Bill W — Spiritual Experience and Traditions (1966–1968 Compilation) — AA (1966)

Archive note: This compilation joins a talk on the Traditions with a discussion of spiritual experience. The same performances overlap recordings already available separately in the archive. Source labeling associates the material with 1966–1968; this is not a single continuous event or a newly discovered performance. Traditions address; Spiritual experience discussion.

Audio

Transcript

Source: Unidentified Historical Recording – Bill W Candidate Identity Review BW0008 – Date Unknown.mp3 File: bill-w-spiritual-experience-and-traditions-1966-1968-compilation-aa-1966-archive-19101.mp3 Duration: 01:02:14

============================================================

Hi, folks. In the end, we have a principle. Let's live one day at a time. Tomorrow is gone, today is here, and the future is not yet with us. And in that trite little statement, there is a great deal of wisdom. But like so many of our familiar clichés, it doesn't cover all the territory, and can leave us rather cockeyed on the subject of time. I make these few observations as a backdrop on talking a little about the traditions.

For example, if a person is all the time in the past, whether with guilt, whether with remorse, or wishing for the good old days when he could drink like a gentleman, no progress at all is possible. And at best, he becomes a conservative who is against all change. On the other hand, if I live in today in a really absolute sense, and forget about yesterday, and take nothing about tomorrow, I become a creature of pure experience.

And you get nowhere. On the contrary, if I'm always pondering the future, I'm out of the reality of today. So, that if you make these two core divisions of time, and label this one as good, the present, and the past is rather bad, and the future is not something to be concerned with, I think we're out of balance. Actually, time is a stream of consciousness. And we came on it out of the past, through the day, and we brought it into the future.

Now then, what bearing does this have on the age of tradition? You know, at times we're apt to congratulate ourselves upon those traditions. As though it were a list of our collective virtues, about which we wish to drink. We say, oh yes, we put the commonwealth out first. Oh yes, we're a pure democracy. Oh yes, we have no punishments, no rules, no regulations, a beautiful benign entity in that sense.

And we don't get complicated with endorsements or alliances. And we keep ourselves as collectively pure as possible, so as to not get messed up with Dell, Silky Lucre, and we have no professional flag. You know, plumbers can do as well as anybody with A.A., only to creep. We just don't need that, and so on. We go through this list as though we were reciting a list of virtues that are singular to us.

Well, I submit that's a rather dangerous and childish thing. Actually, these twelve traditions, which are before me here, are in reality a codification of the lessons of past experience that we got out of the school of damned hard knocks in the early days of A.A., and which we continue to get. These are the lessons of experience, this list of hopeful do's and don'ts. Now then, I think about the origins of some of these traditions.

I believe the theme of our upcoming conference is really the common welfare comes first. Without A.A. unity, there can be no recovery. That's the frank recognition of the fifth point. But as you look at the traditions, one after another, you see that all of them are directly or indirectly related to this subject of the common welfare.

[00:05:04]

And you see this idea in great strength in this last tradition. Anonymity is the spiritual foundation of all our traditions. Everyone wants us to place principles before personalities. Well, that, I think, is a spiritual statement of the idea of the common welfare. Take tradition two. In the early days of A.A., we weren't placing principles ahead of personalities all the time. There wasn't any such thing as a group conscience.

Dr. Bob and I were school teachers at court, and as our leadership was gained in strength, we began to think very well of ourselves. And it was a very long time before we realized that those in position of leadership are biased by consideration of power, prestige, money, and the like. That's how we started off. But the time came little by little, and through many bitter experiences, and I've undergone some, and Bob has, and any old time has, the group conscience began to say to us, the common welfare comes first.

We do not have these biases. Let us take thought to the general welfare, and after that, let's see where the leadership stands. So we turn up as leaders who have not power in the usual sense, not prestige in the usual sense. We turn up as genuine servants with the discretion from the group conscience to act with us, and that's our faith here. The general welfare comes first. Take another which may at first glance seem a little remote.

At about year two of the Akron group, a poor devil came to Dr. Bob in a grievous state. He could qualify as an alcoholic all right. And then he said, Dr. Bob, I've got a real problem to pose you. I don't know if I could join AA because I'm sex deviated. Well, that had to go out to the group conscience. You know, up to then it was supposed that any society could say who was going to join us. And pretty soon the group conscience began to seethe and boil, and it boiled over.

And under no circumstances could we have such a power and such a disgrace among us, said the gentleman. And you know, right then our destiny hung on a razor edge over this single case. In other words, would there be rules that could exclude so-called undesirability? And that caused us in that time and for quite a time, respecting this single case, to ponder what is the more important, the reputation that we shall have, what people shall think, or is it our character?

And who are we, considering our records? Alcoholism is quite as unlovely. Who are we to deny a man his opportunity, any man or woman? And finally the day of resolution came. And a bunch were sitting in Dr. Bob's living room, arguing what to do. Whereupon dear old Bob looked around and blandly said, Isn't it time, folks, to ask ourselves, what would the Master do in a situation like this? Would he turn this man away?

And that's at the beginning of the ancient tradition,

[00:10:04]

that any man who has a drinking problem is a member of A.A. if he says so, not whether we say so. Now, I think that the importance of uncommon welfare has already been set, because it takes in even more territory than the confines of our fellowship. It takes in the whole world of alcoholism. Their charter to freedom, to join A.A., is assured. Indeed, it was enacted in the general welfare. Then we got into, very naturally, into this question of how we were going to relate ourselves to other people in the field of endeavor.

How are we going to relate ourselves to the public at large? And again this same question. The public welfare, or the A.A. welfare, the general welfare. And we came up with the view that we had better stick to our lesson. We could offer our principles to the whole world, and offer the whole world everything but A.A.'s name, which we would like to have sent with those principles. And this, you see, has served the general welfare.

Now, you have a terrific amount of deviations, you see, all this time. Letters were pouring in after the Saturday Post was sent to the office. And naturally, we were getting married, through the microphones, through both anonymity, to all sorts of enterprises, some good, some bad, some indifferent. So the lesson was borne in. We're not so criticized and embarrassed in society around us, but we dare not give in.

Not that we're afraid. This is sense of truth. It's good sense, and we've already seen what happens when we start to do this. And so it goes down through this whole list of traditions. In the early days, in public relations, the A.A. thought, well, I'll get myself on the radio. I've got connections. I'll get my name and picture in the paper. Well, that's what everybody else does. But after a few had fallen on their faces after doing this, we began to see that it wasn't for us.

And so, as I've said, our tradition is a list of the lessons of yesterday. So that as you read the traditions with a sense of history and information about it, you will relive our past, and you will see how we have brought forth, from the past on its time stream, the lessons thereof, and have tried to make estimates about the future. We are not absolutely fixed in all of our principles. There is room for change.

On the other hand, we shall not lightly cast away these hard-earned principles which bear on our unity, on our survival, on our growth, under God's grace. As Herb left us, I think that we stepped out of one epoch into another. During his tenure, the last basic modification was made in our structure, the ratio of change, in which we assumed.

[00:15:00]

full responsibility as a fact for the conduct of our world affairs. This, perhaps, is the last great change in basics. And as I remarked this afternoon, or this afternoon session, I made the remark that now it is a question, I presume, what we have of improving its function. We can always improve its function. But I don't think I nailed that proposition down. I think I made it seem as though everything was going to be clear sailing from here on.

And when Tommy Breen got up to keynote this thing, and we have a keynoter now, you know, probably well over after. I'm going to lose my job, I can see that. Anyway, Tom got up and he said, It's all very well that we have this practice. It's very well that we have this tradition. It's very well that our functional structure seems adequate. But let us be vivid. The problems and difficulties of the future can actually be greater than those we have already survived.

Let's not be pessimistic, but let's be realistic. This, in effect, is what he said. And after all, we are living in a most dangerous world. We are surrounded by behavior to the exact opposite of that by which we must conform to survive. In other words, minorities are able to say, we are the most important. The general welfare has to wait upon us. And the world is going through the same cycle. On what apparently, from a poor alcoholic's point of view, is one hell of a drive then.

A very, very dangerous. So that life may, in the next ten or twenty years, be a very dangerous one for each of us. It may be dangerous for our whole society. Certainly we have little chance at religious escape. But let us never underestimate the bad forces which are tearing the world apart. Have you ever sat down and seriously thought what we'd do if we were given underground? Have you ever seriously thought how we would be affected by firing squads?

Is it common everywhere? Don't suppose I'm pessimistic, I'm hopeful. Now, vigil is going to be the price that we pay for unity. And the love among us and for each other. That indeed everything considers, happens all in the same. These are the things that under God's grace, I am certain, will sustain us through all calamity. No matter how formidable. Thank you. Well, I'll sit down after all of this.

[00:20:01]

Well, I like the informal discussion type of approach. It seems to me that on occasion like this, questions are something of infinitely more value than a lecture or a story. But Rick suggested that I make some remarks here tonight, and I'm only too glad to do that. I'm coming down on a plane. I got speculating with myself about the early days of the AA, and about the meaning of them in terms of the grace of God.

I've read somewhere that the grain of wheat, which has been stored for centuries in a dry place, is exposed to the right soil and the right climate and to enough light from above. It will manifest life, and it will unfold, and it will grow. But this presupposes the right soil, the right climate, and above all, enough light. Well, I think it's that way with AA. I remember years back to when we first began to get publicity.

And the first very large occasion was a speech done in the Saturday Evening Post, which all at once produced up to about 6,000 members. This was in 41, and by then a number of medics had become close friends, some of them psychiatrists. And these fellows allowed their names to be used, a rather audacious step in those days, I assure you. Their names were used in post articles. I make this point because one later had to testify on another occasion, and it seems to do it.

And these were the circumstances. The first gal that got sober in AA is one known to many of you as Marty. They were very much of a growing concern in the education field. Marty was the most good coach ever. God knows they're all complex, but Marty was really a champ. And she had been under the care of a Dr. Foster Kennedy, a man of very wide repute in that time, worldwide renown, a neurologist. And he watched Marty as she was planted in the new soil.

He watched her receive good life. Well, he was tremendously impressed. He came to some meetings, and soon he said to me, Bill, would it be possible to have two or three of the psychiatrists in institutions who have seen recovery, the very good cases, people that you say are friends of yours who have testified for you in the post case, couldn't we get a group of this sort to come to the Academy of Medicine and explain what they have seen?

Well, we thought this was just great, because in those days there were a few friends indeed. So showing by reason of Dr. Kennedy, well, what could we do? So one by one we went to them. And we said, will they come to the Academy? And we supposed they would. After all, some of the candidate lawyers had brushed her off, and, you know, they were friends anyhow, and they proved it. So why not?

[00:25:00]

And not a one would do it. And when pressed for their reasons for not doing it, each one of them separately said the same thing. In effect, he said, look, Bill, you folks have added up to in one column more of the resources which have been separately applied to alcoholics than anyone else. For example, you have this kinship in suffering. You have possibilities of communication that others don't have.

You have a crude form of self-examination or analysis and of psychology. You have a great new outgoing interest. You reduce guilt by restitution. And you have this great compelling interest in helping others. And then there is the religious factor. And then there is this factor of the hopeless, so far as the resources of the individual are concerned, of the malice. Now, this is the formidable risk of fortune.

But we still can't come to the academy. Well, why not? Well, today, we see in any of us, sometimes in weeks, in a few months, shifts in motivation that even the sum of resources couldn't begin to account for because we all too well understand the difficulties of this fashion, this set of compulsions. And if some of us add up to the speed of these transformations, we would be very, very tabled. So for us, there is an unknown factor at work in any of us.

And among ourselves, these factors, we call it the x-factor. We believe in it, people call it the grace of God. And who shall go to the academy to explain the grace of God to their fellow men? No one can, and we simply aren't one. So, I think it is just as futile as ever for any of us to presume to explain this matter of grace around which our entire galaxy of principles and activities gathers and fluxes.

We can't do that. But we can examine this matter of the self, and this matter of life, and this matter of illumination, which, for some reason or other, we have made ourselves ready. Clearly, God's grace is in true law. So, it might be said, why haven't alcoholics over many times more often through grace than they have? It's available. Why hasn't religion been more protective numerically of religion?

Why hasn't medicine been more protective? How is it that laymen seem to be doing this better? So, I would like to tell a story.

[00:30:00]

Depicting, at least as it seems to me, what the style is, what the climate is, and what the light is, these things of which we have been placed in such treasured possession. There is no doubt that in an ordinary sense of time, A.A. began in the office on a surprise and we might be mindful of this when we criticize pretenders especially. Of course, for most of us, we are as in the two thousand years old, for some of us perhaps older, but I am speaking of the situation in an immediate sense.

How was it precipitated, this thing? This too is a matter of conjecture, but this, how it seems to me, there was a certain businessman of great attainment. He was cut down by the Grimes. He ruined the gamut of treatment in this country, and this would be in the year about 1932 when he was just about at the end of his career. So he went abroad and became a patient of Dr. Carl Jung. And as all of you know, Jung was one of the founding fathers of the art, I prefer that instead of science, of psychiatry.

And Jung, Adler, Freud, were the three founding fathers, but of these, only Jung seemed to think that man is something more than two dollars worth of chemicals, a bundle of instincts, and an uncertain intellect. Jung thought that man has something beyond what man has thought. So, our traveler had found a truly great human being. Great indeed, as it then fell out. He placed himself under that dear man's tutelage for a whole year, becoming more and more confident.

That the hidden strains of this baleful compulsion to drink were being understood, and removed, and that's the way. He began to feel more free. There was no drinking while he was on retreat. At the end of the year, he left Carl Jung, and in one month he was past. And the Denver was terrific. So, in infinite despair, he came back to Carl Jung and said, Is there anything now for me? You were my court of last resort.

And this great man said, Rome, I thought for a time, after you first came, that you might be one of those rare cases in which my art has been helpful. Otherwise, I should not have encouraged you instead.

[00:35:02]

But alas, I am obliged to conclude that you are not. And that there is nothing that I have to offer you. My art has failed you. I need not say that coming from a man of his eminence, this one statement, how beautiful to know it. And the whole decadence of their age, you and me, and all this, has spent time on their senses. So then has he found that agony was added to his suffering. And he cried out, but is there nothing now?

And this was the answer he got. Rome, time out of mind, out of heart, have recovery, here and there, now and then, through religious experiences, spiritual experiences, let it say, or very truly through conversion. And that he was brought to age, we don't use it for obvious reasons. But, said the bachelor, this benign writing says such. And no one can say where or when it was, or for the representation of whom.

So I simply would advise you to place yourself in a religious atmosphere, remembering the hopelessness of your doing anything about it on your own remaining resources alone. And cooperating with your associates, and casting yourself upon whatever God there may be. So Rome, aligned itself with the Oxford groups of that time, a rather evangelical movement, rather aggressive, so he needed to criticize.

It was non-denominational, however, and it used simple common denominators of religion. Simple moral principles. It called upon its members to admit that they could not solve the life problem on their own. It called upon them for self-examination. It called upon them for restitution. It called upon them for a kind of giving in the Franciscan manner, a kind of giving that demands no return in money, power, prestige, and the like.

You're losing yourself in the lines of others. Such was the nature of the crowd with which he became associated. Unaccountable to him, the obsession to drink left. And for some years he had no more trouble. At the time in the groups there were a few alcoholics sober, there was one now at Ann Arbor that goes back to that time. An old friend who never became an AA. Sucked it up in the Oxford group. So Rome became a marathon, and the groups here in those days were headed by an ecclesiastical trademan called Sam Schumacher.

[00:40:10]

And in his congregation and among the groups were two or three other alcoholics that poured an ounce for the same guy. And Hazard had a summer place near Benton, Vermont. And two friends, one of them son of a local judge, and himself an alcoholic, described the plight of a boy who was a school at the time, Sam Schumacher, Ebby Sanchez. And Ebby had been deteriorating horribly. There were summer folks in the town above Manchester.

Ebby had run his car into the side of a farmer's house, pushed it out of the kitchen and the jar was still open in the car. Ebby stuck his head out into the poor woman carrying in the corner who hadn't been hit. He said, hey, what about a cup of coffee? Well, the town fathers were panicked. They were going to commit Ebby for alcoholic insanity. So the judge's son and Hazard picked up the man who was to become my sponsor.

Meanwhile, I had gone the route which you're all familiar. I had sobered up the summer before, prepared to bet by the verdict of my doctor, Dr. Silkfoot, the one we have since named the little doctor who loved drunks, and he must have been because in his lifetime he dealt with some 40,000 of them, as a pack doctor in a drying out place. And he had an idea that this thing was an illness, having several components, a spiritual illness, a moral illness, and also a physical illness.

And perhaps oversimplifying, he was asked to describe an alcoholic as a person condemned by a compulsion to drink against his own interests, to drink in spite of his perfect willingness to stop, and that this drinking was coupled to an increasing sensitivity to the body, which if the drinking went on guaranteed his insanity and one day his death. Now, this sort of repentance had been spoken to law at long last by my doctor, Dr. Silkfoot.

So, you see, the saw was under preparation. We were beginning to learn a little more about time. Abby and my other friend Roland had received a considerable amount of life. Well, I got drunk in about two months, and provided with sentences that I would have to be locked up, all go nuts, maybe within a year. And then my friend Abby, who had been brought to New York from Vermont, who sat unaccountably sober, that's the reason I'm being in the access group, came to visit me when I, too, was in great despair.

Despair is a primary ingredient, indeed, of this thought. In the medical jargon, we might call it depression or death. Some depression, huh? So, Abby came to see me. And he pitched it to me.

[00:45:00]

All you might say, cliche, nothing general about that. I was in favor of honesty. I was in favor of helping other people. I was in favor of practically everything he had to say, except one thing. I was not in favor of God. For I had received one of those magnificent modern schools, scientific schooling, that assured me that by a series of stages, picking up information somehow, as they went along, I could be traced back to a single piece of ooze in prehistoric trees.

And this was my faith. And time was my gun. So along comes attitude. And along comes unity, for whom I had respect. And here was my reaction. Science can't do it. Medicine can't do it. Psychology can't do it. Religion can't do it. That was the thought. But how could I buy religion? So I felt trapped. In other words, I was gripped in a trap which we every day construct for the drunk who approaches us, saying, well, I think the group was much too great, helping other people and so on.

But I couldn't get the spiritual angle of that guy. Now, as you know, this gentleman is a newcomer, like me, is being caught in this trap. When you and I talk to another alcoholic, and we identify ourselves as having been denizens of this strange world and having emerged, and we describe this malady in the terms of our God's science, and that God pronounces a sense of hopelessness upon us, a sentence.

We are deflated with death. And then we learn that now we have accepted our personal hopelessness. There still is many hopes because we cannot go to the doctor. And this was the awful one into which I was captured by my friend Debbie. Bringing on the one side all of the bad news, but on the other side, the spectacle of his own release. And that was the word to use. He couldn't say he was on the waterway.

The obsession had just left him as soon as he became willing to trust on the basis of these principles. And indeed, as he said, he became willing to appeal to whatever God there might be. And this was reducing the theological requirements of an alcoholic. Then I went on drinking again for three weeks, and in no waking hour could I forget the face of my friend, a spectacle of release. As I looked out through a haze of gin in Ruth's face, as he puts the sentences at me, a conversion experience is not for me.

I'm an obstacle to the martyr. Besides, I can't die. People say to me, have faith. And I believe I'd have faith if I could have it, but I can't. But anyhow, I'll go and get dried up.

[00:50:00]

So I went with the hunch. I must have had a little optimism because I came in with a bag of beer. I tried to share it on the subway up. I was waving bottles. Dr. Silkworth came out, and I yelled at him this time down, but I got him. He said, I'm afraid you have, Bill. You better get upstairs or you'll die. And he looked very sad. Thought he loved me. So I went upstairs and went to bed. I was there while I had the DT.

So in about three days, I was all in the clear. But the more sober I got, the more awful the despair, the depression. So I think it was morning of the third and fourth day that my friend Abby showed up in the doorway. And my feeling was ambivalent at once. So I said, well, this is the time to go call on the evangelist. And on the other hand, I was thinking, well, he took me looking for a job. Why is he up here at 11 o'clock in the morning to see me?

He does find things quite interesting. So Abby knew my prejudices. So he waited for me to ask him again for that neat little formula through which he had achieved relief. And with me, he went through and got on to himself with another person in confidence who made rectification in all fathers. And he praised the Father. He understood it. I think he might have even used that phrase. And without much more to do, he was gone.

No question. And again, I couldn't have touched the gospel. And again, the prayer grew fast. Until the last sentence Christ will often speak, momentarily, was apparently crushed down. And then, like a child crying out in exasperation, I said, if there is a Father, if there is a God, will He show himself? And the place lit up in a great glare of wondrous white light. And then I began to have images in the mind's eye, so to speak.

And one came in which I seemed to see myself standing on a mountain. And a great clean wind was blowing. And this blowing, at first, went around. And then it seemed to go through. And then the ecstasy redoubled. And I found myself exclaiming, I am free man. So this is the God of the churches. And little by little, the ecstasy subsided. And I found myself in a new world of consciousness. And one of the oldest reflections in this world, as you see, is still over me.

Why, for all is well with God. I am a part of His cosmos at play. Even evil, we may say, can be transmitted into good. So I have been betrothed as such. By a philosophical. Who used the scientific verdicts to betray me.

[00:55:00]

Who used His ability to communicate to me through our kinship of common preference. And who made the attempt of oppression and crisis for this church. So then, to me, here in me, lies the source. Here lies the point. And God knows the life of this church. Now, I venture this assertion is confident of any error. As a spiritual awakening, I would say, I am exactly the same. Certainly it is not for me to differ with theologians.

But let me say, I prefer to think that there is no essential difference between what happened to me and what happens. To each sound I add, excepting the time element. Going back to those psychiatrists who said we can't understand this tremendous shift in motivation despite all your research. Well, in my case, the shift. But the proofs have been the same. And one of the most terrible compulsions and obsessions known has been expelled from us.

Almost wholesale. And through this epicenter of medicine, religion, and our own experience in suffering in the public, and sharing the grace of this, one will be next. I self-apologize my speech. I know there will be some questions, John. So if you have any finally show me how you got the chance. Well, you have enough light. Well, thank you. Thank you, John. You made it. I appreciate it. And every one of us has, John, given experience with ecstasy, and light shining in our eyes.

Okay. Maybe, you know, this is a touchstone thing. But here's how I look at it. You go to AA meetings. And somebody gets up. And this happens time after time. And he says, now, folks, I ain't got the spiritual angle yet. I'm making the deep my higher power. They're trouble, and I'm what? So I got a higher power. But I ain't got the spiritual angle the way you told it. Well, he looked sane in other respects, but, you know.

Now, this guy will get up there and tell a story of losing this compulsion. And it's being carried out of him. And it's being remotivated in many other ways. Just like Joseph Diver said, it's been a matter of months or six months or a year. Now, just take one of those fellows and try to imagine all of those shifts in motivation taking place within six months or within six minutes instead of six months.

I think as this happens to that fellow, he too will have had ecstasy. So I think it's a time element. I personally see no great advantage in these tremendous experiences, save in my case only one, that did give me an instant conviction of the presence of God, which has never left me from that moment. In spite of the worst I can go, and it's often been damned bad. And no matter what pressure.

[01:00:00]

And I feel that that extra good of him may have made the difference whether I was at the circus with AA in the early years or not. Actually it makes some liabilities, and I've seen it in others who have had these experiences in LA and I've taught a lot. And this is a tendency, and I think you feel I'll give us some excuse for it too, of beginning to think that because we have these tremendous illuminations that we are something special.

So you begin to develop a kind of a paranoia alongside of a part of the imbalance in strength and this is just what happens to me. I damn near botched up the whole one by coming out of it, working seriously with guns, and before anybody had been sobered up, I got so far off base as to loudly declare one time to an audience by no means fell down, that I was going to sober up all the goddamn drunks in the world.

Now that is still paranoia if you will. So, don't long for the illumination. I think you have to have the experiences appropriate. I'm not lying to you. Well, some people do, you know. Oh my God, if I only had one line to go. Now, actually, this may be said very sincerely because this may be a guy slipping around. But it may be slipping around on account of the fact that he's a little sticky and needs some of them vitamin B3, so now look where I'm hopping.