:52.036] uh, that inches, to me, closer to disunity, which means it i- inches closer, uh, to the, to c- to complete division. [02:11:52.036 – 02:11:54.816] Uh, the potential of a complete division. [02:11:54.816 – 02:11:56.676] I don't wanna see that happen. [02:11:56.676 – 02:11:59.996] Um, and, and then- then to the other side, right?

[02:11:59.996 – 02:12:10.056] That, um, I have to trust that, you know, when you hear this level of disunity, that it is what it is, and that all of us eventually come [02:12:10.056 – 02:12:14.656] back together to our primary purpose, which is to help the newcomer. [02:12:14.656 – 02:12:22.436] Um, and so I have to trust in that, and not, and not get caught up in, uh, what I hear as disunity. [02:12:22.436 – 02:12:26.316] Um, so anyway, those are the two things that come to mind. [02:12:26.316 – 02:12:36.556] And trust me, when I came into the program, I had mistrust not only of everyb- of everybody in Alcoholics Anonymous, but the process of [02:12:36.556 – 02:12:39.996] how Alcoholics Anonymous works as an organization. [02:12:39.996 – 02:12:45.376] And I have learned through the guidance of many people, um, that I actually…

[02:12:45.376 – 02:12:55.596] And having looked at the history and looked at, like, different ye- uh, years of conferences, that I have seen time and time again how the conference has done [02:12:55.596 – 02:12:59.396] the best for the whole of Alcoholics Anonymous. [02:12:59.396 – 02:13:02.886] Um, and so I, I continue to trust in that. [02:13:02.886 – 02:13:04.296] So that's all I have to say. [02:13:04.296 – 02:13:04.625] Thanks. [02:13:04.625 – 02:13:06.576] And sorry for my oven going off. [02:13:06.576 – 02:13:07.736] No, that's, that's…

[02:13:07.736 – 02:13:09.616] Well, you have indeed, by the way. [02:13:09.616 – 02:13:16.856] Is anyone else wanna make a comment on that, um, or their thoughts on that really? [02:13:16.856 – 02:13:19.095] No? [02:13:19.095 – 02:13:21.056] If not, we can move on to something else. [02:13:21.056 – 02:13:21.676] That was very good. [02:13:21.676 – 02:13:22.196] Very thought. [02:13:22.196 – 02:13:25.596] Jim, I'm just thinking about a workshop for you to come up with language of the Big Book.

[02:13:25.596 – 02:13:28.856] Language of the Big Book. [02:13:28.856 – 02:13:31.916] Hey, I, I got four of them in process right now. [02:13:31.916 – 02:13:40.776] And, and, uh, language of the Big Book, well, I'll work on that when I- We must talk about it … [02:13:40.776 – 02:13:41.216] yeah. [02:13:41.216 – 02:13:41.486] Yeah. [02:13:41.486 – 02:13:47.776] I, uh, June 10th is, uh, the, uh, uh, New Thought- The New Thought movement. [02:13:47.776 – 02:13:50.096] I was thinking, yeah, that's just, that, that's good.

[02:13:50.096 – 02:13:50.226] New Thought movement. [02:13:50.226 – 02:13:50.436] Yes. [02:13:50.436 – 02:13:52.516] We've got the June 10th Founder's Day. [02:13:52.516 – 02:14:00.076] We've got, uh, a, uh, presentation on an expanded presentation on the New Thought movement. [02:14:00.076 – 02:14:09.516] Basically new th- what kind of took over and took the place of the Oxford Group because AA got rid of the Oxford Group pretty quickly. [02:14:09.516 – 02:14:18.016] You know, uh, you know, '37 in New York, and '39 in, uh, in, uh, Akron. [02:14:18.016 – 02:14:20.856] And even then, uh, you know, Dr.

[02:14:20.856 – 02:14:23.045] Bob said in January 19- [02:14:23.173 – 02:14:27.224] 40, we have finally shaken off the shackles of the Oxford Group. [02:14:27.224 – 02:14:32.684] And, uh, and there were a lot of things that they didn't much care for from the Oxford Group. [02:14:32.684 – 02:14:35.464] And, and a lot of new thought ideas. [02:14:35.464 – 02:14:37.364] New thought is Emmet F.. [02:14:37.364 – 02:14:43.464] You know, for example, everybody knows Emmet F. and, uh, his Sermon on the Mount. [02:14:43.464 – 02:14:52.464] And, and, uh, it's a lot in William J. and, and, uh, a lot of the early literature, uh, uh, was new thought literature.

[02:14:52.464 – 02:14:53.914] And, and it, uh, uh… [02:14:53.914 – 02:14:57.564] William J. called it mind cure, you know? [02:14:57.564 – 02:15:06.664] And it's positive thinking and it's, uh, it, it's thinking that, uh, you know, my mind, uh, it controls my reality. [02:15:06.664 – 02:15:08.224] And, uh, so… [02:15:08.224 – 02:15:09.714] But anyway, we got that one going. [02:15:09.714 – 02:15:10.564] What else have we got? [02:15:10.564 – 02:15:11.634] Oh, we've got a…

[02:15:11.634 – 02:15:21.344] I've been working, uh, last couple days on the UK presentation for, uh, the UK, uh, anniversary coming up, 75 years. [02:15:21.344 – 02:15:25.244] And, uh- We'll have to find a date for that, Jim … [02:15:25.244 – 02:15:30.024] and, uh- I think, I think we'll deal with us first, Jim, and then we kind of see… [02:15:30.024 – 02:15:32.104] Mike, uh- Yeah … [02:15:32.104 – 02:15:33.644] wants it at Recovery Speakers. [02:15:33.644 – 02:15:36.324] I can introduce you if that helps. [02:15:36.324 – 02:15:42.734] Wait a minute, that isn't how this was supposed- I, I, I'm kidding.

[02:15:42.734 – 02:15:44.114] You can give me a page or something. [02:15:44.114 – 02:15:45.734] I'll, I'll read something, Mike. [02:15:45.734 – 02:15:50.684] Jim, I, I was asked to do a presentation on the UK, um, AA in the UK, and I asked Mr. [02:15:50.684 – 02:15:52.244] W. to help me, but he, um… [02:15:52.244 – 02:15:54.943] I kind of got lost and Jim took it over. [02:15:54.943 – 02:15:57.924] It got lo- I kicked it into the long grass. [02:15:57.924 – 02:16:00.624] Jim found it.

[02:16:00.624 – 02:16:02.094] Yeah. [02:16:02.094 – 02:16:12.224] And, and I, I wa- I was working on one on, um, the, uh, uh, special in- not special interest, they don't call them special interest groups, [02:16:12.224 – 02:16:17.764] but, uh, uh, the presentation that, uh, Jackie did last week- Right … [02:16:17.764 – 02:16:19.614] was just absolutely excellent. [02:16:19.614 – 02:16:20.244] Special composition. [02:16:20.244 – 02:16:21.494] Uh-huh. [02:16:21.494 – 02:16:26.384] Special composition groups, was just, uh, absolutely excellent.

[02:16:26.384 – 02:16:31.204] And, uh, I don't see any reason to, uh, to try and compete with that. [02:16:31.204 – 02:16:41.404] She did a great job on, on all of them from, uh, uh, Black and African-American to gay to women's groups to, to the seamen [02:16:41.404 – 02:16:45.683] and the air, air, uh, pilots, and all of those- Young people. [02:16:45.683 – 02:16:46.524] Young, yeah. [02:16:46.524 – 02:16:46.574] Yeah. [02:16:46.574 – 02:16:51.744] Uh, you know, just a really great presentation on, on that. [02:16:51.744 – 02:16:57.724] And, uh, so that's, that's one of them we're working on.

[02:16:57.724 – 02:17:06.344] Uh, someone else has asked for a presentation on the, in, uh, May for the Washingtonians and the AA traditions. [02:17:06.344 – 02:17:14.564] Uh, so I'll be doing that probably one Saturday in May next, uh, next month. [02:17:14.564 – 02:17:18.004] I always let you know when I'm not being faithful to you, David. [02:17:18.004 – 02:17:21.704] I like, uh, I like this, Jim. [02:17:21.704 – 02:17:22.724] I like this relationship. [02:17:22.724 – 02:17:23.764] It's a good relationship. [02:17:23.764 – 02:17:24.584] That's your…

[02:17:24.584 – 02:17:29.344] I'm trying to record Jim's record, uh, our speaker from last week, should I say. [02:17:29.344 – 02:17:32.104] Uh, was that, when that link, should be, ought to be in that link. [02:17:32.104 – 02:17:36.903] And Jim, I think we could get you to do that again because there's no harm in hearing it from a different perspective. [02:17:36.903 – 02:17:38.783] Annie talked- What's that? [02:17:38.783 – 02:17:40.264] The one on the special inter- What's that again? [02:17:40.264 – 02:17:40.274] … [02:17:40.274 – 02:17:41.504] then, um, composition groups.

[02:17:41.504 – 02:17:42.204] Oh. [02:17:42.204 – 02:17:42.594] Oh, yeah. [02:17:42.594 – 02:17:44.184] Not now, but maybe in a couple of months. [02:17:44.184 – 02:17:45.924] Maybe in a couple of months or something we'll get you. [02:17:45.924 – 02:17:48.964] We got to keep you on your toes, Jim. [02:17:48.964 – 02:17:50.064] Oh, Nick. [02:17:50.064 – 02:17:51.164] Nick's got his hand up.

[02:17:51.164 – 02:17:55.684] But, but Jim, but Jim, as long as you remain my other half for my readings. [02:17:55.684 – 02:17:56.804] Absolutely. [02:17:56.804 – 02:17:57.284] Oh, yes. [02:17:57.284 – 02:17:58.014] What are you read- Absolutely … [02:17:58.014 – 02:18:01.464] you're reading- A- as long as you stay my better half. [02:18:01.464 – 02:18:01.713] Bless you. [02:18:01.713 – 02:18:03.153] Chapter 21.

[02:18:03.153 – 02:18:04.914] They're bored reading chapter 21. [02:18:04.914 – 02:18:12.964] You just, uh, you, you just have to tell me when we get ready, you know, you just tell me where you want to leave off and, and I'll pick it up and- Okay … [02:18:12.964 – 02:18:15.644] and, uh, talk about the dynamic duo. [02:18:15.644 – 02:18:21.224] Well, actually, the Three M., 'cause I'm sure L- Riley's gonna jump in and- Yep … [02:18:21.224 – 02:18:21.864] you know. [02:18:21.864 – 02:18:23.254] Do our footnotes for us. [02:18:23.254 – 02:18:23.684] Riley.

[02:18:23.684 – 02:18:24.094] Riley's- Yeah. [02:18:24.094 – 02:18:28.684] She's gonna have her work cut out for her because I think that's a footnote-ish chapter. [02:18:28.684 – 02:18:32.124] Shall we, w- shall we go over to Nick? [02:18:32.124 – 02:18:34.484] Nick in the UK, or back in- to Nick in the UK. [02:18:34.484 – 02:18:38.044] Nicky, you got something to bring to the table on, on, um, the big book? [02:18:38.044 – 02:18:42.183] Yeah, I just wished I'd, wished I'd, uh, come to this meeting last week. [02:18:42.183 – 02:18:44.503] I swerved it and went to a face-to-face meeting.

[02:18:44.503 – 02:18:45.183] You swerved it? [02:18:45.183 – 02:18:45.744] You swerved it. [02:18:45.744 – 02:18:46.784] Why did you swerve it, Nick? [02:18:46.784 – 02:18:48.104] Wait, what, what's, what's your reasoning? [02:18:48.104 – 02:18:51.154] Because I went to a face-to-face meeting and, uh, I should do it. [02:18:51.154 – 02:18:51.643] Okay. [02:18:51.643 – 02:18:52.444] I know, chuff.

[02:18:52.444 – 02:18:52.594] Okay. [02:18:52.594 – 02:18:54.054] But like, I wish I'd… [02:18:54.054 – 02:18:59.184] 'cause like, this, this meeting in particular is, like, bringing me back to the original set. [02:18:59.184 – 02:19:03.544] And, uh, next week I've got a meeting with the Oxford Group in London. [02:19:03.544 – 02:19:11.124] And, uh, you know, I had a phone call from them the other day, and, like, they're more than prepared to go through the archives to talk about the Oxford Group. [02:19:11.124 – 02:19:16.324] Uh, I'm, I'm, uh, uh, re-enarm- moral re-rearmament. [02:19:16.324 – 02:19:20.864] And they're now called, uh, Initiative of Change in the UK.

[02:19:20.864 – 02:19:21.014] Mm. [02:19:21.014 – 02:19:23.004] And they've got an office just up by Vauxhall B.. [02:19:23.004 – 02:19:26.684] So I've been invited up there to go and speak to them and look through their archives. [02:19:26.684 – 02:19:34.904] So if there's anything as regards the, uh, the setting up of AA in 1947, I'll, uh, get it off to you and, uh, pass it over to you. [02:19:34.904 – 02:19:35.604] Thank you, Nick. [02:19:35.604 – 02:19:39.144] So I'm gonna stop the recording at that point. [02:19:39.144 – 02:19:40.844] Uh, we, we've done well.

[02:19:40.844 – 02:19:42.824] Thank you everyone for being considerate. [02:19:42.824 – 02:19:43.764] Appreciate it.