Bill S. — Challenging the Creation Myths (June 24, 2022)

Bill S. — Challenging the Creation Myths (June 24, 2022)

Workshop Recording

Listen to Audio Recording

Transcript

[00:00:00.220 – 00:00:03.660] You're muted Thank you everyone. [00:00:03.660 – 00:00:05.880] My name is David and I'm an alcoholic. [00:00:05.880 – 00:00:10.480] Uh, I'd like to welcome you to this open AA recovery workshop with Q&A, and along with Stuart. [00:00:10.480 – 00:00:11.760] Hello, everybody. [00:00:11.760 – 00:00:12.350] I'm Stuart. [00:00:12.350 – 00:00:13.180] I'm an alcoholic. [00:00:13.180 – 00:00:14.190] Nice to see you all.

[00:00:14.190 – 00:00:15.490] See you later for the Q&A. [00:00:15.490 – 00:00:18.580] We will be serving as your co-hosts. [00:00:18.580 – 00:00:26.960] This is one of a series of workshops which has been inspired by recoveryspeakers.com, and it's hosted by the Saturday night AA group here in Camberwell London, SE5. [00:00:26.960 – 00:00:36.160] Now in keeping with AA's traditions, in particular tradition five, each AA group has but one primary purpose, and that is to carry its message to the alcoholics who are still suffering. [00:00:36.160 – 00:00:46.160] The main purpose of these workshops is to introduce and to develop ideas, new ideas, concepts, and hopefully to encourage participants to do some [00:00:46.160 – 00:00:47.780] further investigation on their own. [00:00:47.780 – 00:00:57.900] The common thread throughout has been a quote in step 10 in our basic text, text which says, "We have entered the world of the spirit, and our next function is to grow

[00:00:57.900 – 00:01:05.720] in understanding and of course effectiveness." Now tonight's meeting, I'm delighted to say I'm really tr- actually I'm more, I really am thrilled. [00:01:05.720 – 00:01:06.660] I'm truthfully thrilled here. [00:01:06.660 – 00:01:07.520] We've got… [00:01:07.520 – 00:01:15.690] This is from Challenging the Creation M. is the title of this, and it's from chapter one of a marvelous book, Writing the Big Book: The Creation of AA by, by William H. [00:01:15.690 – 00:01:18.280] S., who fondly is known to us as Bill S.. [00:01:18.280 – 00:01:20.200] We're just thrilled to have him here tonight. [00:01:20.200 – 00:01:25.980] Uh, I'm just gonna read this before I just go further on to it, and this is from, um, the very Reverend W. B.

[00:01:25.980 – 00:01:30.600] E., a trustee and past chair of the General S. Board of Alcoholics Anonymous. [00:01:30.600 – 00:01:35.440] And he said, "For many in recovery, Bill W. is a Moses freeing them from the bondage of alcoholism. [00:01:35.440 – 00:01:44.320] As a result, a variety of myths have evolved around him, some encouraged by his own efforts to tell the story and to sell the spiritual program of Alcoholics Anonymous. [00:01:44.320 – 00:01:54.420] Bill S. does a great service to the fellowship of Alcoholics Anonymous with his exhaustive examination of archival documents separating myth from fact. [00:01:54.420 – 00:02:04.400] The result is a clearer picture of the beginnings of Alcoholics Anonymous and the development of the Big Book, along with a rich and compelling portrait of Bill W. [00:02:04.400 – 00:02:07.100] Less myth produces a much better story. [00:02:07.100 – 00:02:14.840] This volume is a must read for any interested in the history of Alcoholics Anonymous." So privileged to have you here, Bill.

[00:02:14.840 – 00:02:19.220] Um, so just gonna point out that while we share at these workshop meetings in the Q&A, we will… [00:02:19.220 – 00:02:21.040] I'd like to say Bill is gonna stay for a Q&A. [00:02:21.040 – 00:02:26.650] It represents the experience, strength and hope of AA members and not, not to be taken to represent the fellowship as a whole. [00:02:26.650 – 00:02:36.340] If you're new to Alcoholics Anonymous, the AA 12-step proven program of recovery can be found in our basic textbook titled, of course, Alcoholics Anonymous, which we fondly call the Big Book. [00:02:36.340 – 00:02:46.380] Now, if you'd just like to unmute, we're going to just say a version of, um, w- well first off, Bill, I, out of, out of respect for Bill S.'s in the room, I'm just gonna do this one for us if that's okay. [00:02:46.380 – 00:02:49.460] We're gonna do the evening gatha, and we're just gonna do this. [00:02:49.460 – 00:02:55.480] Let me respectfully remind you, life and death are of a, are, are of a supreme importance.

[00:02:55.480 – 00:02:58.540] Time swiftly passes by and opportunity is lost. [00:02:58.540 – 00:03:01.360] Each of us should strive to awaken. [00:03:01.360 – 00:03:02.720] Awaken. [00:03:02.720 – 00:03:03.840] Take heed. [00:03:03.840 – 00:03:06.040] This night your days are diminished by one. [00:03:06.040 – 00:03:08.160] Do not squander your life. [00:03:08.160 – 00:03:11.640] So loving to be, just for today, being in the day.

[00:03:11.640 – 00:03:12.500] Okay. [00:03:12.500 – 00:03:17.060] Now if you'd like to unmute yourself, Stuart, I think they can on s- if you let, let people unmute. [00:03:17.060 – 00:03:18.400] We're gonna use this. [00:03:18.400 – 00:03:22.579] If you'd like to join in, please do, when we get into this language of the heart of Alcoholics Anonymous. [00:03:22.579 – 00:03:25.580] So using God as you do, don't, whatever, or don't understand. [00:03:25.580 – 00:03:26.340] God. [00:03:26.340 – 00:03:28.340] God- Please …

[00:03:28.340 – 00:03:36.660] please help me to set aside everything I think I know for an open mind and a new experience. [00:03:36.660 – 00:03:38.109] Amen. [00:03:38.109 – 00:03:43.440] And like all meetings around the world, we always think of those still suffering from alcoholic torture, and of course their family members. [00:03:43.440 – 00:03:44.320] Thank you. [00:03:44.320 – 00:03:54.220] Thank you everyone for your attention. [00:03:54.220 – 00:03:55.780] And with that, it's over to Bill S.. [00:03:55.780 – 00:03:59.120] Thank you, David.

[00:03:59.120 – 00:04:01.720] Let's see if we can do a share screen here. [00:04:01.720 – 00:04:05.800] There we go. [00:04:05.800 – 00:04:06.360] Good. [00:04:06.360 – 00:04:07.980] Good, good, good, good. [00:04:07.980 – 00:04:10.460] Um, my name's Bill S.. [00:04:10.460 – 00:04:19.739] Um, I realize I should probably qualify myself because a bunch of people don't know whether I'm in the program or not when they read my book, which is a good thing. [00:04:19.739 – 00:04:22.560] Um, I'm a, I'm a, I'm a 78-year-old guy.

[00:04:22.560 – 00:04:26.740] I, uh, professionally I'm a rare book collector and a rare book dealer. [00:04:26.740 – 00:04:30.520] As a writer, my first book was a publication history of the German philosopher Nietzsche. [00:04:30.520 – 00:04:40.540] Uh, that book was published in 1995 by the University of Chicago P., and nine years later, the Germans amazingly translated it into German, and was published by Schweizen [00:04:40.540 – 00:04:41.880] Company in Basel, Switzerland. [00:04:41.880 – 00:04:49.480] But, uh, probably more important to the people on this call, I've been sober and active in Alcoholics Anonymous since December 7th, 1981. [00:04:49.480 – 00:04:56.300] I've had the same sponsor for 35 years, and, uh, when he died in 2017, I replaced him with two other guys. [00:04:56.300 – 00:05:00.020] I talk to those people probably two or three times a week.

[00:05:00.020 – 00:05:03.600] I sponsor eight men, all of whom have long-term sobriety. [00:05:03.600 – 00:05:10.300] Um, my home, current home group is a, a meditation Zoom meeting, which I attend four times a week. [00:05:10.300 – 00:05:20.440] And although I have no supernatural elements in my life, uh, which is why we read the evening gatha, thank you, David, I get on my knees every morning with a laundry list of affirmations and at night [00:05:20.440 – 00:05:21.200] for inventory. [00:05:21.200 – 00:05:26.980] And I do some spiritual readings beforehand, and then formally meditate every morning and every evening. [00:05:26.980 – 00:05:27.570] So that's- [00:05:28.464 – 00:05:34.004] That's my, uh, my vita there for that.

[00:05:34.004 – 00:05:41.644] Um, so I wrote this book called Writing the Big Book, and we, we need to just touch on that briefly before we get started here. [00:05:41.644 – 00:05:43.664] This is my book, Writing the Big Book. [00:05:43.664 – 00:05:50.174] Uh, when it first came out and my lady Sarah first got her hands on it, she said, "My G., it's a bigger book." And there it is. [00:05:50.174 – 00:05:51.384] It's bigger than the big book. [00:05:51.384 – 00:05:54.184] It's, uh, 603 pages of text. [00:05:54.184 – 00:05:57.324] It's almost 800 pages with all the, all the backstory stuff in it. [00:05:57.324 – 00:06:01.144] Um, I started researching in September of 2007.

[00:06:01.144 – 00:06:04.704] I started writing in July 24th of 2010. [00:06:04.704 – 00:06:10.604] I continued to research and write, and then, and to the day seven years later, I finished the first draft. [00:06:10.604 – 00:06:20.764] That was polished and edited over the years by not only my beautiful wife, the lady Sarah, who read this thing over and over and over again, but I sent it out to six friends of mine, four [00:06:20.764 – 00:06:24.684] AA historians and two people not in AA for, uh, comments and edits. [00:06:24.684 – 00:06:28.544] And then it was published on November 5th, 2019. [00:06:28.544 – 00:06:34.444] And, uh, and so far we're about getting ready to do the fifth printing of that book. [00:06:34.444 – 00:06:38.564] So, so it's been selling well and makes me happy, makes my publisher happy.

[00:06:38.564 – 00:06:42.004] Uh, I didn't really think that I was going to be selling a lot of books when I did this. [00:06:42.004 – 00:06:44.384] I never sold many of those nature books, I'll tell you that. [00:06:44.384 – 00:06:49.364] But, uh, but fortunately, people are, people are excited about this book and they're, and they're, and they're buying it. [00:06:49.364 – 00:06:52.484] So it wasn't g- I, I didn't write it to make any kind of money. [00:06:52.484 – 00:06:53.924] I wrote it because I had to write it. [00:06:53.924 – 00:06:59.904] But, um, but I'm very happy about the fact that we're going into the fifth printing probably next month. [00:06:59.904 – 00:07:07.964] So first I wanna start off with a little word about historical research, which is what we're gonna be talking about, is what I discovered doing historical research.

[00:07:07.964 – 00:07:15.124] Uh, the historian's ever elusive goal is what really happened, and that means investigating and collating reams and reams and reams of raw data. [00:07:15.124 – 00:07:20.124] And you gotta create a credible narrative, but you gotta do it without any preexisting agenda. [00:07:20.124 – 00:07:22.384] You just gotta go where the data takes you. [00:07:22.384 – 00:07:28.184] And that was a little bit of a shocking thing as I was doing this stuff for all those years down at GSO and other places. [00:07:28.184 – 00:07:31.244] When I say raw data, I mean those contemporary documents. [00:07:31.244 – 00:07:39.384] In my case, we're talking documents from 1937, '38, '39, that, that, that, that rather the stories told long after the fact. [00:07:39.384 – 00:07:49.524] They're just, it, it's not to say that those older stories aren't necessarily true, but having primary documents that confirm those stories goes a long way towards making us feel confident

[00:07:49.524 – 00:07:52.244] that we're getting closer to what really happened. [00:07:52.244 – 00:07:59.144] Uh, in relation to early AA history, there's thousands and thousands of primary documents. [00:07:59.144 – 00:08:05.524] Uh, GSO offices down on Riverside D. in New York City, uh, Stepping S. in Westchester. [00:08:05.524 – 00:08:12.224] Uh, both of those places are within an hour-and-a-half drive for me, so I've been able to get to both of those places. [00:08:12.224 – 00:08:17.124] Uh, the Akron A., uh, Gale L set up and did an outstanding job of curating. [00:08:17.124 – 00:08:23.844] The R. Archive, which is a fabulous resource because early AA people were, were definitely hooked in with the R. people. [00:08:23.844 – 00:08:30.164] And B. University, which has the largest temperance collection of any university, uh, library in the world.

[00:08:30.164 – 00:08:37.124] And, uh, and they've got a lot of AA stuff there, including, uh, Clarence's stuff and Ernie K.'s stuff, and it's really, really, uh… [00:08:37.124 – 00:08:40.024] I, I need to go back there and take a look at some of that stuff again, I think. [00:08:40.024 – 00:08:47.043] Um, but the facts that get revealed in those documents just come out at you in bits and pieces. [00:08:47.043 – 00:08:50.353] I mean, you're reading something, you're reading something, you're reading, and then all of a sudden you're like, "Whoa, whoa, whoa. [00:08:50.353 – 00:08:58.044] There, there's an interesting piece of information." And fitting them together in a credible and coherent story, it's like doing a jigsaw puzzle. [00:08:58.044 – 00:09:00.384] It really, that's exactly what it is. [00:09:00.384 – 00:09:02.504] It's like how does this stuff fit together?

[00:09:02.504 – 00:09:08.504] Uh, sometimes they fit together the way I thought r- really happened and, and, uh, sometimes it just didn't. [00:09:08.504 – 00:09:09.404] It wasn't even close. [00:09:09.404 – 00:09:12.524] Sometimes it was just so far off the mark of the stories I've been told. [00:09:12.524 – 00:09:14.984] I often say I felt like a detective in the archive. [00:09:14.984 – 00:09:24.384] I was stumbling through neglected clues, bits and pieces, and facts of things that just didn't line up with many of the stories that I've been told for decades about early AA history. [00:09:24.384 – 00:09:35.104] That means that many of the stories in my history of early AA are frequently not the stories you might have read elsewhere, or in books that rely primarily on those long after the fact storytellers. [00:09:35.104 – 00:09:39.144] So the stories you m- or the stories you might have heard around the rooms over years.

[00:09:39.144 – 00:09:48.384] Uh, in addition to all those primary documents, we also have a huge amount of later writings and recordings that talk about early AA history. [00:09:48.384 – 00:09:54.384] The vast majority of these are by Bill W., but other early AA members are also represented there. [00:09:54.384 – 00:09:58.544] But we, and we also have several histories of early AA that have been written over the years. [00:09:58.544 – 00:10:05.344] So there's all this, this material that you gotta fit into a cohesive, coherent story. [00:10:05.344 – 00:10:10.484] Um, and there's a lot of contradictions in those materials, all those different materials. [00:10:10.484 – 00:10:13.904] Tonight I just wanna focus on four different topics. [00:10:13.904 – 00:10:17.664] David said we're gonna talk about the first chapter, but really I'm going beyond the first chapter of my book.

[00:10:17.664 – 00:10:19.284] There's four things I want to cover tonight. [00:10:19.284 – 00:10:21.464] There was a, there's a lot of things. [00:10:21.464 – 00:10:25.504] I, I mean, the first chapter of the book is called Challenging the Creation M.. [00:10:25.504 – 00:10:26.654] There's 30 more chapters. [00:10:26.654 – 00:10:31.524] Every single chapter takes on some sort of story that turns out not to be quite true. [00:10:31.524 – 00:10:38.604] Uh, but today, today I just wanna do this inspirational myth that Bill W. makes up, the story of A number three. [00:10:38.604 – 00:10:48.624] I wanna, wanna tackle an urban legend, the one where Lois says, "Oh no, but you stayed sober, Bill." Uh, there's a completely made-up story from all the lights I can find, that

[00:10:48.624 – 00:10:49.604] six step story. [00:10:49.604 – 00:10:55.304] And then I wanna do a little exercise in demythologizing Bill's story about how he wrote the 12- [00:10:55.648 – 00:10:56.048] steps. [00:10:56.048 – 00:10:58.488] So that's what we're gonna be doing today. [00:10:58.488 – 00:11:08.668] Now since three of those four topics come directly from our founder, before starting I need to emphasize that Bill W. is not always a reliable source for facts about early AA [00:11:08.668 – 00:11:09.188] history. [00:11:09.188 – 00:11:11.648] This was a big shock to me.

[00:11:11.648 – 00:11:14.068] It was a big shock to me. [00:11:14.068 – 00:11:17.008] So I mean, this guy's a great storyteller. [00:11:17.008 – 00:11:18.118] He's a great storyteller. [00:11:18.118 – 00:11:19.988] He's a terrible, terrible historian. [00:11:19.988 – 00:11:22.828] And there was, it's like you know when you tell your story… [00:11:22.828 – 00:11:26.688] I mean, when you hear a guy tell a story six months sober you get all the messy details. [00:11:26.688 – 00:11:36.708] You hear him tell a story when he's five years sober and it's like, it's a slick story about a s- a direct progression from abject horror to a spiritual life of

[00:11:36.708 – 00:11:37.388] sobriety. [00:11:37.388 – 00:11:37.827] And you know. [00:11:37.827 – 00:11:43.968] But, but there's all these messy details in all our stories, man, and, and they just get, and they get left out. [00:11:43.968 – 00:11:50.968] So B. W. was a, he was a consummate storyteller, and one of the things you do when you're a consummate storyteller is you leave out the messy details. [00:11:50.968 – 00:11:53.368] So I just wanna give you one example here. [00:11:53.368 – 00:11:55.388] This isn't one of the four things we're gonna talk about. [00:11:55.388 – 00:11:56.728] We're gonna do a little bit of work on this.

[00:11:56.728 – 00:11:58.908] So know, everybody knows the story. [00:11:58.908 – 00:12:07.888] If you kn- if you know anything about Alcoholics Anonymous history you know that in late 1934 Ebby T. shows up at Bill W.'s house and he brings him the message of recovery. [00:12:07.888 – 00:12:08.668] You know? [00:12:08.668 – 00:12:11.528] It's, it's the story that's in Bill's story in our book. [00:12:11.528 – 00:12:14.098] If you haven't read it, pick up the book, check it out. [00:12:14.098 – 00:12:15.008] It's a great story. [00:12:15.008 – 00:12:16.168] There's Bill's version.

[00:12:16.168 – 00:12:17.728] Ebby calls him on the phone. [00:12:17.728 – 00:12:19.448] Bill answers the phone. [00:12:19.448 – 00:12:23.248] Uh, Ebby comes over and, and they sit down at the K. table. [00:12:23.248 – 00:12:24.058] Bill's drinking. [00:12:24.058 – 00:12:25.308] Ebby refuses to drink. [00:12:25.308 – 00:12:26.628] He says, "No, no, no, no, Bill. [00:12:26.628 – 00:12:28.248] I, I'm not drinking anymore.

[00:12:28.248 – 00:12:32.088] I got religion." Bill s- Bill hears the message, uh, but he keeps drinking. [00:12:32.088 – 00:12:42.128] But he hears the message and it leads him to, to, uh, to, to the Oxford Group and, and to, and actually getting sober in December, uh, of, uh, mid-December [00:12:42.128 – 00:12:43.358] of 1934. [00:12:43.358 – 00:12:45.208] So this is basics of Bill's story. [00:12:45.208 – 00:12:46.148] It's a great story. [00:12:46.148 – 00:12:47.468] It's a great story. [00:12:47.468 – 00:12:50.708] Ebby told this story at least three…

[00:12:50.708 – 00:12:54.108] I got it heard in at least three recordings, and in telling this story in the 1950s. [00:12:54.108 – 00:12:56.208] One of the times Bill W. was even in the audience. [00:12:56.208 – 00:12:57.628] So here's Ebby's version. [00:12:57.628 – 00:12:58.238] He calls. [00:12:58.238 – 00:13:00.248] Lois answers the phone. [00:13:00.248 – 00:13:01.408] Bill doesn't answer the phone. [00:13:01.408 – 00:13:02.608] Lois answers the phone.

[00:13:02.608 – 00:13:12.738] Oh, and Lois says, "Why don't you come over a couple of nights later and have dinner with us?" Now clearly it seems to me, he didn't say this, but, but that Lois heard the story about [00:13:12.738 – 00:13:13.648] him being sober. [00:13:13.648 – 00:13:14.228] So yeah, yeah. [00:13:14.228 – 00:13:15.008] Come on over, man. [00:13:15.008 – 00:13:17.308] I got a husband here who's in the tank all the time. [00:13:17.308 – 00:13:22.348] So he arrives, and when he gets to the house Bill and Lois aren't even home. [00:13:22.348 – 00:13:23.528] He gets let in by Mr.

[00:13:23.528 – 00:13:24.008] Green. [00:13:24.008 – 00:13:24.228] Now Mr. [00:13:24.228 – 00:13:31.188] Green was a, a, a family servant that, that her father, um, had, had, had, had, had, had for years. [00:13:31.188 – 00:13:34.288] He lived in the basement o- o- on Clinton A. where they lived. [00:13:34.288 – 00:13:34.648] Mr. [00:13:34.648 – 00:13:37.028] Green lets, lets Ebby in. [00:13:37.028 – 00:13:38.548] And Bill finally shows up.

[00:13:38.548 – 00:13:39.348] He's been drinking. [00:13:39.348 – 00:13:40.708] Ebby show- Lois shows up. [00:13:40.708 – 00:13:50.488] By the way, Bill, Ebby, Lois, and the woman renter, they're renting the top floor of their place 'cause they got no money, um, she gets invited down for dinner, and they all have dinner. [00:13:50.488 – 00:13:51.847] The four of them have dinner. [00:13:51.847 – 00:13:54.888] Not two guys sitting across the K. table. [00:13:54.888 – 00:13:56.848] Four people around the dining room table. [00:13:56.848 – 00:14:04.108] They all move upstairs after dinner to the living room, and Lois prompts Ebby and says, "So, Ev, well, let's hear about you.

[00:14:04.108 – 00:14:09.708] What's, what's going on with you these days, you know?" And Ebby talks about the Oxford Group until 1:00 AM. [00:14:09.708 – 00:14:13.228] Bill walks Ebby to the subway. [00:14:13.228 – 00:14:16.088] Bill hears the message but keeps drinking. [00:14:16.088 – 00:14:18.608] I love that story. [00:14:18.608 – 00:14:20.408] I love that messy story. [00:14:20.408 – 00:14:27.908] Well, the messy version, uh, of this story on several occasions, and he always acknowledged that the story you read in the Big Book is a little different. [00:14:27.908 – 00:14:36.008] He once glibly explained after those differences by noting that, "After all," he says, "You know, Bill W. was drunk that night and, and I was sober.

[00:14:36.008 – 00:14:42.048] So what do you expect?" I mean, Bill's, Bill pointing out that there were some details of the talk that Bill just doesn't remember. [00:14:42.048 – 00:14:43.518] Yeah. [00:14:43.518 – 00:14:44.708] Bill was drunk that night. [00:14:44.708 – 00:14:45.148] He was. [00:14:45.148 – 00:14:48.208] Even in Bill's story he says he was drunk that night and Ebby was sober. [00:14:48.208 – 00:14:53.708] "But in the end," Ebby said, "it doesn't make any difference what those messy details are because the idea is there. [00:14:53.708 – 00:14:56.528] And the idea happened to get into Bill's head." Amen.

[00:14:56.528 – 00:14:57.328] Amen. [00:14:57.328 – 00:14:59.608] The Bill, the idea happened to get into Bill's head indeed. [00:14:59.608 – 00:15:00.888] Thank G. for that. [00:15:00.888 – 00:15:05.028] We're all very happy the idea got into Bill's head, whatever the backstory is. [00:15:05.028 – 00:15:07.648] Now so you know messy details. [00:15:07.648 – 00:15:15.067] Bill was a willful myth maker, and I wanna go back to that story and, and, and talk about that just a little bit. [00:15:15.067 – 00:15:22.748] Bill took that important experience of Ebby coming over and giving him the message early, and he recast it into a parable, a myth with a message.

[00:15:22.748 – 00:15:30.768] I had a hard time trying to figure out why these two stories could be so, so completely diametrically different. [00:15:30.768 – 00:15:33.168] I mean, it just, it really bothered me. [00:15:33.168 – 00:15:38.608] I mean, I've been, I've been reading that story for, for almost 30 years when I stumbled over this thing. [00:15:38.608 – 00:15:39.688] It was just crazy. [00:15:39.688 – 00:15:41.708] So I mean, what's going on here? [00:15:41.708 – 00:15:43.488] What's, this guy a liar? [00:15:43.488 – 00:15:44.398] What's going on?

[00:15:44.398 – 00:15:45.548] No. [00:15:45.548 – 00:15:50.148] The parable, it was in no way complicated by the messy details of what actually happened. [00:15:50.148 – 00:15:51.088] That's what he's trying to do. [00:15:51.088 – 00:15:54.248] He's trying to come up with a story that gets rid of those messy details. [00:15:54.248 – 00:16:01.748] The point of Bill's myth created was to clearly emphasize one of the foundational beliefs of Alcoholics Anonymous. [00:16:01.748 – 00:16:08.108] Clearly, clearly, clearly emphasize one alcoholic could affect another as no non-alcoholic could. [00:16:08.108 – 00:16:12.508] Now that just jumps off the page at you when he tells the story the way he tells the story.

[00:16:12.508 – 00:16:15.168] It doesn't jump off the page at you the way Ebby tells the story. [00:16:15.168 – 00:16:18.468] He's upstairs with Lois and the, and the girl from upstairs. [00:16:18.468 – 00:16:21.128] I of- often wonder if Ebby was a ladies' man. [00:16:21.128 – 00:16:23.198] I often wonder if Lois was trying to fix him up- [00:16:23.312 – 00:16:24.552] up with the woman upstairs. [00:16:24.552 – 00:16:25.592] You know, what, what do we know? [00:16:25.592 – 00:16:29.711] I mean, there's, oh, there's, there's more messy details than there are in the messy details story.

[00:16:29.711 – 00:16:35.572] So, so I really, really had a hard time with this idea that W. wasn't … [00:16:35.572 – 00:16:37.892] W.'s story was bogus on some level. [00:16:37.892 – 00:16:38.932] Bogus. [00:16:38.932 – 00:16:41.032] And I'm not alone in this. [00:16:41.032 – 00:16:42.092] Here's Pass It On. [00:16:42.092 – 00:16:48.232] This is for, for you purists out there, for the AA police out there, this is a conference-approved book. [00:16:48.232 – 00:16:48.462] Okay?

[00:16:48.462 – 00:16:49.762] Conference-approved book. [00:16:49.762 – 00:17:00.092] And on Pass It On, it says, "Bill was never reluctant to stretch a fact for the sake of emphasis," and Bill often spoke, quote, "in metaphor rather than relating events [00:17:00.092 – 00:17:05.572] as they actually happened." Oh, it's, it's just a metaphor, you know? [00:17:05.572 – 00:17:12.092] It also said Bill never, he was never likely to pass up the opportunity to deliver a parable where he thought it could do some good. [00:17:12.092 – 00:17:12.952] Indeed. [00:17:12.952 – 00:17:14.452] Indeed. [00:17:14.452 – 00:17:15.512] Where it could do some good.

[00:17:15.512 – 00:17:17.312] Messy stories don't do any good. [00:17:17.312 – 00:17:19.092] Parables do good. [00:17:19.092 – 00:17:21.952] So he's a willful myth maker. [00:17:21.952 – 00:17:23.432] He just really, I mean, that's what he was doing. [00:17:23.432 – 00:17:33.572] And, and once I started to accept the fact that, that, that a lot of the stories W. told just weren't purely historically correct, uh, things got easier for me. [00:17:33.572 – 00:17:33.892] You know? [00:17:33.892 – 00:17:36.832] But it was, it was a tough hurdle for me to get over.

[00:17:36.832 – 00:17:40.692] I mean, Bill W. works on, walks on water in my life. [00:17:40.692 – 00:17:40.962] You know? [00:17:40.962 – 00:17:43.872] I mean, I'd be a dead man without Bill W., so. [00:17:43.872 – 00:17:48.712] He also, he did, there's a bunch of reasons why, why you can't trust this guy when it comes to historical facts. [00:17:48.712 – 00:17:50.892] He was deliberately self-deprecating. [00:17:50.892 – 00:17:53.222] You know, everybody thought that Bill W. walked on water. [00:17:53.222 – 00:17:54.312] They were all kissing his feet.

[00:17:54.312 – 00:17:57.232] It was a hard ma- it's a hard way to live that way, you know? [00:17:57.232 – 00:18:07.342] He was constantly changing the facts in order to counter his own tendency towards grandiosity, which he most certainly had, and to take himself out of the spotlight and to, and to tell a more inclusive story, [00:18:07.342 – 00:18:09.132] to spread the, spread it around. [00:18:09.132 – 00:18:12.192] So he's always doing, like, this, this whole co-founder thing. [00:18:12.192 – 00:18:12.962] You know? [00:18:12.962 – 00:18:20.612] Bill W.'s the founder of Alcoholics Anonymous, and there's a whole boatload of people that he said were co-founders, but Bill's the founder. [00:18:20.612 – 00:18:21.692] No.

[00:18:21.692 – 00:18:24.472] He, he leaves out all kinds of uncomfortable facts. [00:18:24.472 – 00:18:34.492] I mean, he, he, he, he, he leaves out any direct reference to the, the Oxford Group because the Oxford Group had gone in, in the tank on the PR side by the time the book was published, so we didn't [00:18:34.492 – 00:18:38.132] wanna be doing anything, and, well, we didn't want people to think we're Oxford Group people. [00:18:38.132 – 00:18:39.172] That was, be a bad thing. [00:18:39.172 – 00:18:46.412] And he leaves out almost all mention of Hank P., who, who was one of the most important guys in the entire story. [00:18:46.412 – 00:18:47.532] Why, why'd he do that? [00:18:47.532 – 00:18:49.612] Well, we'll get to that in a second.

[00:18:49.612 – 00:18:51.952] Uh, and he had a bad memory for dates. [00:18:51.952 – 00:18:58.372] And now I can't remember what I had for dinner last night, so I mean, you really can't throw too many rocks at somebody like this. [00:18:58.372 – 00:18:59.932] I mean, here's just one example. [00:18:59.932 – 00:19:06.372] Hank and Bill go down to meet the editors of Harper & Brothers in the first week of October 1938. [00:19:06.372 – 00:19:08.432] I can nail that down within three days. [00:19:08.432 – 00:19:12.512] It was either a Friday or the Monday or Tuesday, the first week in October. [00:19:12.512 – 00:19:19.652] Bill says, "Oh, it was in July." Another place he says, "Oh, it was probably in August." Another place he says it was around September 1st.

[00:19:19.652 – 00:19:21.192] Another place he says it was late summer. [00:19:21.192 – 00:19:22.932] Another place he says it was early fall. [00:19:22.932 – 00:19:24.672] Lois actually nails it. [00:19:24.672 – 00:19:26.052] She says it was September 6th. [00:19:26.052 – 00:19:28.232] People, it was the first week of October. [00:19:28.232 – 00:19:30.392] I got documents that bookend that thing. [00:19:30.392 – 00:19:33.112] There's no way it could be anything other than one of those three days.

[00:19:33.112 – 00:19:34.552] So let me be clear. [00:19:34.552 – 00:19:44.552] These criticisms of Bill's historical accuracy in no way, no way diminishes his towering stature in the history of 20th century spirituality [00:19:44.552 – 00:19:50.072] or in any way compromises the truly remarkable things he accomplished during his lifetime. [00:19:50.072 – 00:20:01.252] The fact that Bill elected to tell uncluttered and un- and instructive stories and parables rather than historically accurate facts can hardly be held against him. [00:20:01.252 – 00:20:04.912] In fact, Bill W., I mean, he wasn't a good historian, but he was a man of vision. [00:20:04.912 – 00:20:12.061] He had this grand, uplifting, universal, deeply spiritual and, most important, life-saving vision. [00:20:12.061 – 00:20:14.292] Bill wasn't preaching salvation in the next world.

[00:20:14.292 – 00:20:16.712] He wasn't preaching that kind of parables and myths. [00:20:16.712 – 00:20:22.632] He was preaching salvation in this world, in the here and now, and he was looking to save people's lives. [00:20:22.632 – 00:20:25.992] This was a man with a mission and a vision to go with it. [00:20:25.992 – 00:20:36.252] Had he not done the, all that storytelling, it's possible he never would've been successful in transforming his profound vision of widespread recovery into such a vibrant, [00:20:36.252 – 00:20:43.972] spiritually enriching, international reality, something that he most certainly did before his death in January of 1971. [00:20:43.972 – 00:20:47.672] So thanks, Bill, for telling those life-saving stories and parables. [00:20:47.672 – 00:20:51.932] I'm not gonna, I'm not gonna throw you under the bus as a liar.

[00:20:51.932 – 00:21:01.132] I'm gonna, I'm gonna, I'm gonna, I'm gonna praise you and, and, and appreciate you as a creator of stories that helped people sa- save people's lives, including mine. [00:21:01.132 – 00:21:09.072] Well, I never want to completely discount the truth of those older, those long-after-the-fact stories. [00:21:09.072 – 00:21:14.872] In the archives, I quickly learned that many of those hallowed older stories, they were just not historically accurate. [00:21:14.872 – 00:21:23.572] Discovering primary documents that confirm those older stories certainly made me feel more confident about that I was telling a story somewhat closer to what really happened. [00:21:23.572 – 00:21:26.392] It's nice when you get documents that say, "Oh, yeah. [00:21:26.392 – 00:21:26.652] Yeah. [00:21:26.652 – 00:21:29.312] You know that story he was telling in 1955?

[00:21:29.312 – 00:21:30.112] He g- he nailed it. [00:21:30.112 – 00:21:38.732] He got it right." But discovering primary documents that contradicted those later-told stories often proved to be a great challenge, both intellectually and emotionally. [00:21:38.732 – 00:21:42.792] It was a hard thing for me to be going through some of the things we're gonna be talking about here today. [00:21:42.792 – 00:21:46.652] Most especially when we get to the two sections on the six steps and the 12 steps. [00:21:46.652 – 00:21:49.792] I was just appalled trying to make sense out of that stuff. [00:21:51.024 – 00:22:01.044] In the end, I discovered so many of these contradictions that I ended up calling the first chapter of my book Challenging C. Myths, and as I said, we, we bang on at least one of those in every one of [00:22:01.044 – 00:22:02.664] the 30 chapters that follow.

[00:22:02.664 – 00:22:12.904] So for the still skeptical in you who have or haven't seen my book, I can only refer you to the fact that I've got 100, uh, 416 informational footnotes [00:22:12.904 – 00:22:20.284] and 1,570 citational end notes that can be found in writing the big book, The Creation of AA. [00:22:20.284 – 00:22:25.684] I do believe that, uh, that all that information is in there. [00:22:25.684 – 00:22:30.224] Now, I don't mean to say that the history presented in my book or what I'm gonna cover here tonight is definitive. [00:22:30.224 – 00:22:31.444] I'm not saying that. [00:22:31.444 – 00:22:35.764] New materials will surely surface, and some already have. [00:22:35.764 – 00:22:42.724] I had to make some changes to this last printing of the book because people, people brought things to my attention that I hadn't, I hadn't discovered by myself.

[00:22:42.724 – 00:22:46.064] My history is certainly closer to what really happened, though. [00:22:46.064 – 00:22:47.164] It really, really is. [00:22:47.164 – 00:22:54.144] But it's not, I'm not gonna say that it's, that, that it's, that it should be taken as gospel truth, because more will be revealed. [00:22:54.144 – 00:23:01.224] It's the nature of the beast of historical research, writing, and investigation, that more will be revealed. [00:23:01.224 – 00:23:04.484] And, uh, so please keep that in mind. [00:23:04.484 – 00:23:11.704] Having said that, tonight I'd like to focus on two cases of positive evidence and on two cases of negative evidence. [00:23:11.704 – 00:23:20.064] Now, uh, explaining some of what I've discovered in the archives and the challenges they pose to telling a more historically accurate story, closer to what really happened.

[00:23:20.064 – 00:23:26.144] Just for clarity's sake, I wanna say that positive evidence, I mean commonly believed stories for which I have discovered contrary evidence. [00:23:26.144 – 00:23:27.764] We'll see an example of that right away. [00:23:27.764 – 00:23:34.804] And when I talk about negative evidence, I mean stories that everyone believes, but there's no evidence whatsoever. [00:23:34.804 – 00:23:36.324] None whatsoever. [00:23:36.324 – 00:23:39.284] Okay. [00:23:39.284 – 00:23:41.144] Rock and roll. [00:23:41.144 – 00:23:45.544] We'll start with the inspirational myth, AA number three.

[00:23:45.544 – 00:23:47.964] Bill D. was AA number three. [00:23:47.964 – 00:23:50.924] His story is told in Four P. Harmony in A Vision F. You. [00:23:50.924 – 00:23:55.544] It takes up 15 paragraphs of the 57 in that particular chapter. [00:23:55.544 – 00:24:02.433] He, Bill tells a story about he and Bob going to the hospital and getting this guy, and going back a couple of times, getting him sober. [00:24:02.433 – 00:24:12.464] But in the forward to the second edition, it simply says, "Hence the two men," Bill and Bob, "set to work almost frantically upon alcoholics arriving in the ward at [00:24:12.464 – 00:24:13.824] the Akron C. Hospital. [00:24:13.824 – 00:24:19.724] Their very first case, a desperate one, recovered immediately and became AA number three.

[00:24:19.724 – 00:24:23.524] He never had another drink." It's a great story. [00:24:23.524 – 00:24:26.364] Now, Bill D. may have been the very first hospital case. [00:24:26.364 – 00:24:30.144] Bill doesn't say that, but I, I mean, maybe, maybe that's how he weasels out of this. [00:24:30.144 – 00:24:32.064] It was the first hospital case. [00:24:32.064 – 00:24:37.684] But we already had at least two well-documented and spectacular failures before they get to Bill D.. [00:24:37.684 – 00:24:38.284] Th- there's a Dr. [00:24:38.284 – 00:24:48.304] M. that Bill writes about in a letter to his wife Lois in May of 1935, and Eddie R., who gets talked about, you know, in A Main E., which is something Bill

[00:24:48.304 – 00:24:48.824] put together. [00:24:48.824 – 00:24:49.463] Dr. [00:24:49.463 – 00:24:55.764] Bob and the Good O.-Timers has, has, has, talks about this, and Mike F.'s book also talks about it in Four P. Harmony. [00:24:55.764 – 00:24:57.743] So they had these two spectacular… [00:24:57.743 – 00:25:03.724] Eddie R.'s the guy who supposedly chased Anne S. around the K. with a, with a butcher's knife, you know? [00:25:03.724 – 00:25:05.704] I mean, this is, this was good stuff. [00:25:05.704 – 00:25:11.104] But, so why is Bill playing so fast and loose with the facts here?

[00:25:11.104 – 00:25:17.084] What good does this particular parable, this, this, this, this nuance on what actually happened actually do? [00:25:17.084 – 00:25:22.144] Bill's very short story of AA number three encapsulates and presents three of AA's central beliefs. [00:25:22.144 – 00:25:28.123] This is what this man's shooting for when he tells these kind of stories, when he says this was the very first case. [00:25:28.123 – 00:25:31.304] It talks about the need to work with others. [00:25:31.304 – 00:25:34.024] You wanna stay sober, you gotta be working with others. [00:25:34.024 – 00:25:36.944] The fact that sobriety can be passed on. [00:25:36.944 – 00:25:40.824] This is a story about two guys going in and getting a third guy sober.

[00:25:40.824 – 00:25:43.424] And the fact that that sobriety can be permanent. [00:25:43.424 – 00:25:44.804] He never took another drink. [00:25:44.804 – 00:25:51.184] Come on, take, take another look at this brilliant short paragraph by Bill W.. [00:25:51.184 – 00:25:56.424] "Hence, the two men set to work upon alcoholics." You need to work with alcoholics, you wanna stay sober. [00:25:56.424 – 00:26:01.964] "The very first case, a desperate one, recovered immediately." Transferable. [00:26:01.964 – 00:26:12.343] And number three, "He never had another drink." W.'s just packing lessons about sobriety and about how sobriety works and how AA works [00:26:12.343 – 00:26:19.664] in that very, very, very short three sentences taken out of the, our, our, uh, the forward to our second edition.

[00:26:19.664 – 00:26:22.184] I think it's, that's a brilliant piece of writing. [00:26:22.184 – 00:26:25.164] You wanna tell a parable and you wanna tell a myth, bang, bang, bang. [00:26:25.164 – 00:26:26.424] There it is right there in front of you. [00:26:26.424 – 00:26:27.624] Good job, Bill. [00:26:27.624 – 00:26:28.884] Well-delivered message. [00:26:28.884 – 00:26:38.924] We always need to poke around the archives or whatever other fruitful sources we can find to either confirm or deny the accuracy of these myths and parables that Bill so frequently told, and I call this an example [00:26:38.924 – 00:26:40.034] of positive evidence.

[00:26:40.034 – 00:26:43.864] So there's positive evidence supporting a more truthful and historically accurate story. [00:26:43.864 – 00:26:48.764] We know from the letter from Lois, we know from Bill's other things, we know from Mike's book and from Dr. [00:26:48.764 – 00:26:54.264] Bob and the Old-Timers that, that number three was not the very first guy. [00:26:54.264 – 00:26:55.944] He wasn't the very first guy. [00:26:55.944 – 00:26:56.524] Who cares? [00:26:56.524 – 00:26:57.654] Who cares? [00:26:57.654 – 00:27:01.264] I love this urban legend.

[00:27:01.264 – 00:27:04.264] But you stayed sober, Bill. [00:27:04.264 – 00:27:14.264] There's an often repeated urban legend, I've heard this, I hear this at least twice a year in a meeting, that Lois W. was the first one to notice that working with another alcoholic was the best [00:27:14.264 – 00:27:15.564] way to stay sober yourself. [00:27:15.564 – 00:27:18.614] Despite having heard this story repeatedly over the years, I've- [00:27:18.748 – 00:27:21.188] Credible source proved to be surprisingly elusive. [00:27:21.188 – 00:27:26.028] In short, just because everybody knows a story does not mean that it's true. [00:27:26.028 – 00:27:30.308] There's a lot of these floating around AA, let me tell you.

[00:27:30.308 – 00:27:32.848] Here's what I've been told over the years. [00:27:32.848 – 00:27:37.688] Just before Bill W. left for Akron in April of 1935, where he hooks up with Dr. [00:27:37.688 – 00:27:43.568] Bob, he was really depressed and complaining about his lack of success in the previous five months since he's been sober. [00:27:43.568 – 00:27:47.868] He hadn't gotten a single person sober during the previous five months. [00:27:47.868 – 00:27:53.628] At this point, Lois wisely disagreed with him by saying, "Well, that's not true, Bill. [00:27:53.628 – 00:27:59.027] If nothing else, you stayed sober." Damn, that's a great story. [00:27:59.027 – 00:28:06.748] I couldn't think of a better way to start my chapter, Working W. Others, in my book than that story.

[00:28:06.748 – 00:28:08.628] But I needed a source. [00:28:08.628 – 00:28:10.808] Where'd the story come from? [00:28:10.808 – 00:28:11.968] I need something I can quote. [00:28:11.968 – 00:28:15.108] I got those 1,570 citational end notes. [00:28:15.108 – 00:28:18.707] I need an end note for this story, and there was none to be found. [00:28:18.707 – 00:28:23.948] Neither, none of the archivists at either GSO or Stepping S. had a source for that story. [00:28:23.948 – 00:28:28.528] I talked to Art S., I talked to Jay S., I talked to Dan C. and Kevin H..

[00:28:28.528 – 00:28:29.668] I talked to John B.. [00:28:29.668 – 00:28:35.688] I talked to all these guys that I know in the AA history community, said, "Please, please, please, I want to start the chapter with this story. [00:28:35.688 – 00:28:37.648] I need a source." No source. [00:28:37.648 – 00:28:39.367] No source. [00:28:39.367 – 00:28:44.428] I- I- I mean, Sally at, uh, Stepping S., uh, she would love… [00:28:44.428 – 00:28:52.608] She's, uh, one of those questions she gets every, with some regularity is, you know, "So what's, uh, can you tell me where that came from?" No, they can't find it anywhere in Stepping S. archive. [00:28:52.608 – 00:29:00.948] The earliest evidence I've found for anything like this story comes from a, Robert T.'s book, Bill W., which was published in 1975.

[00:29:00.948 – 00:29:03.688] Okay, without a single footnote. [00:29:03.688 – 00:29:05.948] I hate books without footnotes. [00:29:05.948 – 00:29:09.108] And he says, "There was, however, one thing she knew," Lois. [00:29:09.108 – 00:29:19.408] "Their efforts might not have brought about their, any recoveries, but no one could deny that the work was keeping Bill sober." Okay, that's the first reference to this Lois [00:29:19.468 – 00:29:21.508] light bulb over her head, "Well, that's not true, Bill. [00:29:21.508 – 00:29:28.708] You stayed sober." Contrast that lack of evidence with the lovely throwing the shoe story that was told by Bill and Lois W.. [00:29:28.708 – 00:29:29.928] You know this story?

[00:29:29.928 – 00:29:32.148] Um, I love this story. [00:29:32.148 – 00:29:33.978] One S.- They're going to do Oxford group meeting. [00:29:33.978 – 00:29:44.128] "One S., Bill casually said to me, "We'll have to hurry or we'll be late for the Oxford group meetings." Lois was, uh, messing around at the, at the mirror with her makeup or something. [00:29:44.128 – 00:29:53.688] "I had a shoe in my hand," Lois said, "and before I knew what was happening, I had thrown it at him and said, "Damn your old meetings."" That comes right out of Lois R., page 98. [00:29:53.688 – 00:29:55.248] Bill W. told that story, too. [00:29:55.248 – 00:29:57.928] Now, that's a really, really, really good story. [00:29:57.928 – 00:29:58.888] I love that story.

[00:29:58.888 – 00:29:59.648] It's a great story. [00:29:59.648 – 00:30:03.068] But let's face it, it's nowhere near as good as that "but you stayed sober, Bill" story. [00:30:03.068 – 00:30:13.128] There's the, the message of the shoe through sh- shoe throwing story doesn't have anything like the impact and the message that ca- that gets carried with the "but you [00:30:13.128 – 00:30:14.488] stayed sober, Bill" story. [00:30:14.488 – 00:30:15.318] But it, it… [00:30:15.318 – 00:30:21.288] But if not from Lois, then where did this idea that working with another alcoholic could save your own sobriety actually come from? [00:30:21.288 – 00:30:24.118] So what, what, what, what resources do we have?

[00:30:24.118 – 00:30:27.708] What did, what did Bill and Lois actually say about this sort of thing? [00:30:27.708 – 00:30:34.188] Bill repeatedly said that idea first came to him when he was pacing the lobby of the Mayflower H. in Akron. [00:30:34.188 – 00:30:40.428] That, and Bill W. told that story over, he told it in four-part harmony with all kinds of different verbiage over and over and over again. [00:30:40.428 – 00:30:44.988] He says, "Now, all of a sudden," and Lois always said that, too, but she just basically claimed… [00:30:44.988 – 00:30:47.528] It's very rare that Lois goes off of Bill's stories. [00:30:47.528 – 00:30:50.368] So here's one, here's Bill talking in 1954. [00:30:50.368 – 00:30:54.888] "Still walking back and forth between the bar and the church directory, my panic increased.

[00:30:54.888 – 00:30:57.128] The pull of the bar became terrific. [00:30:57.128 – 00:31:01.028] I was really tempted this time, but still I could think straight. [00:31:01.028 – 00:31:02.308] What should I do? [00:31:02.308 – 00:31:08.648] Then, then I suddenly realized how much helping another alcoholic helped me, even though none had gotten well themselves. [00:31:08.648 – 00:31:13.508] I'd have to find an alcoholic in Akron and find him quick." Here's another one. [00:31:13.508 – 00:31:16.398] Right out of the forward of our second edition of our book. [00:31:16.398 – 00:31:22.778] "The broker had gone to Akron on a business venture which had collapsed, leaving him greatly in fear that he might start drinking again.

[00:31:22.778 – 00:31:31.668] He suddenly realized that in order to save himself, he must carry his message to another alcoholic." That alcoholic to be, turned out to be an Akron physician. [00:31:31.668 – 00:31:36.308] And here he is talking in '56 and '51, two different talks. [00:31:36.308 – 00:31:46.448] "I realized as never before how working with another alcoholic had played such a great part in sustaining my original experience, and I thought to myself, I must find another alcoholic [00:31:46.448 – 00:31:56.688] and help him so that I can remain free." So however touching, true-sounding, and instructive that "but you stayed sober, Bill" story [00:31:56.688 – 00:32:03.148] may be, based on this negative evidence, I have to chalk that up to an urban legend until some reliable source can be found. [00:32:03.148 – 00:32:05.268] Again, it's a story that should be true. [00:32:05.268 – 00:32:07.308] I mean, it's such a great story, you know?

[00:32:07.308 – 00:32:11.928] No wonder it's been told over and over and over again in Alcoholics Anonymous meetings. [00:32:11.928 – 00:32:13.068] It's a fabulous story. [00:32:13.068 – 00:32:17.768] But just because everybody knows it and loves it as a story doesn't mean that it isn't true. [00:32:17.768 – 00:32:19.448] That it is true, I'm sorry. [00:32:19.448 – 00:32:24.348] Okay, now we're gonna get serious here. [00:32:24.348 – 00:32:26.008] Got a completely made-up story. [00:32:26.008 – 00:32:29.068] The six-step program.

[00:32:29.068 – 00:32:34.398] First week of December 1938, Bill W. writes the 12 steps. [00:32:34.398 – 00:32:35.728] That's pretty well documented. [00:32:35.728 – 00:32:37.728] It fits with all the other facts all around it. [00:32:37.728 – 00:32:38.648] It definitely works. [00:32:38.648 – 00:32:41.048] My- Maybe it was late 19, m- November. [00:32:41.048 – 00:32:43.128] Maybe it was the first week, the second week of December. [00:32:43.128 – 00:32:45.088] But it's, it's certainly in that zone.

[00:32:45.088 – 00:32:46.398] Personally- [00:32:46.532 – 00:32:51.072] I found the origin story of the 12-step suspect in the extreme, the one that Bill W. always told. [00:32:51.072 – 00:32:57.012] Most especially, I could find no contemporary evidence for the six-step program that Bill claimed they were based on. [00:32:57.012 – 00:33:00.532] He always said the six step, that took the six steps and boiled them… [00:33:00.532 – 00:33:03.492] I mean, he, he extrapolated them into 12. [00:33:03.492 – 00:33:11.532] Unraveling B.'s story of how he wrote the 12 steps was the most perplexing and difficult challenge I faced during this whole 11 years of this project. [00:33:11.532 – 00:33:19.722] I could not make sense out of this, and it just f- it really, really flew in the face of, of, of, of, of my, my belief system in AA, you know?

[00:33:19.722 – 00:33:21.172] I mean that, that he was doing this. [00:33:21.172 – 00:33:23.492] By far the most difficult chapter to write. [00:33:23.492 – 00:33:25.092] It took me more than six months to do that. [00:33:25.092 – 00:33:25.932] So what's the problem? [00:33:25.932 – 00:33:26.932] It would've been easy. [00:33:26.932 – 00:33:28.592] Bill famously told the story over. [00:33:28.592 – 00:33:30.252] Bill told the story over and over again.

[00:33:30.252 – 00:33:32.232] He went upstairs with an imaginary ulcer. [00:33:32.232 – 00:33:39.372] He picks up a yellow legal pad, and he's starting with the, quote, "original tw- six steps." He broke them down into the new 12 steps. [00:33:39.372 – 00:33:45.592] Bill told that story over and over again, and I started, when I first started writing the chapter, I was doing that, you know? [00:33:45.592 – 00:33:48.092] And then I started picking the story apart. [00:33:48.092 – 00:33:54.652] The problem was that once I started looking for verified sources for that story, they were nowhere to be found in contemporary documents. [00:33:54.652 – 00:34:04.212] In fact, the first record I could find of Bill ever telling that story, ever telling that story, was May 23rd, 1949. [00:34:04.212 – 00:34:10.412] If he told it, uh, some- somebody's gonna come up to me and say, "Oh, I found something for 1946." I would love somebody to find something earlier.

[00:34:10.412 – 00:34:20.572] I would love somebody to find something earlier, but the first time I can find Bill W. telling this story about going upstairs and breaking the six steps down to 12 steps is May 23rd, 1949. [00:34:20.572 – 00:34:25.492] And, and we're talking, talking 10 and a half years after the fact. [00:34:25.492 – 00:34:28.492] 10 and a, 10 and a half years after the fact. [00:34:28.492 – 00:34:38.612] Worse yet, worse yet, the first time he tells the story, May, uh, 194- '49, he says that Ebby delivered [00:34:38.612 – 00:34:42.492] the, the six steps to him when he come, came, came to see him in ninth, October… [00:34:42.492 – 00:34:44.492] I'm sorry, in November 1934. [00:34:44.492 – 00:34:50.632] Ebby shows up with the six steps in his back pocket and hands them to, uh, hands them to Bill W., kind of thing.

[00:34:50.632 – 00:35:00.832] But in all his later talks, all his later talks, other than this very first telling of the story, he always claimed that those original six steps were gradually evolved within [00:35:00.832 – 00:35:03.192] the fellowship, not that Ebby had delivered them to him. [00:35:03.192 – 00:35:13.312] So there's, but there's no evidence for any of the primary documents that supports Bill's claim that there was a pretty consistent procedure, his six-step program, before the 12 [00:35:13.312 – 00:35:17.472] steps were written, and there are a lot of primary sources to consult. [00:35:17.472 – 00:35:21.572] I mean, if you're looking for the 12 steps, it's not like you only got three places to go to. [00:35:21.572 – 00:35:31.812] Um, if there had been a pretty consistent procedure of s- of a six-step program around since 1934, or if such a pro- when Ebby handed [00:35:31.812 – 00:35:42.032] it to him, or if such a program had evolved over time as more and more people stayed sober, then you could reasonably expect to find mention of those six steps in, oh, Frank A.

[00:35:42.032 – 00:35:42.772] goes to Akron. [00:35:42.772 – 00:35:44.312] He writes a long report for John D. [00:35:44.312 – 00:35:45.192] R. Jr. [00:35:45.192 – 00:35:49.052] in February 1938, and he talks about how those people are staying sober. [00:35:49.052 – 00:35:50.532] Any six steps there? [00:35:50.532 – 00:35:50.992] Nope. [00:35:50.992 – 00:35:57.452] Uh, Fitzmaio in, in, in late May of 1938 writes the first version of his story.

[00:35:57.452 – 00:35:58.952] No six steps there. [00:35:58.952 – 00:36:04.852] Hank writes a proposed, Hank P. writes a proposed Q&A chapter for the book in late 1938. [00:36:04.852 – 00:36:06.972] No six steps there. [00:36:06.972 – 00:36:12.472] And in the back of the first edition of our book, there's 30 personal stories. [00:36:12.472 – 00:36:20.132] 30 personal stories about how they, how they got drunk and how they got sober, how they stayed sober. [00:36:20.132 – 00:36:22.291] No six steps there. [00:36:22.291 – 00:36:32.292] None of those 30 original stories mention anything like Bill's later six steps as their pathway to sobriety, except for story number 31, Bill's story, which as we shall

[00:36:32.292 – 00:36:35.112] see in a few minutes, is another story completely. [00:36:35.112 – 00:36:42.972] Bill regularly changed the wording of those alleged six steps, but in Alcoholics Anonymous Come To- Comes of Age, he said they were as follows. [00:36:42.972 – 00:36:52.992] Number one, "We admitted we were l- that we were powerless over alcohol." Number two, "We made a moral inventory of our defects or sins." Number three, "We [00:36:52.992 – 00:37:02.992] confessed or shared our shortcomings with another person in confidence." Number four, "We made restitution to all those we had harmed by our drinking." Number five, "We tried [00:37:02.992 – 00:37:13.012] to help other alcoholics with no thought of reward or prestige, or money or prestige." Six, "We prayed to whatever God we thought." As you can see, this is [00:37:13.012 – 00:37:15.132] a pretty well-defined program of recovery. [00:37:15.132 – 00:37:16.332] That works.

[00:37:16.332 – 00:37:19.532] I don't purposely mean to bore you. [00:37:19.532 – 00:37:27.932] Honestly, I don't wanna do that, but, but people just, people have such pushback on this that I, I really, I, I'm gonna beat a dead horse here, okay? [00:37:27.932 – 00:37:37.092] Most A's just haven't read the stories that are in the first edition of our big book, so they frequently get skeptical when I say this six steps was an alleged program. [00:37:37.092 – 00:37:46.192] Please bear with me as we review each of those stories, looking for evidence of what our earliest members say they actually did to get and then stay sober. [00:37:46.192 – 00:37:47.232] You know, there's… [00:37:47.232 – 00:37:49.072] Well, we'll see. [00:37:49.072 – 00:37:55.192] And note that all we'll find here is negative evidence for the existence of the six steps.

[00:37:55.192 – 00:37:56.512] We're not finding the six steps. [00:37:56.512 – 00:38:00.572] They're telling you what, what they did to get sober, and they're not talking the six steps. [00:38:00.572 – 00:38:04.432] Man after man after man after man after man, and one woman. [00:38:04.432 – 00:38:07.232] So here, the doctor's nightmare, Dr. [00:38:07.232 – 00:38:07.632] Bob. [00:38:07.632 – 00:38:14.082] "If you think you're an atheist, an agnostic, a skeptic, or have any other form of intellectual pride which keeps you from accepting what is in this wr- [00:38:14.236 – 00:38:15.476] Look, I feel sorry for you.

[00:38:15.476 – 00:38:17.916] Your H. Father will never let you down. [00:38:17.916 – 00:38:23.176] Uh, "You've been trying man's ways, and they always fail," he told me. [00:38:23.176 – 00:38:28.076] "You can't win unless you try God's way." That day I gave my will to God and asked to be directed. [00:38:28.076 – 00:38:34.696] You know, I heard a guy say one time, when you listen to somebody speak at an AA meeting, you should look for that one spot where something happened. [00:38:34.696 – 00:38:36.096] Something happened. [00:38:36.096 – 00:38:37.196] What, what happened, you know? [00:38:37.196 – 00:38:38.996] And, and what did they do after that, you know?

[00:38:38.996 – 00:38:40.516] And this did. [00:38:40.516 – 00:38:41.536] That's what I did. [00:38:41.536 – 00:38:43.396] Gave my will to God and he directed me. [00:38:43.396 – 00:38:48.896] No conviction was necessary to establish my status as a miserable failure at managing my own life. [00:38:48.896 – 00:38:54.576] I began to read the Bible daily, and to go over a simple devotional exercise as a way to begin each day. [00:38:54.576 – 00:38:56.616] Gradually, I began to understand. [00:38:56.616 – 00:39:06.616] "All my life," he said, "I have been doing things by my own human will, as opposed to God's will, and that the only certain way for me to stop drinking was to submit

[00:39:06.616 – 00:39:11.076] my will to God and let Him handle my difficulties." Spiritually… [00:39:11.076 – 00:39:12.976] Something's in my way here, David. [00:39:12.976 – 00:39:14.676] Some- some let the people in the room. [00:39:14.676 – 00:39:15.036] There we go. [00:39:15.036 – 00:39:19.596] Spiritually, I have found a friend who never let me down, and is ever eager to help. [00:39:19.596 – 00:39:23.296] I can actually take my problems to Him, and He gives me comfort. [00:39:23.296 – 00:39:25.466] He does give me comfort, peace, and radiant happiness.

[00:39:25.466 – 00:39:27.856] For all of these blessings, I thank Him. [00:39:27.856 – 00:39:35.896] I only know that as long as I seek God's help for the best of my ability, so long will liquor never bother me. [00:39:35.896 – 00:39:43.676] They were living proof that a sincere attempt to follow the cardinal teachings of Jesus C. was keeping them sober. [00:39:43.676 – 00:39:48.196] I acknowledged my fault to God and asked His help to keep the course that I had to follow. [00:39:48.196 – 00:39:50.916] I learned the secret. [00:39:50.916 – 00:39:52.956] They had a religious experience. [00:39:52.956 – 00:39:56.656] I was willing, and renewed my acquaintance with God, and acknowledged Him as reality.

[00:39:56.656 – 00:39:57.496] I found it easy. [00:39:57.496 – 00:40:00.236] I came to life, and have been free now for two years. [00:40:00.236 – 00:40:02.075] I hope never to take another drink. [00:40:02.075 – 00:40:08.116] But if friends and fellowship were to disappear tomorrow, I don't think I would be dismayed. [00:40:08.116 – 00:40:18.216] Back of all that, there is the knowledge that I have a defined Father, that as I long, uh, that as long as I try to walk as He has laid down for me to do throughout my life, [00:40:18.216 – 00:40:23.596] nothing of ill can befall me, that I, if I wish, I can be sober for the rest of my life. [00:40:23.596 – 00:40:30.076] They made it very plain that I had to seek God, that I had to state my case to Him and ask for help.

[00:40:30.076 – 00:40:34.436] Every morning I read a part of the Bible and ask God to carry me through the day safely. [00:40:34.436 – 00:40:41.436] I've been sober for two years, kept that way by submitting my natural will to the higher power, and this is all there is to it. [00:40:41.436 – 00:40:43.856] No six steps. [00:40:43.856 – 00:40:45.176] It was so simple. [00:40:45.176 – 00:40:52.496] The sum and substance of it seemed to be that if I would turn to God, I would very probably, it was very probable that He could do better job of my life than I had. [00:40:52.496 – 00:40:57.736] And, um, are you right with the Father, who knows your needs before you ask? [00:40:57.736 – 00:41:01.576] If so, your help comes from an ever-present and all-powerful Father.

[00:41:01.576 – 00:41:08.776] I feel that the combined efforts of these three Christian gentlemen made it possible for me to have a vital spiritual experience. [00:41:08.776 – 00:41:11.316] I love this one. [00:41:11.316 – 00:41:12.616] We actually got some steps here. [00:41:12.616 – 00:41:15.866] Why not avail myself of this all-wise, ever-present help? [00:41:15.866 – 00:41:16.896] This I did. [00:41:16.896 – 00:41:22.535] I asked for, accept, and acknowledge this help, and, and know that so long as I do, I shall never take a drink. [00:41:22.535 – 00:41:27.546] And what is more important, though impossible without the first, all these phases of my life have been helped.

[00:41:27.546 – 00:41:32.166] There is, it seems to me, four steps to be taken by one who is a victim of alcoholism. [00:41:32.166 – 00:41:34.716] First, have a real desire to quit. [00:41:34.716 – 00:41:36.796] Second, admit you can't. [00:41:36.796 – 00:41:37.616] This is the hardest. [00:41:37.616 – 00:41:41.576] Third, ask for His ever-present help. [00:41:41.576 – 00:41:45.016] Four, accept and acknowledge this help. [00:41:45.016 – 00:41:49.316] Four steps, but nothing like the six steps Bill keeps talking about all the time.

[00:41:49.316 – 00:41:53.646] Since giving my husband's problem to God, I have found peace and happiness. [00:41:53.646 – 00:41:57.476] My husband and I now talk over our problems and trust in a divine power. [00:41:57.476 – 00:41:59.196] We have now started to live. [00:41:59.196 – 00:42:01.336] When we live with God, we want for nothing. [00:42:01.336 – 00:42:06.556] A religious awakening was conveyed to me through some unseen force. [00:42:06.556 – 00:42:12.536] I have found a new life, and I know as long as I do the few things that God requires of me to do, I shall never take another drink. [00:42:12.536 – 00:42:20.916] That's the sum and substance of the important instructions found in 16 of the 18 stories contributed by Akron.

[00:42:20.916 – 00:42:26.876] That's, you know, you wanna, you wanna read the story to find out what you gotta do to stay sober, that's the basic. [00:42:26.876 – 00:42:31.356] You know, there's a little, little, little bit more information, but that's basically what they're saying. [00:42:31.356 – 00:42:35.596] Now, nothing, there's nothing faintly resembling a six-step program. [00:42:35.596 – 00:42:39.356] The two remaining stories make no mention of God's role in their sobriety. [00:42:39.356 – 00:42:49.395] The first emphasizes fellowship as the critical factor, and the second only notes that alcoholics vis- visited him in the hospital, quote, "Imparted to me the necessary knowledge," [00:42:49.396 – 00:42:56.696] doesn't tell you what that is, "and mental tools," doesn't tell you what that is, "which have resulted in my complete sobriety." No six steps. [00:42:56.696 – 00:43:06.715] The New Yorkers, supposedly much less religious than those guys out in Akron, um, uh, no less helpful in confirming the existence of this six-step program,

[00:43:06.716 – 00:43:09.356] uh, in their 12 Big Book stories. [00:43:09.356 – 00:43:14.176] Here's Hank P- "I raised my," "He raised my hopes so high it looked as though I had something I don't know. [00:43:14.176 – 00:43:24.256] I, I guess I was so sold that I expected him to spring some kind of a pill, and I asked him desperately what it was, and he said, 'God.' And I laughed." And then six pages later, Hank [00:43:24.256 – 00:43:25.346] falls on his knees. [00:43:25.346 – 00:43:27.326] "Brr, this floor is cold on my knees. [00:43:27.326 – 00:43:29.456] Why are these tears running down my cheek? [00:43:29.456 – 00:43:35.776] God, have mercy on my soul." It's a sum and substance of the program described by Hank P., the unbeliever.

[00:43:35.776 – 00:43:37.666] Are you willing to give up? [00:43:37.666 – 00:43:40.835] Are you willing to say, "Here it is, God, all mixed up. [00:43:40.835 – 00:43:41.866] I don't know why I'm mixed up." [00:43:41.948 – 00:43:42.888] That I'll leave it to you. [00:43:42.888 – 00:43:47.588] The thing I do is to say, "God, here I am, and here are all my troubles. [00:43:47.588 – 00:43:49.788] I've made a mess of things and can't do anything about it. [00:43:49.788 – 00:44:00.008] You take me and all my troubles and do anything you want with me." It never occurred to me that He, in His infinite wisdom, knew much better than I what I should have and be

[00:44:00.008 – 00:44:04.888] and do, and that if I simply turned the decision over to Him, I would be led along the right path. [00:44:04.888 – 00:44:13.028] From that day, I gave and still give and always will, time every day to read the words of God and let Him do all the caring. [00:44:13.028 – 00:44:15.668] Who am I to try to run myself or anyone else? [00:44:15.668 – 00:44:22.818] A belief in the basic spirituality of life has grown, and with it, belief in a supreme and guiding power for good. [00:44:22.818 – 00:44:26.638] The first step I took when I admitted to myself for the first time that I had … [00:44:26.638 – 00:44:28.837] That all my previous thinking c- might be wrong. [00:44:28.837 – 00:44:32.588] The second step came when I first consciously wished to believe.

[00:44:32.588 – 00:44:38.288] Well, that is pretty close to our current second step, but that's not mentioned. [00:44:38.288 – 00:44:41.108] Our current second step doesn't make much mention of Bill's six steps. [00:44:41.108 – 00:44:49.728] So then the next day, a fine fellow came, and in a halting but effective way, told how he had placed himself in God's hands and keeping. [00:44:49.728 – 00:44:52.808] Almost before I knew it, I was asking God to clean me up. [00:44:52.808 – 00:45:02.948] I should not be surprised to find myself coming to the astounding conclusion that God, whoever or whatever He may be, is eminently more capable of running this uni- universe than I am. [00:45:02.948 – 00:45:05.568] At last, I believe I am on my way. [00:45:05.568 – 00:45:08.268] These men were thinking straight.

[00:45:08.268 – 00:45:12.748] They'd given themselves, their minds, over to a higher power for direction. [00:45:12.748 – 00:45:17.648] The day I made my first efforts in that direction, an entire new world opened up for me. [00:45:17.648 – 00:45:21.388] Drinking, as a vicious habit, was washed completely out of my consciousness. [00:45:21.388 – 00:45:27.748] I knew that the only way to con- c- combat this curse was to ask the help of the greater power, God. [00:45:27.748 – 00:45:29.588] God is my only chance. [00:45:29.588 – 00:45:34.788] The two remaining New York stories, uh, they make no reference to God in any way. [00:45:34.788 – 00:45:38.588] The first is less than 400 words, the shortest story in the first edition.

[00:45:38.588 – 00:45:44.308] The second only says, "What I heard was hard to believe, but I wanted to believe it." We don't know what that was. [00:45:44.308 – 00:45:47.268] "What's more, I wanted to try it and see if it wouldn't work for me. [00:45:47.268 – 00:45:52.788] It worked, and it's still working." Well, thank you very much, but that doesn't tell us much, does it? [00:45:52.788 – 00:45:57.968] And that's the sum and substance of the important instructions found in the 12 stories from New York. [00:45:57.968 – 00:46:02.428] And again, nothing even faintly resembling an organized and agreed-upon six-step program. [00:46:02.428 – 00:46:11.928] Now, clearly, clearly people were staying sober in the late '30s before Bill W. wrote the 12 steps in December of 1938 and published them in April of 1939. [00:46:11.928 – 00:46:12.768] But how?

[00:46:12.768 – 00:46:14.028] What are they doing to stay sober? [00:46:14.028 – 00:46:17.928] If you read all those stories, um, Bob S. says that he made … [00:46:17.928 – 00:46:24.148] And although Bob S. makes no mention of it in his Big Book, uh, Bob S.'s story's almost all drunk along. [00:46:24.148 – 00:46:24.528] I just… [00:46:24.528 – 00:46:26.828] Anyhow, I don't care for drunk alongs. [00:46:26.828 – 00:46:31.148] We do know that he made amends on his first day sober. [00:46:31.148 – 00:46:39.088] So he was doing, you know, he was doing some, some ninth step work there, and he did the equivalent of the fifth step with Bill W. shortly, shortly after that.

[00:46:39.088 – 00:46:43.308] We know that those things happened, but it doesn't get mentioned in his b- in his story in the book. [00:46:43.308 – 00:46:48.548] Still, a careful reading of those 30 stories reveals the following common elements. [00:46:48.548 – 00:46:50.368] You wanna know what these people were doing? [00:46:50.368 – 00:46:52.048] This is basically what they were doing. [00:46:52.048 – 00:46:54.368] They gotta admit you're, you're defeated. [00:46:54.368 – 00:46:55.048] You know? [00:46:55.048 – 00:46:56.668] Powerless over alcohol.

[00:46:56.668 – 00:47:00.418] David, I've locked up here. [00:47:00.418 – 00:47:01.148] Oh, there we go. [00:47:01.148 – 00:47:06.248] You gotta surrender your life to God, and you gotta act accordingly. [00:47:06.248 – 00:47:08.988] Different, different, different stories had different… [00:47:08.988 – 00:47:15.028] After you surrender your life to God, sometimes th- they prayed, sometimes they meditated, sometimes they made amends, sometimes they helped others. [00:47:15.028 – 00:47:22.388] But it was just admit your life, surrender your life to God, and then start a- living like a real human being again kind of thing. [00:47:22.388 – 00:47:24.488] No six-step program.

[00:47:24.488 – 00:47:34.528] Given that presentation, somebody always objects that I'm forgetting about page 263 of our Big Book, [00:47:34.528 – 00:47:39.608] which references and explicitly states the six-step program that existed before the 12 steps were written. [00:47:39.608 – 00:47:43.008] I'm well aware that the Big Book story, he sold himself short. [00:47:43.008 – 00:47:46.508] Ear- Earl T., early guy in AA, says Dr. [00:47:46.508 – 00:47:56.868] Bob took him through, quote, "the six-step program as it was at that time." And supposedly in three or four hours, they did this in three or four hours in April of 1937. [00:47:56.868 – 00:47:58.328] So what was the six-step program? [00:47:58.328 – 00:48:00.628] According to Earl T.'s story, he sold himself short.

[00:48:00.628 – 00:48:01.988] Complete deflation. [00:48:01.988 – 00:48:04.468] Number two, dependence and guidance from a higher power. [00:48:04.468 – 00:48:06.008] Number three, moral inventory. [00:48:06.008 – 00:48:07.488] Number four, confession. [00:48:07.488 – 00:48:08.718] Number five, restitution. [00:48:08.718 – 00:48:10.948] And number six, continue to work with others. [00:48:10.948 – 00:48:19.868] Somebody always says, "Well, there's a six-step program right there." Now, that doesn't really correspond to Bill W.'s six-step program, but it's a six-step program, and it's, it's close on many different levels.

[00:48:19.868 – 00:48:20.588] I get that. [00:48:20.588 – 00:48:26.248] But you gotta realize this is a piece of positive evidence, right? [00:48:26.248 – 00:48:27.968] This is a piece of positive evidence. [00:48:27.968 – 00:48:36.268] Earl's story is written 18 years after the fact and published for the first time in 1955 in the second edition of the book. [00:48:36.268 – 00:48:37.478] It doesn't appear in the first. [00:48:37.478 – 00:48:39.668] Earl wouldn't write a story for the first edition of the book. [00:48:39.668 – 00:48:41.538] That's another story we don't have time to get into.

[00:48:41.538 – 00:48:46.768] Though sober nearly two y- years, he didn't write a story for the first edition of the Big Book. [00:48:46.768 – 00:48:48.408] Okay, I put a shot in there. [00:48:48.408 – 00:48:53.088] But so how much credibility can we give to this written long after the fact story? [00:48:53.088 – 00:48:53.928] I would say none. [00:48:53.928 – 00:49:03.968] On one side of the ledger, we have this mass of contemporary 1938 documents that make no mention whatsoever of anything like a formal eight, [00:49:03.968 – 00:49:04.968] six-step program. [00:49:04.968 – 00:49:09.578] Frank A.' report, F.'s early story, Ag's proposed chapters and-

[00:49:09.692 – 00:49:12.232] And 30 personal stories in the big book. [00:49:12.232 – 00:49:22.272] On the other side of the ledger, we got one single story that was written 18 years after the fact, and at least five years after Bill W. started spreading that six-step story far and wide in Alcoholics [00:49:22.272 – 00:49:22.852] Anonymous. [00:49:22.852 – 00:49:32.932] So did Frank, and Fitz, and Hank, and the 30 other early members just forget to mention the six-step program they were all [00:49:32.932 – 00:49:35.352] working in mid-1937? [00:49:35.352 – 00:49:37.092] Give me a break. [00:49:37.092 – 00:49:39.372] My…

[00:49:39.372 – 00:49:49.612] Or is Earl's much later written story nothing more than another sterling example of people rewriting their memories so that they more closely [00:49:49.612 – 00:49:51.472] reflect pre- present reality? [00:49:51.472 – 00:49:53.932] Personally, I don't see a problem here. [00:49:53.932 – 00:50:03.932] We all have to decide how we're gonna weigh the available evidence, but I think Earl's much later story is positively overwhelmed, capital letters should be underlined, by the huge amount of [00:50:03.932 – 00:50:05.392] negative evidence against it. [00:50:05.392 – 00:50:11.532] So I'm siding with Ernie K., who noted that the formulation of these six steps was contrived by Bill W.. [00:50:11.532 – 00:50:15.472] If you don't know who Ernie K. is, he's, he's the dean of AA historians.

[00:50:15.472 – 00:50:17.452] Ernie's been dead about four years now, maybe. [00:50:17.452 – 00:50:18.372] I don't know. [00:50:18.372 – 00:50:22.272] His, his magnum opus, Not G., is a great history of Alcoholics Anonymous. [00:50:22.272 – 00:50:26.332] He claims that, uh, W. formulated, or contrived, by Bill W.. [00:50:26.332 – 00:50:36.352] And Glenn Chestnut, who died a couple of years ago, a great AA historian, said, "There's no evidence that there was any formal set of six steps being listed or followed by people in AA [00:50:36.352 – 00:50:46.352] prior to Bill W.'s writing of the 12 steps in early December of 1938." People who like things neat and tidy with lists to memorize tend to get carried away with this idea of six [00:50:46.352 – 00:50:56.372] steps, and start imagining early AA meetings with a window shade mounted on the walls displaying a list of six steps, and everybody sitting around memorizing and analyzing the six

[00:50:56.372 – 00:50:56.832] steps. [00:50:56.832 – 00:51:01.392] No six-step window shade, folks. [00:51:01.392 – 00:51:02.812] Ah. [00:51:02.812 – 00:51:07.012] But if that is the case, why would Bill make up that six-step story? [00:51:07.012 – 00:51:13.632] An investigation into the positive evidence for the real origins of the 12 steps may help clarify that. [00:51:13.632 – 00:51:20.352] So now we're gonna do a little exercise in demythologizing this story about writing the 12 steps. [00:51:20.352 – 00:51:28.592] So B. didn't start with six steps and then break them down into smaller pieces in the first week of December 1938.

[00:51:28.592 – 00:51:30.572] Where did those 12 steps come from? [00:51:30.572 – 00:51:40.652] January 30th, 1948, 16 months before he first introduced [00:51:40.652 – 00:51:46.251] this six-step story, Bill and Lois are on a train going to DC for an AA regional banquet. [00:51:46.251 – 00:51:50.512] Uh, and on with them is, uh, Paul H., a lawyer, and his secretary. [00:51:50.512 – 00:51:57.412] And Paul's, Paul's gonna give a talk at that speech about, about Fitz M., who's the founder of the Washington AA group. [00:51:57.412 – 00:52:04.992] Paul tells Bill that he's never, 1948, he's never heard the story of the evolution of the 12 steps. [00:52:04.992 – 00:52:08.392] Where did those 12 steps come from, Bill?

[00:52:08.392 – 00:52:10.652] It's 1948, for God's sakes. [00:52:10.652 – 00:52:12.512] It's, it's 10 years after the steps are written. [00:52:12.512 – 00:52:16.032] Bill's never publicly said anything about where the 12 steps come from. [00:52:16.032 – 00:52:17.112] No, I can't find anything. [00:52:17.112 – 00:52:22.792] If there's something there, I'd love to see it, but Paul had never heard it for sure, and he's a knowledgeable AA guy. [00:52:22.792 – 00:52:26.292] He's, uh, the keynote speaker on Fitz M. when he gets down to Washington. [00:52:26.292 – 00:52:36.632] So he says, "I've never heard the story about the evolution of the 12 steps, and can you tell me about that?" Bill's story was so impressed that Paul thought it was of sufficient importance to commit to writing, a

[00:52:36.632 – 00:52:41.512] piece of writing which you can find in the GSO archive in New York City, which he did. [00:52:41.512 – 00:52:49.172] And then he had subsequent conversations, according to these letters, with Bill W. to make sure that it was true, that he eliminated any errors from it. [00:52:49.172 – 00:52:52.491] He explained how the… [00:52:52.491 – 00:53:02.492] Bill explained how the pioneers in AA fought, thought, and prayed their way through to recovery, noting that in those days the alcoholic was obliged to, get ready folks, number one, [00:53:02.492 – 00:53:04.292] admit he was powerless over alcohol. [00:53:04.292 – 00:53:07.532] Number two, make an inventory of his own character. [00:53:07.532 – 00:53:11.091] Number three, put his trust in God.

[00:53:11.091 – 00:53:13.572] Number four, work with other alcoholics. [00:53:13.572 – 00:53:16.072] Four steps. [00:53:16.072 – 00:53:26.072] "As it stood, this program needed clarification," Bill W. says, "And he sat down," he said, "and began to figure out the various phases of his own [00:53:26.072 – 00:53:26.852] recovery. [00:53:26.852 – 00:53:36.872] Having done that and setting them down on paper, he found that there were 12 separate and distinct steps." So [00:53:36.872 – 00:53:46.052] according to this earliest story, he starts with these four that I've just noted here, and he breaks down, he thinks about his own recovery, and he breaks them down into 12. [00:53:46.052 – 00:53:56.152] The origin of the 12-step story to being simply a recap of the various phases of Bill's own recovery is not just credible to me.

[00:53:56.152 – 00:53:57.032] We're gonna show some evidence. [00:53:57.032 – 00:53:59.292] It's confirmed by any careful reading of Bill's story. [00:53:59.292 – 00:54:07.972] So I just pointed out that there was no six-step program in any of the 30 stories written in the back of the book in the first edition. [00:54:07.972 – 00:54:18.072] Nothing even close to a six-step story, nothing even remotely resembling a six-step story, but when we look at Bill's story, we're gonna find almost all of the 12 steps right there in this [00:54:18.072 – 00:54:18.832] thing that he wrote. [00:54:18.832 – 00:54:23.672] Two versions of which were written six months before the 12 steps were put down on paper. [00:54:23.672 – 00:54:30.432] In late May of 1938, Bill W. first wrote a long and then a shorter version of his stories.

[00:54:30.432 – 00:54:34.171] The first one was about 12,000 words, the second one was 5,300 words. [00:54:34.171 – 00:54:37.332] And then, and then in the explicit- [00:54:37.456 – 00:54:39.376] He mentions 11 of the 12 steps. [00:54:39.376 – 00:54:47.016] So this is his story to Paul, that he looked at his own experience and started breaking it down, and this is what he came up with. [00:54:47.016 – 00:54:55.495] And so this is in December, but the previous May, he writes this story that has 11 of the 12 steps in it. [00:54:55.495 – 00:55:00.736] The second step material was added to Bill's story later by Hank P. in his own handwriting, and we'll see that in a minute. [00:55:00.736 – 00:55:09.936] Bill's story in late May of 1938, in the very first long version of his story, he clearly paraphrases eight of the 12 steps.

[00:55:09.936 – 00:55:19.946] And in his second shorter version, he mentions 10 of the 12 steps using slightly different language, for a grand total of 11 steps mentioned in these two earliest versions of [00:55:19.946 – 00:55:21.276] his story. [00:55:21.276 – 00:55:28.196] Now, I gotta tell you, the first time I sat down with these stories in the archive in New York City, I was just flabbergasted. [00:55:28.196 – 00:55:29.096] When I read… [00:55:29.096 – 00:55:39.196] When I was putting the timeline together and realizing that this, this thing on my hand was written and typed in May of 1938, but supposedly the steps weren't written until December, and here [00:55:39.196 – 00:55:39.536] they are. [00:55:39.536 – 00:55:42.096] I'm- They're, they're right there in this story.

[00:55:42.096 – 00:55:43.616] I was knocked out. [00:55:43.616 – 00:55:44.716] Knocked out. [00:55:44.716 – 00:55:54.716] Uh, so here, we're gonna compare the steps as they were published in April of 1939 when the book came out, and the original story, the long version, [00:55:54.716 – 00:56:00.006] and Bill's story, those are what they're ki- kinda called, uh, from May of 1938, months earlier. [00:56:00.006 – 00:56:10.036] The first one is probably the least, the least correspondence, the lamest correspondence, but for the first step he says, "Like myself, he," Ebby, "had admitted [00:56:10.036 – 00:56:13.056] defeat." Second step. [00:56:13.056 – 00:56:14.176] I'm sorry, third step.

[00:56:14.176 – 00:56:15.256] We're gonna skip the second step. [00:56:15.256 – 00:56:16.076] Third step. [00:56:16.076 – 00:56:25.336] "I turned my face to God as I understand Him," as I understand Him, "and placed my life at His disposal and direction." That's from the long one. [00:56:25.336 – 00:56:31.616] The shorter one says, "I humbly offered myself to God, as I then understood Him, to do with me as He would. [00:56:31.616 – 00:56:40.696] I placed myself unreservedly under His care and direction." I mean, that's a few more words than we got in our current third step, but it's all there, people. [00:56:40.696 – 00:56:50.836] Four, "Made a thorough and reluth- ruthless inventory of my moral defects and derelictions." Second one from Bill's story, "I ruthlessly faced my sins of [00:56:50.836 – 00:56:56.156] omission and commission and made a list of people towards whom I felt resentments." Wow.

[00:56:56.156 – 00:56:57.436] Step four. [00:56:57.436 – 00:57:07.656] Step five, "I should sit down with whatever person I chose and reveal to him without any reservations whatever the results of my self-appraisal," step four had been, "and to be really [00:57:07.656 – 00:57:12.376] honest with myself and God." Okay, bang, we just nailed step five there. [00:57:12.376 – 00:57:22.036] Oh, yeah, "I fully acquainted him with my problems and deficiencies." Step six, "I was now willing to rid myself of all these defects. [00:57:22.036 – 00:57:26.096] Moreover, I was to understand that this would not be accomplished by myself alone. [00:57:26.096 – 00:57:36.176] Therefore," step seven, "I was to humbly ask God that He take these handicaps away." Or, as he said in Bill's story later, "Became willing to have my newfound [00:57:36.176 – 00:57:46.235] friend take them away, root and branch." Step eight, "I made a list of all persons I had hurt, and with whom I had bad relations." Or

[00:57:46.236 – 00:57:50.596] from Bill's story, "We made a list of people I had hurt or towards whom I felt resentments. [00:57:50.596 – 00:57:59.156] I expressed my entire willingness to approach these pe- individuals, admitting my wrong." Yeah, entire willingness. [00:57:59.156 – 00:58:00.196] Man, it's all in there. [00:58:00.196 – 00:58:09.396] Nine, "I approached these people, telling them I had come to set matters right insofar as I possibly could, but discretion should be used lest others should be hurt. [00:58:09.396 – 00:58:19.436] I was to right all such matters to the utmost of my ability." 10, "This principle of continuing amends was to continue into [00:58:19.436 – 00:58:23.876] the future." Yeah, personal inventory continued. [00:58:23.876 – 00:58:29.036] 11, "I was to test my thinking by the new God consciousness within.

[00:58:29.036 – 00:58:40.076] I was to sit quietly when in doubt," a little meditation there, "asking Him," praying, "only for direction and strength to meet my problems as He would have me." And [00:58:40.076 – 00:58:40.976] step 12, I love it. [00:58:40.976 – 00:58:42.776] Now, by the way, you got a note on the left-hand side. [00:58:42.776 – 00:58:48.656] The original publication of, of the 12 step was having had a spiritual experience, not having had a spiritual awakening. [00:58:48.656 – 00:58:51.196] It wasn't changed until the second printing in 1941. [00:58:51.196 – 00:58:53.476] But that's neither here nor there. [00:58:53.476 – 00:58:56.895] What I love is what he says in, in, uh, in his story.

[00:58:56.895 – 00:59:00.576] He hits all three, 12A, 12B, 12C. [00:59:00.576 – 00:59:03.496] "The moment I fully accepted them, the effect was electric. [00:59:03.496 – 00:59:07.796] I felt lifted up as though a great clean wind of a mountaintop blew through and through. [00:59:07.796 – 00:59:13.496] I soon found that when all other measures failed, work with another alcoholic would save the day. [00:59:13.496 – 00:59:23.506] My friend emphasized the absolute necessity of my demonstrating these principles in all my affairs." In short, although Bill W. always claimed that he first [00:59:23.506 – 00:59:33.696] wrote the 12 steps in early December 1938, this is absolutely conclusive positive evidence that he had clearly written them out without numbers attached a full six months before [00:59:33.696 – 00:59:34.696] earlier in his story.

[00:59:34.696 – 00:59:44.316] So what Bill had written out in early December days in those 12 steps was a formal elaboration and encapsulation of his own experience in getting sober. [00:59:44.316 – 00:59:48.276] Look at those other 30 stories about what those people's experience were. [00:59:48.276 – 00:59:50.396] You don't find any evidence of six steps. [00:59:50.396 – 00:59:52.936] You certainly don't find any evidence of 12 steps. [00:59:52.936 – 00:59:57.116] But if you look at Bill's story, bang, oh, there it is jumping right off the page. [00:59:57.116 – 01:00:04.926] Ever the pragmatist, Bill W. felt his own experience best expressed the road to sobriety. [01:00:06.820 – 01:00:11.660] It's a little bit of egotism going there, but we do know that Bill, like most alcoholics, had more than a little bit of ego.

[01:00:11.660 – 01:00:22.040] To appreciate just how radical and revolutionary Bill's mid-1938 inclusion of these steps in his story actually is, let's compare Bill's clearly articulated [01:00:22.040 – 01:00:26.120] formula for suc- successful sobriety with one other contemporary story. [01:00:26.120 – 01:00:29.940] This one leans heavily on the Oxford Group rather than on the yet-to-be-published 12 Steps. [01:00:29.940 – 01:00:32.200] Now I mentioned Fitz M.'s story. [01:00:32.200 – 01:00:34.140] This is John H. Fitzhugh M.. [01:00:34.140 – 01:00:37.239] Fitz, he's born, uh, two years younger than Bill and Hank. [01:00:37.239 – 01:00:39.560] He gets sober in October of 1935.

[01:00:39.560 – 01:00:40.980] He's the number three guy in New York. [01:00:40.980 – 01:00:42.340] He lives in Maryland. [01:00:42.340 – 01:00:44.870] He's a, he's a, he's a loner out there. [01:00:44.870 – 01:00:46.080] Uh, he's married with three kids. [01:00:46.080 – 01:00:49.039] He's unsuccessful in business, and he's really like the first loner. [01:00:49.039 – 01:00:57.560] So the first time, as Bill's writing his story, those stories that I just quoted from, Fitz is also writing in the pri- the first version of his personal story. [01:00:57.560 – 01:01:02.420] And B- I know it's the same time because there's only two stories typed in this really, really bizarre strange way.

[01:01:02.420 – 01:01:05.500] We can't get into the details on that, but it was written at the same time. [01:01:05.500 – 01:01:10.620] But the path to recovery that Fitz describes while Bill's writing his story is radically different. [01:01:10.620 – 01:01:12.180] Radically different than what Bill was saying. [01:01:12.180 – 01:01:17.300] In F. M.'s story, our southern friend, uh, it appears in all four editions of the Big Book. [01:01:17.300 – 01:01:20.300] He's the, uh, he and only two other guys, Dr. [01:01:20.300 – 01:01:25.500] Bob's story and Archie T.'s, share that honor of, of being in all four b- all, uh, four of our editions. [01:01:25.500 – 01:01:28.500] Fitz's original version of the story is called Me and John.

[01:01:28.500 – 01:01:29.900] That was John B.. [01:01:29.900 – 01:01:34.550] So the original typed version, I love this, in May of 1938, he says, "I was… [01:01:34.550 – 01:01:38.820] One evening I was playing bridge in my room with two other alcoholics and a drug addict. [01:01:38.820 – 01:01:40.940] Anything to keep from thinking about the blank future. [01:01:40.940 – 01:01:43.400] When the game was over, the men left the room, but one returned. [01:01:43.400 – 01:01:47.580] He looked at me and said, 'Oh, you think you're hopeless, don't you?' 'Certainly,' I replied. [01:01:47.580 – 01:01:49.400] I knew it." So he's in T. Hospital.

[01:01:49.400 – 01:01:50.100] This is his deal. [01:01:50.100 – 01:01:51.840] "'Well, you are not,' he said. [01:01:51.840 – 01:01:59.920] 'There are men on the streets in New York today who are worse than you are, and they don't drink anymore.' Then the man asked, 'Are you willing to try to live on a new basis? [01:01:59.920 – 01:02:09.920] To live up to ideals by trying to be absolutely honest, absolutely pure, absolutely unselfish, and absolutely loving in all your relationships with your fellow men to get rid of this drink [01:02:09.920 – 01:02:13.300] problem?' 'Of course I would,' I declared without much thought. [01:02:13.300 – 01:02:23.200] 'I'd do anything.' 'Then all your troubles are over,' said the man, and he left the room." So this is Fitz's original version of what happened when he was in T. Hospital. [01:02:23.200 – 01:02:30.720] The multi-lith version, published 10 months later or so in February 1939, this is what it says.

[01:02:30.720 – 01:02:33.530] "For alcoholics," we, we had to get rid of that drug addict. [01:02:33.530 – 01:02:34.880] We don't wanna talk about drug addicts. [01:02:34.880 – 01:02:36.580] This is all about alcoholism. [01:02:36.580 – 01:02:37.389] Basically, blah, blah, blah. [01:02:37.389 – 01:02:38.140] I know it. [01:02:38.140 – 01:02:38.850] No, I know you're not. [01:02:38.850 – 01:02:41.050] The men on the streets already, they don't drink anymore.

[01:02:41.050 – 01:02:46.020] "Then he asked me if I believe in a power greater than myself." Oh, does that sound familiar? [01:02:46.020 – 01:02:53.420] Uh, and, "And then he asked me if I was willing to right all the wrongs I had ever done to anyone, no matter how wrong I thought they were. [01:02:53.420 – 01:03:03.420] Am I willing to be honest with myself about myself and tell someone about myself, and am I willing to think of other people instead of myself and their needs to get rid of the drink problem?" He said, "I'll do anything." [01:03:03.420 – 01:03:05.440] "Then your troubles are over," and the man leaves the room. [01:03:05.440 – 01:03:08.900] Big difference between these two stories. [01:03:08.900 – 01:03:10.140] Big difference. [01:03:10.140 – 01:03:16.520] The first one is straight Oxford Group, and the second one is straight Bill W. 12 steps.

[01:03:16.520 – 01:03:21.900] This i- another perfect example of my comment on Earl's story. [01:03:21.900 – 01:03:26.419] We regularly change the story so that it better fits the present reality. [01:03:26.419 – 01:03:27.840] We all do this, people. [01:03:27.840 – 01:03:28.840] We all do this. [01:03:28.840 – 01:03:32.300] Rather than accurately report what really happened. [01:03:32.300 – 01:03:34.740] The first two versions of Bill's story make no… [01:03:34.740 – 01:03:35.300] I, I just…

[01:03:35.300 – 01:03:41.340] Okay, that, I just think that's another example of, of, of how we do this thing, and there it is in black and white in the archives. [01:03:41.340 – 01:03:42.100] You can't miss it. [01:03:42.100 – 01:03:52.460] The first two versions of Bill's story make no mention of the second step, but between the February printing of the multi-lith copy and the April publication of the book, Hank P. made an amazing four-paragraph [01:03:52.460 – 01:03:53.600] addition to Bill's story. [01:03:53.600 – 01:03:57.640] Amazing f- Hank P.'s handwriting. [01:03:57.640 – 01:04:07.780] If you got the book that started it all, which is the mul- It's a facsimile copy of the multi-lith printing that they, they collected all the, the suggested changes, some of which were taken, [01:04:07.780 – 01:04:10.110] some of which were not, for the printing of the book in April.

[01:04:10.110 – 01:04:18.720] There's four paragraphs handwritten by Hank P. in the very front of that, and they got put right into Bill's story. [01:04:18.720 – 01:04:20.400] Thank you, Hank P.. [01:04:20.400 – 01:04:23.400] These are the four paragraphs. [01:04:23.400 – 01:04:28.380] I consider these among the four most important paragraphs, at least for me and my sobriety, in the entire book. [01:04:28.380 – 01:04:31.360] One man's story. [01:04:31.360 – 01:04:35.940] "Despite the living example of my friend, there remained in me the vestiges of my old prejudice. [01:04:35.940 – 01:04:38.880] The word God still aroused a certain antipathy.

[01:04:38.880 – 01:04:44.340] When the thought was expressed that there might be a God personal to me, this feeling was intensified. [01:04:44.340 – 01:04:46.040] I didn't like the idea. [01:04:46.040 – 01:04:56.160] I could go for such conceptions as creative intelligence, universal mind, or spirit of nature, but I resisted the thought of a czar of the heavens, however loving his [01:04:56.160 – 01:04:57.000] sway might be. [01:04:57.000 – 01:05:00.400] I have since talked with scores of men who felt the same way. [01:05:00.400 – 01:05:03.680] My friend suggested what then seemed a novel idea. [01:05:03.680 – 01:05:11.200] He said, italics, 'Why don't you choose your own conception of God?' That statement hit me hard.

[01:05:11.200 – 01:05:15.760] It melted the icy intellectual mountain on whose shadow I had lived and shivered many years. [01:05:15.760 – 01:05:19.680] I stood in the sunlight at last." Italics. [01:05:19.680 – 01:05:25.100] "It was only a matter of being willing to believe in a power greater than myself. [01:05:25.100 – 01:05:28.560] Nothing more was required for me to make my beginning. [01:05:28.560 – 01:05:32.730] I saw that growth could start from that point upon a foundation of complete willingness- [01:05:32.901 – 01:05:34.912] this I might build what I saw in my friend. [01:05:34.912 – 01:05:35.792] Would I have it?

[01:05:35.792 – 01:05:36.672] Of course I would. [01:05:36.672 – 01:05:40.982] It was only a matter of being willing to believe in a power greater than myself. [01:05:40.982 – 01:05:42.892] Nothing more was required to make a beginning. [01:05:42.892 – 01:05:52.992] My sponsor pointed that out to me and he said, "Do you think Alcoholics Anonymous is a greater, uh, a power greater than yourself and the men in your home group are a power greater than yourself?" And I said, "Yeah, I got no problem with that." [01:05:52.992 – 01:06:00.091] He said, "Good, then you can make a beginning." And that brings the total number of steps we have found in Bill's stories up to 12. [01:06:00.091 – 01:06:01.332] Thank you Hank P.. [01:06:01.332 – 01:06:03.632] Thank you, thank you, thank you.

[01:06:03.632 – 01:06:06.892] And just in case you don't believe, this is a copy of my… [01:06:06.892 – 01:06:08.252] This, I got… [01:06:08.252 – 01:06:09.382] So here's my book, right? [01:06:09.382 – 01:06:12.592] There's this, step one is on the page 11. [01:06:12.592 – 01:06:13.752] There's step two. [01:06:13.752 – 01:06:17.112] Uh, if you go on s- page 13, there's three, there's four. [01:06:17.112 – 01:06:19.912] You gotta skip down to get five, go back up for six and seven.

[01:06:19.912 – 01:06:21.912] There's eight, there's nine, there's 11. [01:06:21.912 – 01:06:23.492] There's, there's 10. [01:06:23.492 – 01:06:24.792] I, I'm sorry. [01:06:24.792 – 01:06:27.412] 12 A and 12 B, and 12 C are on the next page. [01:06:27.412 – 01:06:31.972] It's right there in black and white, the 12 steps of Alcoholics Anonymous. [01:06:31.972 – 01:06:42.412] And that, that text aside from that second step, those four paragraphs that Hank P. stuck in there, were written in May of 1938, not in December [01:06:42.412 – 01:06:43.552] of 1938.

[01:06:43.552 – 01:06:46.472] So again, why the six steps? [01:06:46.472 – 01:06:48.312] It's a mystery, but I can speculate. [01:06:48.312 – 01:06:50.032] This is speculation, people. [01:06:50.032 – 01:06:59.432] I mean, I think, and there's proof that I just went through about that story I just told you, but I don't know actually know why all those things came out like that. [01:06:59.432 – 01:07:00.652] Uh, why are we saying… [01:07:00.652 – 01:07:10.662] No, I mean, it's, you don't want to, you wanna say, "These are the steps we took." It's a much more powerful statement, and it's a much more better selling point for the program of recovery than [01:07:10.662 – 01:07:14.092] saying, "These are the steps I took." You just do what I did, you know?

[01:07:14.092 – 01:07:14.692] No, no, no, no. [01:07:14.692 – 01:07:15.992] There's 100 of us. [01:07:15.992 – 01:07:22.332] That's another little bit of a fallacy, but there's 100 of us, and we all did the same thing, and we all got sober doing it. [01:07:22.332 – 01:07:23.392] Of course, nobody… [01:07:23.392 – 01:07:31.252] The book is published saying that in April of 1938, and four months earlier was the first time anybody put those 12 steps down on paper. [01:07:31.252 – 01:07:38.432] But that's what we were all doing, that's what we were all doing, and that's, we want you to be doing the same thing, and you can, you can, you can have the life we've got. [01:07:38.432 – 01:07:42.892] Hence, the mythical origin stories of both the six steps and the 12 steps.

[01:07:42.892 – 01:07:45.352] Hence, that's why. [01:07:45.352 – 01:07:46.432] That's why. [01:07:46.432 – 01:07:49.152] We're trying to get people sober here, people. [01:07:49.152 – 01:07:51.212] We're trying to save people's lives here. [01:07:51.212 – 01:07:53.612] Thank you. [01:07:53.612 – 01:07:57.672] Oh my. [01:07:57.672 – 01:07:58.072] Wow.

[01:07:58.072 – 01:07:59.212] Thank you, Bill S.. [01:07:59.212 – 01:08:01.132] Please unmute yourselves. [01:08:01.132 – 01:08:02.492] Thank you, everyone. [01:08:02.492 – 01:08:04.122] Thank you, Bill. [01:08:04.122 – 01:08:04.682] Thank you, Bill. [01:08:04.682 – 01:08:05.642] Thank you so much. [01:08:05.642 – 01:08:07.452] Great job as ever.

[01:08:07.452 – 01:08:08.592] Thank you. [01:08:08.592 – 01:08:09.962] Great job. [01:08:09.962 – 01:08:10.432] Bye, Bill. [01:08:10.432 – 01:08:11.672] As always. [01:08:11.672 – 01:08:13.452] Thank you. [01:08:13.452 – 01:08:14.412] Excellent. [01:08:14.412 – 01:08:15.842] Thanks, Bill.

[01:08:15.842 – 01:08:16.232] For Bill. [01:08:16.232 – 01:08:17.152] Best B. ever. [01:08:17.152 – 01:08:18.742] Thanks, Bill. [01:08:18.742 – 01:08:19.002] Well done. [01:08:19.002 – 01:08:20.192] Thank you so much, Bill. [01:08:20.192 – 01:08:23.852] We're gonna have a Q- we're gonna have a short Q&A. [01:08:23.852 – 01:08:26.652] Uh, I think 20 minutes or so, Bill, if that's okay with you.

[01:08:26.652 – 01:08:27.292] We got- No, no, no … [01:08:27.292 – 01:08:28.691] about 20 minutes. [01:08:28.691 – 01:08:28.962] All right. [01:08:28.962 – 01:08:30.071] Whatever you want, David. [01:08:30.071 – 01:08:30.992] Thank you, Bill. [01:08:30.992 – 01:08:36.752] And then quickly if I may, just while you're getting your thoughts together, maybe Bill might be able to have a cup of tea, but a quick cup of tea. [01:08:36.752 – 01:08:38.362] Addicts, next week we have, uh, Dr.

[01:08:38.362 – 01:08:41.892] Lynn H. with us, and he's gonna do a, a presentation for us on alcoholism. [01:08:41.892 – 01:08:45.351] Is it really a disease, and if so, so what? [01:08:45.351 – 01:08:47.912] I'll quickly go through this. [01:08:47.912 – 01:08:56.152] And, and- If you'd like to ask a que- if you'd like to ask a question, be part of the meeting, then please raise your hand in the participant section. [01:08:56.152 – 01:09:02.912] I will say, just to reiterate, if you'd like to ask a question, um, that's what we're about. [01:09:02.912 – 01:09:05.572] Um, so we're gonna go to Bob C. [01:09:05.572 – 01:09:07.432] in Ilford in the UK.

[01:09:07.432 – 01:09:10.252] Um, yeah. [01:09:10.252 – 01:09:10.552] Thanks. [01:09:10.552 – 01:09:11.272] Yeah, my name's Bob. [01:09:11.272 – 01:09:14.452] I'm a grateful recovering alcoholic, and I'm slightly insane. [01:09:14.452 – 01:09:18.012] Um, one, one was like an observation, and o- and, and there is a question. [01:09:18.012 – 01:09:21.192] Um- Just the question, please … [01:09:21.192 – 01:09:21.952] o- j- just the question.

[01:09:21.952 – 01:09:22.592] Oh, okay. [01:09:22.592 – 01:09:28.072] Um, i- it's the term that, uh, that keep it simple. [01:09:28.072 – 01:09:34.072] Um, now is it correct that that was a message that Bob, Dr. [01:09:34.072 – 01:09:35.282] Bob, gave to Bill? [01:09:35.282 – 01:09:45.472] That he was overcomplicating things, and he said, "You've gotta try and keep it simple," and hence why Bob was, "Trust G., clean house, [01:09:45.472 – 01:09:51.491] and help others." That's, that's the question. [01:09:51.491 – 01:09:52.222] Yeah, got it.

[01:09:52.222 – 01:09:52.522] Got it. [01:09:52.522 – 01:09:53.231] Thank, thanks, Bob. [01:09:53.231 – 01:09:57.792] Um, what, what you're talking about is, I presume what you're talking about, is Dr. [01:09:57.792 – 01:10:06.232] Bob's speech at the 1950 Cleveland, the first international, what we call, now call the international conferences we have every five years. [01:10:06.232 – 01:10:09.812] The first one was in 1950 in Cleveland before Bob died. [01:10:09.812 – 01:10:13.412] Bob died, God, I think he died in November, but this was in, uh, June or July. [01:10:13.412 – 01:10:14.092] It was in June.

[01:10:14.092 – 01:10:14.942] And Dr. [01:10:14.942 – 01:10:22.332] Bob makes a speech, and he, he's not talking to Bill, he's talking to the entire assembled Alcoholics Anonymous people who were at that meeting. [01:10:22.332 – 01:10:28.242] And he said, "Let's just, let's not screw this thing up with psychological things." I think he's talking about Freudian and Jungian things. [01:10:28.242 – 01:10:30.912] "Let's just keep it simple." And he gets into that. [01:10:30.912 – 01:10:33.972] And I'm sure that you could, you go online and look for Dr. [01:10:33.972 – 01:10:38.372] Bob's last speech on- online, you'll be able to find that in a heartbeat, you know? [01:10:38.372 – 01:10:41.652] It's a, it's a, it's a wonderful, wonderful piece.

[01:10:41.652 – 01:10:48.072] And it, and it, and I think it's, I think it's sterling and important advice for us, not to co- not, don't complicate this thing. [01:10:48.072 – 01:10:51.232] Just, you know, it's about, it's about not drinking. [01:10:51.232 – 01:10:54.372] I, I do have a copy of a prescription written by Dr. [01:10:54.372 – 01:11:00.332] Bob, and it's got on there, "Trust G., clean house, help others." I'll, I'll WhatsApp it to David. [01:11:01.556 – 01:11:02.476] Thank you very much. [01:11:02.476 – 01:11:04.996] We're gonna go to Azio now. [01:11:04.996 – 01:11:07.116] Oh, Azio.

[01:11:07.116 – 01:11:10.836] Thank you. [01:11:10.836 – 01:11:19.186] And just, just a sad way, um, that last speech that Dr. [01:11:19.186 – 01:11:26.476] Bob gave where they talked about keep it simple, it's a lot of different takes on that. [01:11:26.476 – 01:11:36.656] And one being especially directed to Bill W. because of his enormous ego and the way he did [01:11:36.656 – 01:11:37.156] things. [01:11:37.156 – 01:11:43.396] And Bill, Bob didn't know how long, how much longer he would be around. [01:11:43.396 – 01:11:45.836] But that's not what I wanted to ask.

[01:11:45.836 – 01:11:56.016] I wanted to ask, um, you mentioned earlier on that, uh, a lot, that there's [01:11:56.016 – 01:12:03.416] a lot of data that went to B. University or can be found at B. University. [01:12:03.416 – 01:12:13.416] Now, they, is it true or would you know if the information that came from the Yale S. [01:12:13.416 – 01:12:23.516] Institute where Bill taught, uh, whether that information was transferred [01:12:23.516 – 01:12:34.026] to, to B. or whether it came from some, uh, because Yale, um, sent all of their information, [01:12:34.026 – 01:12:37.876] uh, to either B. or somewhere else. [01:12:37.876 – 01:12:40.736] And I ca- I'm, I'm not certain of what that is.

[01:12:40.736 – 01:12:44.296] So, uh, that would be my question. [01:12:44.296 – 01:12:45.236] Thank you. [01:12:45.236 – 01:12:49.836] Um, Azio, I have no idea where that… [01:12:49.836 – 01:12:54.396] I mean, I know that Bill worked with Yale and their alcoholism through, through the '40s and '50s. [01:12:54.396 – 01:12:56.686] I, I, I, we're outside of my scope. [01:12:56.686 – 01:13:04.356] You know, you get, you get past June of 1939 and I'm, I'm, I'm, I'm, I'm repeating the same old BS that you heard at a meeting, you know? [01:13:04.356 – 01:13:07.296] I mean, I haven't got any, haven't got any data for that.

[01:13:07.296 – 01:13:08.656] I mean, I've looked to Yale. [01:13:08.656 – 01:13:12.976] I've been up to Yale many, many times to, to the, to the Beinecke R. Book L.. [01:13:12.976 – 01:13:22.036] Whether, whether all that stuff is preserved there or if it's in some sort of administrative hold, I doubt that Yale shipped anything important off to B. University. [01:13:22.036 – 01:13:32.056] They might have shipped copies of it off to Yale U.- to B. University, but the idea of, of Yale just summarily giving up important stuff to B. and say, "Oh no, [01:13:32.056 – 01:13:36.556] you just take it, we don't need it," doesn't, doesn't sound plausible to me, so. [01:13:36.556 – 01:13:39.496] Thank you very much. [01:13:39.496 – 01:13:39.966] Okay.

[01:13:39.966 – 01:13:43.016] We're gonna go to, I think it's Jeannie now. [01:13:43.016 – 01:13:45.076] Yes. [01:13:45.076 – 01:13:48.516] Uh, I'm Jeannie, I'm an alcoholic. [01:13:48.516 – 01:13:59.256] Uh, years ago in a discussion I had heard that, um, Bill hadn't actually worked the 12 steps until about [01:13:59.256 – 01:14:02.056] the time he wrote the 12 and 12. [01:14:02.056 – 01:14:05.856] Is, do you know anything about that? [01:14:05.856 – 01:14:09.216] Jeannie, I would call that an urban legend in Alcoholics Anonymous.

[01:14:09.216 – 01:14:11.556] Uh, that makes no sense to me whatsoever. [01:14:11.556 – 01:14:13.456] No sense to me whatsoever. [01:14:13.456 – 01:14:14.796] No, sorry. [01:14:14.796 – 01:14:16.136] Okay. [01:14:16.136 – 01:14:16.616] Thank you. [01:14:16.616 – 01:14:17.046] Thank you. [01:14:17.046 – 01:14:20.536] We're, we're, we're back to, we're back to Bill W. bashing here.

[01:14:20.536 – 01:14:21.076] You know? [01:14:21.076 – 01:14:23.736] I mean, Azio talked about him having a big ego. [01:14:23.736 – 01:14:26.936] I know he had a big ego, but I don't, I, I personally don't think Dr. [01:14:26.936 – 01:14:31.956] Bob was, was browbeating Bill W. in 1950 over keeping it simple. [01:14:31.956 – 01:14:33.836] I, I just, I wouldn't be going there. [01:14:33.836 – 01:14:36.356] Those guys were, those guys were marching in lockstep. [01:14:36.356 – 01:14:40.196] They were really trying to get AA going to the point where they could step out.

[01:14:40.196 – 01:14:42.436] Another long story. [01:14:42.436 – 01:14:42.876] Okay. [01:14:42.876 – 01:14:44.216] Thank you. [01:14:44.216 – 01:14:46.116] We're gonna go to Jim W. now. [01:14:46.116 – 01:14:47.876] Hello, Jim. [01:14:47.876 – 01:14:48.456] Good evening. [01:14:48.456 – 01:14:49.976] Hi.

[01:14:49.976 – 01:14:51.336] Uh, thanks, uh, Bill. [01:14:51.336 – 01:14:55.396] You've attended our, I'm in Santa B., you've attended our book club out here. [01:14:55.396 – 01:14:56.536] Thanks so much. [01:14:56.536 – 01:15:06.776] Uh, the question is, the, i- i- um, do you feel in the third step prayer when it says take away our difficulties that Bill is referring [01:15:06.776 – 01:15:11.476] to our defects of character, our shortcomings? [01:15:11.476 – 01:15:19.636] I sh- I mean, I think those are certainly included in, in, in Bill's intentions with, say, taking away our difficulties. [01:15:19.636 – 01:15:22.576] But, but there's also difficulties that we pray for.

[01:15:22.576 – 01:15:28.656] We wanna, you know, we wanna, we want this cancer taken away from, from ourse- ourselves or our wife, you know? [01:15:28.656 – 01:15:34.356] There's, there's other things that are covered by that difficulty than just shortcomings and, uh, and defects, I think. [01:15:34.356 – 01:15:36.376] But I don't know. [01:15:36.376 – 01:15:38.636] There's no, there's, again, there's no document. [01:15:38.636 – 01:15:44.836] I don't, can't even find any, any, uh, information, contemporary information for who wrote that. [01:15:44.836 – 01:15:46.636] I presume Bill W. wrote it. [01:15:46.636 – 01:15:51.276] But I, but, but everybody says, "Well, yeah, okay, Bill W. wrote it." But where'd he get it from?

[01:15:51.276 – 01:15:51.686] Mm-hmm. [01:15:51.686 – 01:15:53.296] Well, I don't know where he got it from. [01:15:53.296 – 01:16:01.896] I mean, it just, you know, there's, there's this, this, this, I think of it as some sort of crazy obsession to tell you the truth on part of AA people. [01:16:01.896 – 01:16:05.476] Uh, trying to track everything back from where it came from, you know? [01:16:05.476 – 01:16:15.476] Bill W., Bill W. was a guy who was just, he was collecting stuff out of the spiritual, religious, cultural atmosphere around him, trying to keep himself [01:16:15.476 – 01:16:16.566] and other people sober. [01:16:16.566 – 01:16:19.506] And anything that worked, Bill W. was a pragmatist.

[01:16:19.506 – 01:16:20.356] That's what he was. [01:16:20.356 – 01:16:21.196] He was a pragmatist. [01:16:21.196 – 01:16:26.396] And if it worked, he, he, he told people to keep doing it, and he maybe adopted it himself. [01:16:26.396 – 01:16:28.266] And if it didn't work, he said, "Stop doing that." That's- [01:16:28.380 – 01:16:29.120] Didn't work for Harry. [01:16:29.120 – 01:16:30.840] You know, he got drunk, so we don't wanna be doing that. [01:16:30.840 – 01:16:32.820] He was a supreme pragmatist.

[01:16:32.820 – 01:16:43.180] Um, he beg, borrowed, and stole stuff, but he only beg, borrowed, and stole stuff and kept it because it worked, which is the supreme definition of a pragmatist, [01:16:43.180 – 01:16:43.840] so. [01:16:43.840 – 01:16:45.640] Thank you. [01:16:45.640 – 01:16:48.120] We're gonna go to Marlene now. [01:16:48.120 – 01:16:49.860] Good evening, Marlene. [01:16:49.860 – 01:16:53.580] Good evening. [01:16:53.580 – 01:16:55.860] Thank you, Stuart, and thank you, Bill.

[01:16:55.860 – 01:17:01.660] Packed full of information, but the question I have is when… [01:17:01.660 – 01:17:11.940] And I apologize for not knowing who said it because I was trying to take it all in, but there's a reference you said from the four absolutes, [01:17:11.940 – 01:17:17.620] trying to tell the person if you did absolute, you know, the four absolutes. [01:17:17.620 – 01:17:22.080] And then there was a translation or an extrapolation, I'm not sure. [01:17:22.080 – 01:17:24.180] Um, can you, um… [01:17:24.180 – 01:17:34.280] I guess I wanna, I guess I wanna ask is do you think that was the point where they started to separate from the absolutes, and then they, [01:17:34.280 – 01:17:36.740] then they separated and went a different way?

[01:17:36.740 – 01:17:38.280] Do you get my gist? [01:17:38.280 – 01:17:41.960] I know what you're talking about, Marlene, and, and, and, and I get it. [01:17:41.960 – 01:17:46.200] But you know, it's, it's not an easy, it's not an easy question. [01:17:46.200 – 01:17:49.950] You, you go out to Akron today, and they're gonna quote the four absolutes for you. [01:17:49.950 – 01:17:52.460] They're gonna throw the four absolutes at you right in your face, you know? [01:17:52.460 – 01:17:54.060] Just that's the way it goes. [01:17:54.060 – 01:17:56.360] But in New York they started to separate.

[01:17:56.360 – 01:18:04.980] They, they officially left the Oxford Group, they officially left the Oxford Group in April and May of, April or May of 1937. [01:18:04.980 – 01:18:11.140] But Bill got sober in '34, and between '34 and '37 they were doing the Oxford Group in New York the same way they were doing… [01:18:11.140 – 01:18:16.500] Well, not the same way, but not the same way, but they were doing the Oxford Group in New York City up until that time. [01:18:16.500 – 01:18:21.160] You know, when, when Ebby came and talked to Bill, he was talking the Oxford Group. [01:18:21.160 – 01:18:30.200] He was ta- I mean, they, they don't say he was doing the four absolutes because, because if they said that, then everybody would know it was Oxford Group, and that was bad, so they didn't say that. [01:18:30.200 – 01:18:38.920] But if you think Ebby showed up and wasn't spouting the four absolutes to Bill W. in November of 1934 and in December when he was in the hospital. [01:18:38.920 – 01:18:43.060] So the story we've got is, is from Fitz M..

[01:18:43.060 – 01:18:53.080] He's in the hospital, and he's in the hospital in November of 1935, and a guy comes up to him and says, "You need to be doing these four absolutes," Oxford [01:18:53.080 – 01:18:53.360] Group. [01:18:53.360 – 01:19:03.460] But by the time Fitz wants to put his story in the book, he's rewritten that completely, and he's putting all this stuff about higher power, and making amends, and doing [01:19:03.460 – 01:19:06.640] inventory, and, you know, blah-di-da, all that. [01:19:06.640 – 01:19:08.240] He's changed it by then. [01:19:08.240 – 01:19:10.040] But yeah, up until… [01:19:10.040 – 01:19:20.100] I'm, I'm, I'll guarantee you up until early 1937 they were doing Oxford Group stuff in Alcoholics Anonymous both in Akron, where they're still doing a lot of that, and in

[01:19:20.100 – 01:19:21.920] New York, where they're not still doing that. [01:19:21.920 – 01:19:23.880] Thank you very much. [01:19:23.880 – 01:19:25.280] Thank you. [01:19:25.280 – 01:19:27.540] We're gonna go to Randy in Ontario. [01:19:27.540 – 01:19:28.580] Good evening, Randy. [01:19:28.580 – 01:19:29.880] Good evening. [01:19:29.880 – 01:19:31.760] Uh, hi, Bill.

[01:19:31.760 – 01:19:33.280] Thank you very much. [01:19:33.280 – 01:19:43.280] Uh, did I hear you say or mention, um, Fitz M.'s story was, uh, it's currently and all the [01:19:43.280 – 01:19:49.380] way through, uh, the multi-lith, it's called Our S. Friend? [01:19:49.380 – 01:19:57.640] A- and did I hear correctly when you mentioned, uh, it was called, uh, John B. and I or something like that? [01:19:57.640 – 01:19:59.220] John and, John and… [01:19:59.220 – 01:20:00.920] Me and John it was called. [01:20:00.920 – 01:20:02.600] And, and he meant John B..

[01:20:02.600 – 01:20:13.440] The original typed version that's in the Stepping S. archive is, and it, and it has this really, as I said, it's got this really weird typing format, just as Bill W.'s [01:20:13.440 – 01:20:16.480] first 12,000-word story has. [01:20:16.480 – 01:20:19.440] It's, it, it's got exactly the same kind of crazy format. [01:20:19.440 – 01:20:20.900] Every single line is numbered. [01:20:20.900 – 01:20:24.940] Bill W.'s story goes up to 1,180 lines or something like that. [01:20:24.940 – 01:20:26.200] Just nuts. [01:20:26.200 – 01:20:31.740] And the only, the only other document I've ever seen like that is Fitz M.'s story that they've got up there in the same folder.

[01:20:31.740 – 01:20:37.779] So it was done at the same time, I presume, but it was called Me and, uh, John, Me and John. [01:20:37.779 – 01:20:39.760] And, uh, and it, and it, it… [01:20:39.760 – 01:20:49.760] You know, his story, one of the things we were just talking about, Randy, in the, in the, the chapter we read yesterday is that Fitz M.'s story is the only one that got longer as it went [01:20:49.760 – 01:20:55.400] through these different, different iterations as they approached the April 1939 book. [01:20:55.400 – 01:21:00.140] Everybody else's story was getting whacked down, and Fitz's story almost doubled, I think. [01:21:00.140 – 01:21:05.880] You know, again, I don't remember the numbers off the top of my head 'cause I'm an old guy, and that's why I wrote the book, so you could look it up in the book. [01:21:05.880 – 01:21:09.120] And, uh, but yes, current story kept getting longer and longer.

[01:21:09.120 – 01:21:13.100] And, and I think it's, I think it's interesting to note that Fitz, and Dr. [01:21:13.100 – 01:21:18.660] Bob, and Earl T.'s are the only three stories that a- that appear in all four editions of our book. [01:21:18.660 – 01:21:20.560] All four editions of our book. [01:21:20.560 – 01:21:21.720] Not E. Treat. [01:21:21.720 – 01:21:23.160] I forget who- Thank you very much. [01:21:23.160 – 01:21:24.000] Okay. [01:21:24.000 – 01:21:25.260] Thank you.

[01:21:25.260 – 01:21:26.760] We're gonna go to Paul B. [01:21:26.760 – 01:21:27.320] now. [01:21:27.320 – 01:21:28.500] Hello, Paul, good evening. [01:21:28.500 – 01:21:30.330] Hey, Bill. [01:21:30.330 – 01:21:31.020] How are you doing? [01:21:31.020 – 01:21:32.600] I'm doing great, Paul. [01:21:32.600 – 01:21:33.520] How about yourself?

[01:21:33.520 – 01:21:35.460] I'm doing excellent for an old turkey. [01:21:35.460 – 01:21:39.800] Hey, listen, you, in the beginning you said there was apparently a fifth printing. [01:21:39.800 – 01:21:40.810] Yes, sir. [01:21:40.810 – 01:21:45.260] How many copies of the, of the printing do they- They, they, they do 3,000. [01:21:45.260 – 01:21:48.720] So we did, we did three printings of the hardback, 3,000 copies. [01:21:48.720 – 01:21:50.660] Then they did a paperback, 3,000 copies. [01:21:50.660 – 01:21:51.070] Mm-hmm.

[01:21:51.070 – 01:21:56.030] And now we're, we're, we're gonna, w- actually they're gonna do, uh, another 3,000 of the hardback and- [01:21:56.144 – 01:21:59.344] And then 3,000 of the paperback, I think simultaneously, but I don't know. [01:21:59.344 – 01:22:01.124] It's hard to get- Yeah, yeah, yeah … [01:22:01.124 – 01:22:03.304] supply, supply chain problems. [01:22:03.304 – 01:22:11.694] Hey, Bill, on, uh, on W.'s story, did you say that, uh, Hank P. has put a few paragraphs in there? [01:22:11.694 – 01:22:15.564] He most definitely put four paragraphs in, yes. [01:22:15.564 – 01:22:18.444] And did- Those four paragraphs that I read at the end of my presentation.

[01:22:18.444 – 01:22:23.284] And did Hank put in the paragraphs that explain the 12 steps? [01:22:23.284 – 01:22:25.044] No. [01:22:25.044 – 01:22:26.424] He didn't do that. [01:22:26.424 – 01:22:26.634] No. [01:22:26.634 – 01:22:26.724] No. [01:22:26.724 – 01:22:31.664] As far as we, as far as we know, Bill W. wrote chapter five and six. [01:22:31.664 – 01:22:32.904] Okay.

[01:22:32.904 – 01:22:33.244] Right. [01:22:33.244 – 01:22:35.564] Thank you. [01:22:35.564 – 01:22:42.484] How does somebody go about getting a, a recording of this, of your presentation today, which was fabulous? [01:22:42.484 – 01:22:45.684] Talk to Shaw or David, I guess. [01:22:45.684 – 01:22:46.584] Okay. [01:22:46.584 – 01:22:47.424] I'll talk to them. [01:22:47.424 – 01:22:48.804] Bill, thank you very much.

[01:22:48.804 – 01:22:48.954] Okay, thanks, Bill. [01:22:48.954 – 01:22:50.944] We'll explain at the end of the meeting. [01:22:50.944 – 01:22:54.524] We're gonna go to Bill C. in Los Angeles now. [01:22:54.524 – 01:22:55.483] Good evening, Bill. [01:22:55.483 – 01:22:57.344] Hey. [01:22:57.344 – 01:22:58.724] How's it going? [01:22:58.724 – 01:23:00.083] That was a great presentation.

[01:23:00.083 – 01:23:01.504] I, I love this stuff. [01:23:01.504 – 01:23:11.804] The question I have, is there any evidence that in the Oxford Group they were doing, as a general practice, a written inventory and amends list [01:23:11.804 – 01:23:13.024] and that kind of stuff? [01:23:13.024 – 01:23:14.604] Were they doing that? [01:23:14.604 – 01:23:18.064] You know, I'm, I'm not sure about that, Bill. [01:23:18.064 – 01:23:18.824] I've never heard that. [01:23:18.824 – 01:23:19.944] I know they, I know that the…

[01:23:19.944 – 01:23:22.344] when they did quiet time they wrote. [01:23:22.344 – 01:23:22.984] Yeah. [01:23:22.984 – 01:23:23.364] You know? [01:23:23.364 – 01:23:25.024] That, that's what you, that's what you did. [01:23:25.024 – 01:23:26.904] I mean, you and I have done that at Mago. [01:23:26.904 – 01:23:32.764] I know that we've actually gone through that Oxford Group kind of meditation where you actually write stuff out. [01:23:32.764 – 01:23:39.504] But whether they actually wrote that out, I just discovered a book probably a month ago called, uh, I don't know.

[01:23:39.504 – 01:23:41.844] It's not called The Eight Principles of the Oxford Group. [01:23:41.844 – 01:23:48.804] It's the eight something of the Oxford Group, and I got a copy of it and I'm halfway through it, and so far they haven't mentioned anything about writing out inventory. [01:23:48.804 – 01:23:51.404] So more will be revealed, Bill. [01:23:51.404 – 01:23:54.784] It'd be interesting to find out where that came from. [01:23:54.784 – 01:23:56.084] Like, how that… [01:23:56.084 – 01:23:58.364] It must have morphed from something. [01:23:58.364 – 01:24:01.324] Yeah, I mean, what do people get crazy over?

[01:24:01.324 – 01:24:02.254] You know, like, where did Mr. [01:24:02.254 – 01:24:03.224] B. come from? [01:24:03.224 – 01:24:05.603] Where did that format come from that, that he did? [01:24:05.603 – 01:24:15.474] And obviously, you know, he either stole it from somebody or he made it up himself, or somebody in the group made it up and they all said, "Hey, that's a, that's a good way to do that." You know? [01:24:15.474 – 01:24:25.484] I mean, for years in my circle, my non-reading the big book circle for the first 20 years of my sobriety, uh, we had a guy come into a, you know, [01:24:25.484 – 01:24:28.584] a step meeting one time and he said, I, I only saw him this one time. [01:24:28.584 – 01:24:31.824] He said, "My sponsor, uh, made me do a fourth step this way.

[01:24:31.824 – 01:24:33.804] He, I had to take out four pieces of paper. [01:24:33.804 – 01:24:40.084] The first one," he said, "I was confused by resentment, so they told me I had to put people who piss me off at the top of that and make a list of those things. [01:24:40.084 – 01:24:43.444] Things I'm a, things I'm afraid of was the second piece of paper. [01:24:43.444 – 01:24:52.234] Things, uh, things I'm embarrassed about was the third piece of paper, and the fourth piece of paper was things I never told anybody else." And I was, like, floored. [01:24:52.234 – 01:25:02.364] I heard that, and that became, that was, like, the Stratford M.'s how to do the, how to do the fourth step for, for a decade or 15 years until we started doing the step work [01:25:02.364 – 01:25:03.224] group stuff, you know? [01:25:03.224 – 01:25:08.444] And, and really blew it out into, into, into a based on the big book kind of thing.

[01:25:08.444 – 01:25:10.904] But, but I think it was that kind of a thing. [01:25:10.904 – 01:25:12.754] Somebody in the group did a Mr. [01:25:12.754 – 01:25:17.584] B. kind of inventory and, you know, they looked at it and some, you know, they said, "Oh, that's really cool. [01:25:17.584 – 01:25:18.804] Let's, let's all do that. [01:25:18.804 – 01:25:21.164] Let's all do that." Well, we know for sure that Mr. [01:25:21.164 – 01:25:22.664] B. needs his ass kicked. [01:25:22.664 – 01:25:24.164] Yeah, I saw a T-shirt.

[01:25:24.164 – 01:25:27.224] I seen a T-shirt at the Atlanta convention said Mr. [01:25:27.224 – 01:25:28.934] B. needs to get his ass kicked. [01:25:28.934 – 01:25:31.144] And I thought, now that guy reads his big book. [01:25:31.144 – 01:25:32.604] That was really a great job. [01:25:32.604 – 01:25:33.564] Thank you, Bill. [01:25:33.564 – 01:25:36.164] Thank you for everything you do, Bill C.. [01:25:36.164 – 01:25:36.684] Thank you.

[01:25:36.684 – 01:25:38.744] Thank you. [01:25:38.744 – 01:25:43.864] And our last question for tonight we're going to South A., uh, to Ja- Ja- Janos? [01:25:43.864 – 01:25:44.364] Janos? [01:25:44.364 – 01:25:45.764] Uh, Janos. [01:25:45.764 – 01:25:46.124] Yes. [01:25:46.124 – 01:25:46.824] Uh, thank you. [01:25:46.824 – 01:25:47.684] Good evening to all.

[01:25:47.684 – 01:25:48.673] Uh, thank you, Bill. [01:25:48.673 – 01:25:53.964] Uh, I, I found a podcast on YouTube, uh, Bill W. [01:25:53.964 – 01:26:04.124] speaking at a 1951 international conference, and he says there that, uh, AA was formed actually three years before people think. [01:26:04.124 – 01:26:08.444] Uh, and he, he refers to his meeting with Carl J.. [01:26:08.444 – 01:26:12.364] Um, and, uh, I seen your presentation. [01:26:12.364 – 01:26:20.084] You didn't mention, uh, much of that in terms of what influence did Carl J. have, and obviously tied to the religious experience. [01:26:20.084 – 01:26:30.424] Um, and sort of my connected question to that was that from what you presented, Jack, could we sort of assume that the, the fundamental and core essence of the recovery

[01:26:30.424 – 01:26:33.564] is the spiritual experience from, from what Bill said? [01:26:33.564 – 01:26:39.844] 'Cause his, his initial focus really was that connection with God and that God will, will solve the problem. [01:26:39.844 – 01:26:41.224] Yeah. [01:26:41.224 – 01:26:43.624] Janos, you're absolutely right about, about… [01:26:43.624 – 01:26:48.304] I mean, when I read all those excerpts out of the 30 stories in the back, I mean, what were they all saying? [01:26:48.304 – 01:26:52.624] They were all saying you know, "Hook up with God and get sober." I mean, that was really the message. [01:26:52.624 – 01:26:52.634] That's it.

[01:26:52.634 – 01:26:53.804] And, and that was fine. [01:26:53.804 – 01:26:57.524] The, uh, uh, I, I don't know what talk you're talking about. [01:26:57.524 – 01:27:02.184] The, the, the internationals always happen on zeros and fives, so it would've been one of those. [01:27:02.184 – 01:27:12.464] But what, what, what, what, what Bill would've been talking about wasn't so much his involvement with Carl J. as it was Roland H.'s involvement [01:27:12.464 – 01:27:13.264] with Carl J.. [01:27:13.264 – 01:27:18.304] So there's that whole story in, in, uh, in, in More A. Alcoholism. [01:27:18.304 – 01:27:18.924] More A.?

[01:27:18.924 – 01:27:19.184] No. [01:27:19.184 – 01:27:20.744] In T. is a Solution. [01:27:20.744 – 01:27:23.714] In the back of There is a Solution it tells a story about Roland [01:27:23.836 – 01:27:29.515] Roland H., he's not named, but he goes to see Carl J., and there's that whole story that got passed around all the time. [01:27:29.515 – 01:27:39.536] Now the first time Bill W. wrote There is a Solution, you know, the famous line from Carl J. is to, to, uh, to, uh, Roland H. is, "You know, you need to get [01:27:39.536 – 01:27:43.276] yourself a vital spiritual experience." That's what it says in our book. [01:27:43.276 – 01:27:53.896] You need a, quote, "a vital spiritual experience." But the first version that Bill wrote of that story in 1938 or early 19- uh, in, uh, June or, or May of 1938,

[01:27:53.896 – 01:27:57.556] it doesn't say vital spiritual, it says vital religious experience. [01:27:57.556 – 01:28:00.376] He quotes J. as saying a vital religious experience. [01:28:00.376 – 01:28:05.776] Now that got toned down, it got morphed down, it got, it got, you know, we got, we got, got a… [01:28:05.776 – 01:28:13.596] Hank P. was pounding on Bill W. to soften up the God stuff, and that's one serious and very, very important place that it got softened up. [01:28:13.596 – 01:28:23.716] And then the whole story, one of the, one of the things that made AA, AA historians crazy for years was this when did Roland H. go see Carl J., and how [01:28:23.716 – 01:28:26.946] long did he stay, and when did he drink, and da, da, da. [01:28:26.946 – 01:28:36.076] And there's a, there's a, there's a, a really great piece of research done by a woman named Cora F., F-I-N-C-H, and it's online someplace.

[01:28:36.076 – 01:28:41.796] It's called s- it's not called Catching F., that's, that's, uh, that's the f- that's the, the Hunger G.. [01:28:41.796 – 01:28:44.006] But it's, uh, it's something- That's it, that's it … [01:28:44.006 – 01:28:45.896] fire, and, uh, and this woman did… [01:28:45.896 – 01:28:48.206] it's like a, I don't know, a 40, 50-page paper. [01:28:48.206 – 01:28:57.996] It's a brilliant, brilliant piece of, uh, investigation on when that stuff happened between, when that stuff probably happened between J. and, uh, and Roland H.. [01:28:57.996 – 01:29:00.176] Cora F., you say? [01:29:00.176 – 01:29:01.056] Cora F..

[01:29:01.056 – 01:29:01.516] Yeah. [01:29:01.516 – 01:29:01.646] Yeah. [01:29:01.646 – 01:29:02.136] Cora F.. [01:29:02.136 – 01:29:03.036] I'll write that down. [01:29:03.036 – 01:29:03.416] I- Thank you. [01:29:03.416 – 01:29:04.336] Thanks so much … [01:29:04.336 – 01:29:10.056] if you got a copy of my book and you look in the index and find Cora F., I'm sure you'll find a reference to whatever the name of that thing is.

[01:29:10.056 – 01:29:11.086] I- Okay, cool … [01:29:11.086 – 01:29:11.455] I'm, I'm old. [01:29:11.455 – 01:29:14.476] I can't remember lots of people's names, so. [01:29:14.476 – 01:29:15.416] Great. [01:29:15.416 – 01:29:15.816] Super. [01:29:15.816 – 01:29:16.536] Thank you, Bill. [01:29:16.536 – 01:29:17.096] Thank you.

[01:29:17.096 – 01:29:18.876] That's all, everybody. [01:29:18.876 – 01:29:20.455] Thank you very much indeed. [01:29:20.455 – 01:29:22.436] We're gonna hand the meeting back to David now. [01:29:22.436 – 01:29:23.816] Thank you, Stuart. [01:29:23.816 – 01:29:26.696] Just to let you know that, uh, Bill S. has some talks coming up. [01:29:26.696 – 01:29:29.036] I just wanna me- mention those as well before we close. [01:29:29.036 – 01:29:32.646] Bill, we'll go back to you shortly to close with, uh, maybe, I don't know, a few thoughts or something.

[01:29:32.646 – 01:29:35.596] Just maybe if you want to do the evening gathering, that's cool. [01:29:35.596 – 01:29:39.916] But Bill's got this one once a month for 13 months, exploring the big book one chapter at a time. [01:29:39.916 – 01:29:41.016] Just take note of this one. [01:29:41.016 – 01:29:42.656] It's starting Sunday, July 10th. [01:29:42.656 – 01:29:44.226] The first two forwards, Drew H. [01:29:44.226 – 01:29:45.136] is gonna be there. [01:29:45.136 – 01:29:50.676] People and places, Bill S., uh, Bill S., and they've got- they have a monthly guest speaker.

[01:29:50.676 – 01:29:51.846] Again, J- Yeah. [01:29:51.846 – 01:29:52.066] David. [01:29:52.066 – 01:29:52.906] David, I just gotta say- Yes … [01:29:52.906 – 01:29:54.076] I think that's gonna be… [01:29:54.076 – 01:30:04.456] I'm, we just, Drew and Alan and I got together today after I talked to you, and, uh, and we spent an hour and a half going over the PowerPoints we've got going so far. [01:30:04.456 – 01:30:07.856] And, you know, we're, we're having a hard time squeezing it into the time allotted. [01:30:07.856 – 01:30:12.056] I've, I've, I've easily got a- an hour's worth of stuff on the, on the first two forwards.

[01:30:12.056 – 01:30:17.536] You know, the, the history and, and, and the problems and the issues of the, the good things and the bad things that are in there. [01:30:17.536 – 01:30:22.316] It's just, those things are just rich, rich, rich with, with sobriety material. [01:30:22.316 – 01:30:23.545] Really, really good information. [01:30:23.545 – 01:30:25.516] And we're gonna do a chapter a month. [01:30:25.516 – 01:30:27.016] Every month we're gonna do one chapter. [01:30:27.016 – 01:30:31.976] So we're gonna do the two forwards, then we're gonna do the doctor's opinion, then we're gonna do Bill's story, and then we're gonna do the… [01:30:31.976 – 01:30:37.656] I'm looking forward to that because normally what I do in these presentations is I talk about people and what they did.

[01:30:37.656 – 01:30:46.236] And what I'm gonna be talking about in this series of 13 monthly presentations is what does it say in the book and how did we get there? [01:30:46.236 – 01:30:49.616] What was the history between how that got there? [01:30:49.616 – 01:30:51.196] Wow, what a great time. [01:30:51.196 – 01:30:53.796] I got sober listening to people like Bill C. on cassettes. [01:30:53.796 – 01:30:55.856] Wonderful time that was as well. [01:30:55.856 – 01:30:58.716] But now look at us, we're on Zoom and we have access to all these people. [01:30:58.716 – 01:30:59.576] How wonderful is that?

[01:30:59.576 – 01:31:02.735] And in August, uh, 6th, look at this. [01:31:02.735 – 01:31:06.096] You Zoom, you have Bill is doing a talk here on 9:00 AM. [01:31:06.096 – 01:31:09.836] Bill S.'s doing Changing the Big Book: Bill's Story. [01:31:09.836 – 01:31:12.676] And Patrick O. is there as well, and Drew H. [01:31:12.676 – 01:31:13.276] again. [01:31:13.276 – 01:31:14.196] Look, what a wonderful. [01:31:14.196 – 01:31:18.056] And I just want to, uh, mention, of course, Mike M. again.

[01:31:18.056 – 01:31:21.686] If you'd, uh, knew Mike at all from Zoom, and what a wonderful guy. [01:31:21.686 – 01:31:27.676] And you can contact for the in person email toddbowen@gmail.com, and also you can contact Debbie. [01:31:27.676 – 01:31:28.556] I think Debbie's here. [01:31:28.556 – 01:31:31.616] threads1058@gmail.com. [01:31:31.616 – 01:31:40.376] And they have this flyer going out, Worldwide S. Marathon: We Grieve and Now We Grow, and that's in memory of our friend Mike M.. [01:31:40.376 – 01:31:45.276] Bill S., as always, it's a pleasure, a privilege, you know, with just delight. [01:31:45.276 – 01:31:49.416] We're gonna close the meeting with, uh, maybe it's some reflection.

[01:31:49.416 – 01:31:50.476] People out applauding there. [01:31:50.476 – 01:31:52.316] Please do unmute yourselves if you'd like to do that. [01:31:52.316 – 01:31:53.386] Thank you very much, everyone. [01:31:53.386 – 01:31:55.536] If you'd like to unmute. [01:31:55.536 – 01:31:56.976] Thank you. [01:31:56.976 – 01:31:58.076] Thank you, Dave. [01:31:58.076 – 01:31:58.966] Thank you.

[01:31:58.966 – 01:32:00.326] Thank you so, so much. [01:32:00.326 – 01:32:01.146] Thank you. [01:32:01.146 – 01:32:01.556] Thank you. [01:32:01.556 – 01:32:01.656] Thanks. [01:32:01.656 – 01:32:02.276] Thank you. [01:32:02.276 – 01:32:03.316] Well done. [01:32:03.316 – 01:32:04.416] Well done.

[01:32:04.416 – 01:32:04.796] Well done. [01:32:04.796 – 01:32:05.676] Thank you. [01:32:05.676 – 01:32:06.376] Thank you. [01:32:06.376 – 01:32:07.576] Great meeting. [01:32:07.576 – 01:32:08.876] So glad I got home. [01:32:08.876 – 01:32:09.516] Thank you, Bill. [01:32:09.516 – 01:32:10.336] Okay.

[01:32:10.336 – 01:32:13.016] Thank you, Bill. [01:32:13.016 – 01:32:21.056] So with that, W- Bill, do you want to close with, uh, any particular, Bill S.? [01:32:21.056 – 01:32:24.936] I think he's gone, David. [01:32:24.936 – 01:32:25.536] He jumped. [01:32:25.536 – 01:32:25.976] He jumped. [01:32:25.976 – 01:32:26.536] He gone. [01:32:26.536 – 01:32:27.196] Okay.

[01:32:27.196 – 01:32:28.276] Shall we have the evening gathering? [01:32:28.276 – 01:32:30.916] Shall we close with the usual where we use God as you understand it? [01:32:30.916 – 01:32:32.176] What a friendly prayer. [01:32:32.176 – 01:32:33.796] God. [01:32:33.796 – 01:32:35.056] God. [01:32:35.056 – 01:32:36.086] Welcome to us. [01:32:36.086 – 01:32:37.036] Surrounds us.

[01:32:37.036 – 01:32:37.116] Surrounds us. [01:32:37.116 – 01:32:39.916] To accept things we cannot change. [01:32:39.916 – 01:32:43.006] Things we cannot change. [01:32:43.006 – 01:32:43.046] Courage. [01:32:43.046 – 01:32:43.726] Courage to change the things I can. [01:32:43.726 – 01:32:44.046] I can. [01:32:44.046 – 01:32:45.896] Wisdom.

[01:32:45.896 – 01:32:46.745] To know the difference. [01:32:46.745 – 01:32:46.746] To know the difference. [01:32:46.746 – 01:32:47.656] Thank you, everyone. [01:32:47.656 – 01:32:49.356] Bye.