0:00
Source
Roger W - Clarence Snyder Wartime Letters - 2026-10-13.mp3 File: roger-w-clarence-snyder-wartime-letters-2026-10-13.mp3 Duration: 01:02:42
0:06
Unknown
============================================================
0:06
Moderator
Welcome everyone, and thanks for joining us for the Tuesday night Recovery Speakers History meeting. I'm Tim, and tonight's presentation is on Clarence Snyder and the Wartime Letters, Reflections of the Person, and Cleveland AA in the 1940s, presented by Roger W. And this is a great presentation that I'm really looking forward to hearing again. We meet every Tuesday at the same time and at the same Zoom ID, and we explore the people, events, books, recordings, and stories that shaped AA and the 12-step fellowships.
0:41
Unknown
And next week, we are going to have Jim W. back for a presentation on Ebby T., and I'll be sharing all this information in the chat if anyone wants to save flyers. And tonight's meeting is being recorded and will be preserved at RecoverySpeakers.org, along with our growing archive of recovery history and thousands of historic recordings. Recovery Speakers is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit dedicated to preserving and sharing this history.
1:10
Moderator
We are independent and not affiliated with AA or any other 12-step organization. If you would like to receive our emails or support the archive, I will be sharing in the chat the subscription and donation links. And at the end of tonight's presentation, we'll have some time for Q and A. And I am going to close the chat during the presentation and open it back up at the end. And before I turn it over to Roger, I did want to just show a couple features that I mentioned if you were on, I think, last week or two weeks ago. There were some new features on the RecoverySpeakers.org platform, and it is a lot cleaner now.
1:57
Unknown
So I'm sharing my screen, and I am currently in my account. And you can see you can have my library, research, you can save playlists. Here's the flyer for tonight's meeting. And you will have, soon we got to get the other flyers of upcoming presentations uploaded, and all kinds of cool features on here. We are now available on Spotify, if that's your preferred platform. You can find us on Spotify, and there's a lot of cool features, and it's clean now and looks great.
2:34
Moderator
You can use the Ask the Archive and deep research, and there's a lot of cool functionality now in my account, and you can save all the stuff that you're looking at. And I hope you all enjoy and take some time to play around with the site and see all the cool stuff that's available on there, and also listen to the audio. That is just some incredible recordings on there, and I know in my recovery, I'm grateful for having all of the audio to listen to, and I've been fortunate to be surrounded by it. So I hope you all take the time to check it out.
3:19
Moderator
And now that is it for me. I am going to ask Roger to unmute, and you can take it away for a presentation on Clarence Snyder. Thank you, Tim, and thanks for that look at the site again. I love what you guys are doing. It's fantastic, and I got to spend some more time in there. But thank you for this opportunity. Is the slide up? We see it? Okay, fantastic. My name is Roger. I'm a grateful alcoholic. And if you've heard my military, AA in the military presentation, A New Pair of Goggles, that was sort of the start.
4:00
Unknown
That was the first one given in the National Archives work, I think in 2015. But this is sort of a deep dive into one character who served during World War II from that presentation. And so I had an opportunity to go to Brown University, where Clarence Mitchell K., thanks to Mitchell, after he wrote the book How It Worked, and all of Clarence's papers and documents and artifacts are there at Brown University available.
4:29
Moderator
So I applied as a private researcher and took the time to look only at the
4:36
Moderator
box that it contained things from around World War II, from 1940 to '45 era. So that's what we're going to be looking at. I'm excited to share this with you. It was terrific. This cover here is a postcard that Clarence got that was in the collection from Private Glen Wadick, who was an AA member from Cleveland, who was at that time serving at Fort Leonard Wood, Missouri. And he wrote, Hi, Schmitz, which seems to be his nickname.
5:08
Unknown
Letter received. Thanks. May the best be yours and may I never forget. Hello to Selma. Try to keep in touch and let me know when and if you go into service. Glenn. Here's a slide that just shows you that most of everything, all these letters came from Brown University, but I did use some of these other resources and references throughout. Now, Clarence had his last drink in February the 11th, 1938.
5:36
Moderator
It's a sober date. And so after he was sent to Akron, the young feller pictured here would return to Cleveland. He found his first prospect eventually, and he got started with intensive work with other alcoholics. Ultimately, Cleveland AA grew very rapidly, probably faster than Akron and New York for a time. And the methods that Clarence and the other early members worked out seemed to work incredibly well. The letters and some of the other material in the collection paint a really interesting picture of Clarence, the person, that might or might not fit your current understanding or perception.
6:15
Unknown
We'll see at the end. I learned a whole lot about Clarence, the person, the people that wrote the letters, and a lot about Cleveland AA in the 1940s. So it's just my pleasure to share all that with you. As an early member, Clarence attended the Rockefeller dinner in 1940. Here's the menu that he kept that was in the collection. This is the dinner where Bill just was convinced that all the attendees were going to just donate millions to Alcoholics Anonymous.
6:49
Unknown
So Clarence traveled by train with Dr. Bob to New York. The train ticket cost $3.95. And based on some comments that are recorded in How It Worked, Clarence was embarrassed that a bunch of bums were brought in to panhandle money from the rich dinner guests. So that friction we're going to see a little bit later on. But the friction between Clarence and Bill, usually regarded the direction of the movement, money, and whether or not it was an altruistic movement or not, and whether or not it needed a lot of money. So that's usually the friction there.
7:28
Moderator
So before we get into the wartime, for sure, I just found this too interesting not to put in here, right? It's a letter from Ruth Hock, our first secretary at the headquarters, the typist for the Big Book at Honor Dealers with Bill and Hank, and it's on Works Publishing letterhead. It's to Clarence, and it was forwarding a request from a prospect that was asking for Rollie Hemsley to be sent to help him right away.
7:59
Unknown
So Ruth sent it to Clarence, a telegram, asking for a 12-step call. So the letter to Ruth Hock followed Rollie Hemsley. You know, Raleigh was a baseball player, and he publicly announced his sobriety and membership in Alcoholics Anonymous before the traditions, and it really surged membership. So there's a little friction there about whether it was a good thing. You know, eventually we decided that hanging our reputation on one celebrity was too risky, and the traditions 11 and 12 came about.
8:31
Unknown
But I thought it was just an interesting letter from Ruth to Clarence. And then here's a handwritten card that seems to be an early draft of what would later be the sponsorship pamphlet that Cleveland produced in 1941 or '44. But this box that this was in was like the 1940 to '42 era, whether it was mislabeled or in the wrong place or not, it seems to be an early draft, right? So it says proper sponsorship is one of the most important factors in determining the measure of success that may be expected of the prospect.
9:08
Unknown
When we're called upon to sponsor, it would be well to consider the responsibilities connected with such a duty. In the first place, we should realize that we're
9:21
Unknown
about to play a very vital part in his general welfare, his health, sanity, future, and yes, his soul. Now, I thought this was too interesting not to put in there too. Frank Westfall wrote a letter to Clarence about the draft pamphlet, which is candid opinion. He praised most of the pamphlet as written, the draft, and it was to the point. He liked it, but he wanted to add very specific directions for slippers. He went on to say this, and here's what I like: most trouble in AA is because of poor sponsorship.
9:58
Unknown
Now, you got to imagine that the concept, the term sponsorship, was not in the Big Book in 1939. In the Akron manuals, 1940, '41, the term sponsorship was obviously—there was parts to the sponsor. So this is a new concept. It's no more than a few years old, and already there's an AA member telling us that what's wrong with AA is poor sponsorship. This brand new concept. So I just thought, you know, complaints about poor sponsorship are not new. You can go all the way back.
10:33
Unknown
And he insisted that not only that, we got to put this instruction into literature because if we codify it in literature, all the sponsors will suddenly get better. So that's not a new idea either, that if you get it in, approve it in literature, it's going to change things. And here's a mimeographed copy of the AA sponsorship. It's obligations and it's responsibility. And it matches, the words match the pamphlet produced later with one notable change.
11:07
Unknown
Obligations was changed to opportunities. So Cleveland AA owes a whole lot to the idea of sponsorship, basically. And then he also preserved the motion that created the Cuyahoga County AA committee, made up of two representatives from every group in the county. They had no authority to bind the groups without proposing ideas to the committee. And the motion carried with C. H. Snyder being the first chairman.
11:33
Unknown
So the committee decided and they asked that the mail from the headquarters be sent to a post office box. And so Clarence wrote Bill right after that, and he was seeking some support. A little evidence. He did not like letting go and letting the groups, I guess. He wrote about the movement, to oust Clarence, and appoint Bill H. as the chairperson, and some underlying political movement in the AA groups were not getting along.
12:02
Unknown
And he was appealing to Bill and objecting about— In promising to help the foundation financially, if Bill came in on his side, he could make that happen for him. And Bill replied to Clarence, and he told him how terrible it was, but it was a local matter. He assured Clarence that the trustees had concluded long ago that they would never interfere with the local affairs. He addressed the issue of the correspondence going to central office, post office box, and he said the question of local authorities a matter for the groups to decide.
12:38
Unknown
But when it came down to the question of who's going to exercise authority in Cleveland, that had to be for the Cleveland group to decide. Bill told him that he had already talked to Bert T. by phone and that it was the group conscience that they went in the P.O. box, and that's what they were going to do. And Bill told him, and I love this part, he was sending Doc Smith a copy of this letter because, as you know, he's one of the trustees, and he has the advantage of being on the ground. It might be a good idea to have a heart-to-heart chat with him before you undertake to show by petition or otherwise that the committee's in the wrong. So I thought that was great.
13:32
Unknown
That's like a 1941 version of call your sponsor. So, and then Bill closed, urging unity and, you know, explaining that above all, let us remember those thousands that are still sick and realize that our dissension among us might mean the death of some of them. So he asked for unity. And then here's another interesting, before we're getting, we're almost to World War II, but the September 1941 minutes of the hospital committee outlined the procedures for admitting patients to the hospital and included who's going to pay the bill, the rules for visitors.
14:11
Unknown
So in 1941, Cleveland AA, the committee's telling— 1941, Cleveland AA, the committee is telling the hospitals what to do.
14:18
Unknown
We're directing their outfit. So AA directed the hospitals to create a case history, maintain official AA patient visitation records, and that nobody except AA members can visit a patient except in extreme emergencies and only at the discretion of the sponsor. They instruct the hospitals that the patient will not be given their street clothes until the last day, and that the person in charge is going to have to inspect all their packages.
14:47
Unknown
And then minutes of that committee from February 1942 show that they created a list of approved hospitals that they approved of that obeyed the rules of the committee. I thought that was just hilarious. And also it was reported that the emergency clinic did not follow the AA rules, that they didn't take patients' clothes away, and they appointed a three-person committee to go investigate and report back whether or not they were breaking the AA rules.
15:18
Moderator
Then the Cuyahoga County Central Committee held an appreciation dinner for Dr. Bob at the Lakeshore Hotel, and you could get a ticket for a dollar thirty-five. Then on December 7th, 1941, of course, the context changes completely. AA members are going into uniform. Here's where we start. Families are being separated. Correspondence becomes one of the ways that the fellowship stays connected. And so what was the size of Cleveland AA at this time?
15:46
Unknown
Let's ask the recording statistician of the Central Committee, Norman Ebert. So I used to say, when people would spout off statistics of success rates and so forth, to go ask your group statistician. And I said it tongue in cheek, but apparently there was somebody that self-appointed themselves this unique service position. So the number of groups in Cleveland jumped from 15 to 23 in this nine-month period right here.
16:13
Moderator
Membership increased from 745 to 1,059, and weekly attendance went up as well. And at first they tracked wives, and then it's blank. So I don't know if they just stopped counting or what that's about. So in the summer of 1942, Clarence decides it's time to join the Army, and he applied for volunteer officer candidate training. The war is six months old. The demand for able men is really high. He was not a young recruit. He was 40 years old.
16:46
Moderator
He was established in Cleveland. He was already an active member of Alcoholics Anonymous, but he chose to go, which is sort of a reflection on the greatest generation. Selective Service notified. It says, Your applicant for volunteer officer candidate training has been approved by the local board, and he shipped out to Fort Knox a few months later. That's the kind of tank that was being operated at Fort Knox at the time.
17:15
Unknown
He kept in touch with members in Cleveland, and he wrote to his friends and family often. So that's what this whole presentation is about, is excerpts of the letters from members in the military service, family, Clarence sharing about Army life. He said, The going is tough, but I don't hear anyone holler and uncle. My only regret is that I'm not 15 or 20 years younger, but I feel I can offset it by applying some other advantages I may have.
17:47
Unknown
I received a copy of the first edition of the newspaper, and I enjoyed it very much, and I'm hoping the best for its success. I'll anticipate receiving it each month. So here's the postcard at the beginning was from Glen Wadick. Here he wrote another letter. I'm glad and I'm proud to hear that you've enlisted. I know that you'll give a good account of yourself, Smitz, old boy. I'm proud of you, proud to call you a friend.
18:24
Moderator
Things are okay for me. Was appointed corporal the 29th day of last month and sergeant the 20th of this month. I've been accepted for Officer Candidate School for the infantry, and I'm awaiting orders to report to Fort Benning, Georgia, for schooling probably sometime next month. I hope. Well, Smitz, I wish you the best of luck and stay in touch. So that's the kind of friendly language that you see back and forth all throughout these letters. There's one local member and a friend of Clarence was Gus, Clayton Bull. He wrote Clarence often, and this letter is four handwritten pages. He also said that if he enlisted two years ago, he would either be dead or in the guardhouse. He wrote much about his efforts to apply for officer training like Clarence. He wrote about training for quartermaster and plans to go to Camp Lee, Virginia.
19:23
Unknown
He was at Fort Warren in Cheyenne, Wyoming. During World War II, that was a massive quartermaster training center. So Clayton called it a nice fort in the foothills of the Rocky Mountains. The air is thin, 6,300 feet above sea level. Beer drinkers are warned to cut usual quantities in half, as they find themselves half lightheaded to start. He said, Too bad we didn't know that years ago. I recommend we send all slippers out here to hasten the dive.
19:54
Unknown
Then in September 1942, we hear from Glen Wadick again. He wrote, Just a note to let you know that I'm okay. I'm due to report to Fort Benning, Georgia for infantry training. He also asked Clarence to give my regards to all the fellow AAs. I think of you often, and I hope to see you again someday. And he closed with a shared experience and some advice to work like hell. Now in September 1942, he got this card from AA members in Cleveland to my friend in the service, and it was signed by Ed Kinsley, Dud Hawkins, Walt Burleston, Bill Haffer, Mr. Dave Thobold, Hank Heller, Edward Hughes, Bob Robertson, Harry Smith, C. W. Whitewell, Irwin Myerson, and John Coolidge.
20:42
Moderator
So I'd love to know more about a lot of those guys. Walt B. was among early members, and Smitty, Dr. Bob's son, recalled him being one of the people in Dr. Bob and the Good Oldtimers. He remembered him coming over to the house for coffee and fellowship after the meeting at T. Henry's. And then Irwin Myerson has a bit in Dr. Bob and the Good Oldtimers. He said, That says one of the most famous early adherents of our Cleveland was Irwin M., who sold Venetian blinds to department stores in the Deep South. Irwin weighed 250 pounds and had energy and gusto.
21:23
Unknown
Bill Wilson wrote, noting that the prospect of Irwin as a missionary scared us rather badly. Still, in his territory, there was a long list of prospects, which was reluctantly given to him, even though he had broken all the rules of caution and discreet approach to newcomers. He ran each and every one of them down, working day and night. In addition, he wrote them letters, and he got them writing to each other.
21:52
Moderator
He had cracked the territory wide open, wrote Bill, and it started or stimulated many an original group. So he's one of the guys that wrote to Clarence in this card. And then this is the Central Bulletin, Volume 1, Number 1. This is a newsletter began nearly two years before the Grapevine. The first one, October 1942, included a plea to group secretaries to compile a mailing list of all the men in service. They sent copies to all the known service members free.
22:23
Unknown
They note the annual dinner where Dr. Bob spoke in 1941 is going to have Bill Wilson speak in 1942. And Clarence is going to be away at the Army training, but he's going to hear about it. He's going to be very interested to hear more about it and ask about it in several letters. So the first issue, of course, asked the group secretaries for names. So the second Central Bulletin reported on the farewell party and a dance, an AA dance.
22:56
Unknown
Can you imagine? Held in honor of Clarence Snyder before he left for Army training at Fort Knox. He was presented with a wristwatch by the West Side groups for his pioneer work in Cleveland, and off he went. Here's an Army pay stub that he saved. He got $21.15 in 1942. So the average annual income was about $1,900. A brand new recruit made $50 a month, or $600 a year plus housing and food. So I don't know, maybe it was a partial pay.
23:28
Unknown
I really don't know. There's no deductions why it wasn't a full pay, but he saved that one. In November, while he's at Fort Knox, he got this letter from the National Secretary, Margaret Bobby Berger, from the Alcoholic Foundation headquarters. Now I saw Gary on here today, so I'd love to see him. So Bobby was instrumental in AA history. I highly recommend Gary's book about her life. She practically sponsored, I would say, all the service members serving in World War II, at least by mail. She was certainly their mail contact.
24:08
Unknown
And this letter is really indicative of all the work that she was doing in that realm and so many others. So she tells them that there's the group in Cleveland gave them his name and service file for the service file at the office, and that they're making special efforts to connect others.
24:30
Unknown
So she was passing along another name of an AA member that was at Camp Knox also, so that Clarence would have somebody to contact that's also in AA. So these letters just keep telling the story of the people, early fellowship and family. Here's a four-page letter signed by Nell and Tom in November 1942. They were glad to hear from Clarence. They told him about the Halloween party by the groups on the west side. The fellowship and family were a big part of early AA.
25:04
Moderator
There were AA dances, as you can see. They spent a lot of time together celebrating sobriety and working with others. So the letter they shared that they had started a women's group, but then they clarified that that's of the men's wives, so it was a precursor to Al-Anon. They shared about a common friend, Doc Presley, in Webster's Hospital, Ben Durko's off again. The new secretary of the morning group is Jack Kellogg.
25:36
Moderator
They told Clarence they'd miss him at meetings because he put something educational and kept bad ideas out. And they closed asking him to give them a call if he's ever home on furlough. On October the 20th, 1942, Clarence was contacted at his Fort Knox address by the Louisville group. This is the only group here in the state of Kentucky at the time, by the secretary, Mildred, inviting him to the group meeting and a Halloween party.
26:07
Unknown
Interesting how dances and parties are big AA things in the 1940s. There was a second letter from the Louisville group that said they were sorry he couldn't make it and invited him to speak at an open meeting on Friday, November the 6th. And from later letters in the Central Bulletin, we'll see in a minute, we do know that he did attend that group at least once and that they brought a prospect down to Fort Knox for him to work on.
26:40
Moderator
Here's a January '43 letter from Mary Dickman that talks about a prospect that he met. That's the prospect that he worked on with a guy named Bob, who did not stay sober, and despite the time and effort Clarence gave him, they offered him to stay in their home in Louisville with his wife if they ever wanted to visit. And then another letter in January from Miss Jean Russell in Louisville about an article in a magazine section of the Courier-Journal.
27:13
Unknown
And a prospect that they were working on. She said she wasn't impressed by the article. She liked some of the literature that she'd seen from Cleveland a lot better and thought that they should send more literature to help this guy. Here is the article that she was referencing. It was an early '43 article in the Louisville Courier Journal. It's a big part of our story here in Kentucky, ex-drunks liquidate Louisville drunks.
27:43
Moderator
It was an early press piece that helped the only group that we had at the time grow and expand membership and help people. It's clear Clarence never really stopped working with drunks during training or otherwise. He got a seven-page handwritten letter from Louise Cotton. She wrote about her son John, who Clarence had 12-stepped, drinking, military discipline, family crisis, and hoping that he could get sober again.
28:10
Unknown
For the mom of an alcoholic, the situation serious, Lois shares the details of his AWOL at a nearby hotel, blames his wife for dragging him back into drinking, and she was glad that he couldn't get access to liquor while he was in the brig, and that he made a solemn oath that he would never do it again. Then she held out hope that the work with John did with Clarence would not be in vain, and as the mother of an alcoholic, she was struggling to understand the malady, and how was it possible that he was explaining AA to the chaplain one day and drunk in AWOL the next?
28:54
Unknown
It just didn't make sense to her. And then there was mail from family and friends. Reverend Theodore Kitterer was Clarence's brother-in-law. His second wife, maiden name Selma Gertrude Kitterer, was close to her brother. So Reverend Kitterer wrote several long letters describing life back in Cleveland, church life, family, military service, chaplaincy, alcoholism, and a bunch of other topics. Clarence apparently sent him some tracts about the evils of drinking and that were distributed at Fort Knox, and Reverend Kitterer saw little good in telling somebody not to drink, and he thought that they were And telling somebody not to drink, and he thought that they were either going to drink themselves to death or find some site like the AAs that could help conquer liquor.
29:43
Unknown
That is the tracts that he was referencing in that letter. And then Reverend Kinneder shared about a family supper, including Selma. They had ham because turkey was 55 cents a pound, for goodness sake, so they could only afford ham. I don't know how much it was, but he shared that his son John is going to leave November 17th for the Army and hoped he would do well. And then in closing, he asked Clarence to share about Army life and particularly about the duties and doings of the Protestant chaplains in the camp that he was interested in.
30:21
Unknown
Then there's a letter here from John G. He opened it Dear Snatch, which maybe is another nickname from his Army buddies. He talked about leaving Fort Knox for Louisiana, and he shared about Louisiana driving tanks, KP duty. He compared the excellent food with the bad food at Fort Knox. He liked the nice new barracks, but he shared about the bugs that also liked them. And then in closing, he says, I'll cut the BS and say so long.
30:53
Unknown
The lights is keeping the bugs awake. And then Charlie Sanders wrote in November about a local AA stuff and a new secretary. He praised Clarence for making the grade and proving his caliber. He praised Clarence's AA service for his courage and good works. He shared with Clarence about a new group called the Parma Brooklyn Group. Apparently, it was a resentment and coffee pot spinoff of the Brooklyn Group.
31:21
Moderator
He reported that he doubts Al can put this new group over. He's been indiscreet in criticizing other members. So he attended the Bill W. testimonial dinner, he called it, at Hotel Carter, and he reported about 700 people attended. So that's pretty good numbers. The letter referenced a news clipping from Cleveland Press by Dr. Dilworth Lupton praising Clarence and his work in Cleveland. You might be familiar with this little pamphlet.
31:50
Unknown
So Reverend Lupton was the pastor of the First Unitarian Church. When he first was approached about AA by Dorothy, Clarence's first wife, he was skeptical, and he said, Nothing good could come out of the Oxford Group, and he wanted no part of it. But once Cleveland broke from Akron, started the Alcoholics Anonymous group, he was willing to read the book, and he met with Clarence. And after a few meetings and interviewing some members, he preached a sermon called Mr.
32:22
Moderator
X and Alcoholics Anonymous. Mr. X was Clarence. And then the church later published this talk as this pamphlet here, and he became a friend of AA. So now we get to one of my favorite letters in the collection. It's a wartime love letter from Selma to Clarence. This is the two of them here. And so this is Selma writing to Clarence while he's away doing Army training. She opened it, Darling, and signed Forever, Selma, and I love you was on the back page. She wrote it in pencil due to not having a pen at lunch next door to where she worked, and she tells him about the Build W dinner.
33:07
Unknown
She shared the dinner in detail that 750 attended. Jack Darrow read Clarence's letter that he had written. Bill Wilson gave a wonderful talk and praised Clarence for the AA setup in Cleveland. She promised to get a copy of the prayer that he closed with, and Dr. and Mrs. Smith sent their regards. Mr. Kennedy from West Virginia was master of ceremonies. Henrietta was not there. She sat with the Meyersons, the Hellums, and a new couple.
33:36
She shared the menu
the fruit cocktail, turkey dinner, ice cream, and coffee. Following the afternoon meeting, she went to the church that evening for a candlelight service and dedicated an honor roll for 49 boys in service with a candle for each one. And then she shared details of life and this wartime love letter. She shared about church and missing Clarence. The tone was very loving, and it was really clear that Selma missed Clarence.
34:05
Unknown
It demonstrated why soldier mail is such a great morale boost. I was busy from morning until night yesterday, but still I missed you, wished you could have been with me. She wrote, My lunch hour is almost over now. If I think of more things, I will write again tonight. And then she reclosed, recalling her day and loneliness, and then signed it with, My love
34:30
Moderator
now and forever, Selma. So the Cleveland Central Bulletin is such a great source of history in Cleveland AA. It kept the troops connected, and it was just a big part of early Cleveland AA. Harry Danksworth sent a letter in November of 1942 that accompanied the second issue of the Central Bulletin. The letter was on the Dankworth Company printers' letterhead, so he might have used his personal printing business, I assume, to publish and possibly donate both time and material to the Central Bulletin.
35:03
Unknown
He called this edition a dandy setup, and he praised the editorial on the Wilson talk as a masterpiece. There's the letter. About Bill Wilson's talk at the dinner, he called it a master class, and then he said, It certainly was too bad that a meeting was held immediately after the grand talk to quiz him on the finance skullduggery he was purported to have engaged in. So Harry felt like this was embarrassing for Cleveland, and he suggested that there was another article in the bulletin on gossip, and the perpetrator might find that and maybe make amends.
35:42
Unknown
Some believe Clarence was presented and led the confrontation of Bill Wilson that this talks about, but we got a primary source here showing he has an alibi that day. He was at Army training at Fort Knox, so he might have expressed an opinion. He might have stirred the pot, but he was not there. Most letters are from someone else to Clarence that he saved, but there are some letters that Clarence wrote to his ex-wife Dorothy and his son Charlie that give us a remarkable exception and gives us a glimpse of Clarence's words directly.
36:20
Unknown
Dorothy was instrumental in Clarence getting help from Dr. Bob in Akron. She was as much of an AA pioneer as the other early wives. Friendly with early members, and she happened to be present with Ruth Hock, Bill Wilson, and Hank Parkhurst when the final edits to the manuscript were made for the Cornwall Press. So Clarence had divorced Dorothy in August of 1940, a few years before he left for Army training. They had a child together, and based on their letters, they had a close friendship after the divorce.
36:54
Unknown
Clarence remained grateful for Dorothy saving his life and leading him into sobriety. And Clarence thanked Dorothy for a letter and one from his son Charles enclosed, and then shared about going to the USO and a movie for a break from training. And that's a picture of him at that USO. If you're familiar with Elizabethtown, Kentucky, it's right between where the Pritchard Center is and the police department. It was where the USO was.
37:25
Moderator
It's the photo taken during that time. And then Clarence shared about the good lunch in Elizabethtown, the poorly cooked grub at camp. He complained about Army life and getting up at 4 a.m. Friday and early foot march. We get a glimpse of what he was doing, 18 hours guard detail, and then the general lack of sleep. Of officer training, he confessed he may not pass the board at his age, but at least I'll have the satisfaction of knowing I've given it everything I have, and I'm further satisfied if that in the most of the requirements, I am okay.
38:06
Moderator
So in addition to his regular training, he's got all this extra officer training he's got to do. He talked about hopes for leave during the holidays and the challenge of making plans, not knowing if he could leave or not. And he assured Charlie, his son, he would see him if he does get leave. And he asked about Charlie being in Cleveland for Thanksgiving and Christmas, and he emphasized if he does get time off, it's going to be short notice.
38:40
Unknown
And then showing his sense of humor, he said, I'm enclosing a couple of pictures in case you have rats in the basement or bats in the attic. They might be of some. Before he closed the letter, and despite hearing about the Bill Wilson dinner from a bunch of sources, he asked Dorothy to tell him about the Bill Wilson dinner from her perspective. He claims that he didn't have much news on the party, and then he goes on to tell her everything he knows. He says he asked for details, and then he goes on to share that he does know that they had 4:50 for dinner and another 300 afterwards. They had a nice dinner, but I'd like to know about who talked and what was said. And then we get to the root of what he really wants to know.
39:36
Unknown
He specifically says, How did they ever pick out Lynn Kennedy for MC with so many fellows around who have really been on the beam so long?
39:46
Moderator
And what finally happened, referenced the matter of Bill and Doc's remuneration from the foundation. He had obvious interest, and he trusted Dorothy to share that with him. So the wartime letters continue to reveal the fellowship. Here's a letter from Irwin Myerson, the Venetian blind salesman, that, out there growing AA from the hotel in South Bend, Indiana, wishing Clarence Godspeed and thanking him for his untiring work. And this is a softer side of Clarence that you might not have seen before.
40:19
Moderator
It was a pleasant surprise to me. Apparently through a beautiful correspondence exchange between Clarence and the teenage daughter of an AA member. That, along with a whole lot of other youth during World War II, wrote friends and family and had a pen pal. She exchanged letters with Clarence, obviously several times. There's some replies. So Ruthie Karan decided to write Clarence as a patriotic exercise. Her father was sober and was present at the farewell that they had, the farewell dinner and dance. And Ruthie got the address that was written in a pamphlet that her dad had. Clarence, taking time to write with a family member, paints a different picture of him, and then the abrasive personality reputation that you might be familiar with.
41:08
Unknown
So we have Ruthie's letter to Clarence, and yeah, based on the second letter, it seems like a warm and kind reply. She wrote, My father says he remembers seeing you the night you said goodbye to the group. My name is Ruthie Karan. I'm 13 years of age, and I'm in the seventh grade at Holy Trinity School. After filling up the page with a bunch of facts that a 13-year-old would write, she said, Aw shucks, I can't think of anything to write, so I'll close this little note for now. Then Clarence obviously replied, including a picture, because on December 6th, Ruthie sent another letter and she wrote, Dear Clarence, I received your letter and enjoyed reading it. I decided to answer it right away.
42:00
Unknown
I'm sorry I don't have a photograph of myself, as it is snowing and I don't have a camera. That's 13-year-old logic. I got your picture. I want to thank you very much. She shared that she read an article about Fort Knox and the family circle, and she closed with best wishes. You could just see the innocence of youth in the letters and the desire to be patriotic and write a soldier. And incidentally, this is the easiest cursive letter I ever translated in the whole collection, was a 13-year-old with good penmanship.
42:39
Unknown
The adults, not so much. So Ralph Bunkholder announced by letter that he had a year sober on the 13th of November, and he said Clarence played a big part in finding AA, and that he told the story. Clarence had spoke at a Rotary Club about AA, and Ralph's brother heard it, told their mother, who told Ralph, and there's a place you can go to get some help. So after getting these letters, he carried them around for a week or so, but he couldn't get up the nerve to call Clarence's phone number.
43:18
Unknown
But after some anguish and a few more bouts with alcohol, he called him, and then Clarence turned him over to Bill Haffer, Mr., and Bill did the job and picked me up out of the gutter, he says. So he shared local AA news with Clarence that he was active in the hospitals. He led his first meeting at the Crawford Group. He shared about Clarence's letter being read at the Bill W. dinner, and that Glen Wadick was going to get into the action soon, and then he shared about a bunch of local Cleveland AAs.
43:56
Unknown
Here's a program of the menu from the Christmas dinner that winter in 1942 that Clarence would have had at Fort Knox, traditional turkey dinner. Note that it includes cigars and cigarettes at the bottom after coffee, part of the menu. And then the inside of the program was the trainees on the right, C. Snyder's in the third platoon. And then this is a good one. Clarence saved this letter from the Parkhurst.
44:25
Unknown
Yep, that's Hank Parkhurst and his second wife, Carolyn Wright, who was Dorothy Snyder's sister. Hank drank again, divorced his first wife, and that's a different story. But this Christmas card casted some serious 1940 shade at Clarence. He wrote, Merry Christmas, Clarence. Isn't it the height of something or other to have to send your card to the address business at that of your ex-wife? But I do not have your address, even though I did read a— I do not have your address, even though I did read a darn nice letter you wrote. So the height of something or other is like a passive-aggressive dig widely used back
45:09
Moderator
then to describe extreme behavior. It lets Clarence draw his own conclusion about the height of what. And he also points out that, like, you didn't write me, but I read a letter that you wrote. And then he closes with a nonchalant, Sure would like to see you on leave, but anyway, have a nice time. It sounded a little sarcastic to me, but at least he was still on the Parkhursts' Christmas card list. After Christmas, Clarence remained at Fort Knox. He sent this letter to Dorothy and Charlie.
45:44
Unknown
There was so much good information about Clarence's experience in this eight-page letter, it's hard to distill down. But he talked about tanks. He shared some humorous stories about them, reporting that they're the coldest thing in the world in the winter and the hottest in the summer, and the inside arrangement was designed for anything but comfort. He shared about an accident crushing a car and leaving it flatter and thinner than a rooming house rug.
46:16
Unknown
He claimed all the talk about shooting was for Charlie's benefit, and he shared about the grub getting worse and field rations and his desire for holiday leave. He wanted a good home for Christmas, but it was impossible. He moved on to talk about his uncertain Army future. He was offered maybe he'll stay at Fort Knox, maybe he'll be a platoon sergeant, maybe he'll go to officer training later. He seemed concerned about all the physical demands, and then he wrote that, of course, Selma, my brother, and most everyone else are of the opinion that I should drop the whole idea and come home.
46:59
Unknown
As a VOC being 40, there's much element of reason in that also. And then he closed it with, Thank you much for your Christmas letter, and thanks a lot to you, Charlie, for your card and note. And so Charlie was enrolled in a military academy. He sent a picture. He was going to a military academy out of state, and Clarence told him that he looked the part more of soldiers than some of the people around Fort Knox. So by March of '43, he had been discharged, returned to civilian life. He started doing AA work.
47:37
Unknown
He was classified 1A in the draft. He remained available, but by age he was never actually called up. Could have got that bad, but it didn't. So in March of 1943, he comes back to AA life, and this is the first thing that I see in the files. Some people on this call may be familiar with this, but the Alcoholic Foundation sent a letter to all the groups signed by Dr. Leonard Strong as the secretary.
48:07
Unknown
That's Bill's brother-in-law. It asked all the groups to complete a survey and include information about distribution of income from the book, the Alcoholic Foundation, the central office. They asked the groups or local committees to carefully consider these questions and return two copies, care of Margaret Berger at the central office. The trustees have always taken the position that they are but a service committee acting for the national welfare of Alcoholics Anonymous. Hence, an assurance from the groups, such as the questionnaire, would be highly appreciated.
48:42
Unknown
Now here's the one in Clarence's, in the folders of his collection. This is Clarence's handwriting, clearly from the other cursive letters that he wrote, the noes and all of the answers. So what were the questions? You probably can't read them on the screen, but it says, Does your group believe that the AA Central Office in New York is an effective and necessary part of our national program? Does your group believe that the Central Office should continue to be supported by voluntary contributions from the groups?
49:18
Unknown
Does your group believe that any publicity literature or project intended to have a national circulation or effect should be first submitted to our Central Office or trustees of the Foundation? And then in answering the next question, there were some appendices about book sales and the debt to the Rockefellers and so forth. And it says, Does your group believe, inasmuch as Bill Wilson and Bob Smith cannot fully maintain their present activity out of their own means, that the trustees should continue to procure them income from sources outside the groups?
49:53
Unknown
And then before answering the next question, there's another appendix, and it says, Does your group approve the manner in which the trustees have divided the income of the book Alcoholics Anonymous? And then that attachment shows a credit, a $5,000 bill, that 35 cents
50:10
Unknown
each royalties per book, a dollar back to the groups, and $1.80 toward the foundation debt. So you can see Clarence's answer is no, and we'll see that again. So in addition to that, he wrote an eight-page handwritten letter, really small print, a lot of words to Bill. He started the letter on March 28th, and he mailed it on April 16th, saying there was so much to be said on the topic that he shall run out of paper before getting half of it written.
50:44
Moderator
This is the letter. He assured Bill that soon all the groups are going to have time to discuss and reply, but they asked him to write it. He felt obligated, so he invited Bill to share the letter with Doc. He said, Go ahead. I've called my sponsor. He shared about a whispering campaign and suspicions about Bill and Bob obtaining money out of the thing, and that some implied Clarence was also, and that really bothered him.
51:15
Unknown
Clarence said that was contrary to all the ideas and principles that had been accepted here. Cleveland, so far, has had about 3,000 alkies pass through the mill here, and always have we impressed every prospective member with the fact that this is simply a fellowship, a labor of love and an avocation, and no money or paid representatives could be evidenced. He emphasized group individual autonomy. He opined that most people would answer the questionnaire in the negative, and since 25% of all the groups are in Cleveland, and that they were directly responsible for carrying the torch elsewhere, that most of the members are going to feel that this matter should have been brought up with them before it ever started.
52:00
Unknown
And he said, From where I sit, it seems impossible to justify the actions, even if the motives were the best. And then he reported that the members were shocked to learn of the money going to Bill and Bob. He went on about everyone being equal, whether they're new, six months, ten years. He expressed the idea that there was no leaders, governors, or directors, and he told Bill that he always advocated that groups should always be broke.
52:31
Unknown
He stated that the position that a good cross-section of the more stable and interested thinking person in Cleveland, the idea of any person sharing in monetary action of our fellowship or foundation is not acceptable. So he was very much against royalties, very much against any money in this deal at all. Group should be broke. And then he went on to the book royalties, and he said one of the things they object to is that when the book was written, the purpose of it was to spread the word.
53:06
Unknown
And the understanding was that after the first issue was sold, the debts paid, there was to be a cheap copy printed for about a dollar, and no such thing as royalties ever crept into the picture. So Clarence was clear about where he stood after he got back from Fort Knox on this whole deal. He closed, leaving the door open for a conversation about the letter, and asked Bill to write him and ask him for any clarification.
53:36
Moderator
If he was unclear anywhere, go ahead and give me a call. So the wartime correspondence from those that continue to take a deeper look. Here's a real quick—he's back in Cleveland. He's getting this mail at his Cleveland address. Dewey Jensen wrote at his Cleveland address. He was at Fort Knox with Clarence, and now he's at Camp Hood, Texas, writing about life. Six-man tent with only candlelight, a little wood stove for heat, and no hot water.
54:09
Unknown
On the field for four days where it gets pretty chilly. And there's just a ton of these letters. I don't know if I can—I'm not going to share them all. There are probably 250 images that I have. But this one was interesting. This one was addressed to Mrs. C. Snyder from Ray J. Art. And if there's anybody that knows who that is, I would love to know. Maybe a church member, a friend of Selma's. He thanked Selma for writing him.
54:45
Unknown
He was glad to learn Clarence was back with his family. He hadn't been paid since December, but he said he couldn't use money where he was, so he's probably—he talked about a Japanese attack. His dad had sent a picture of the type of plane that he flies, so maybe he's a pilot or a navigator. He talked about the Japanese bombers overhead and the unearthly whistling bombs being dropped. It's just a really vivid picture of the war.
55:19
Unknown
He said, I've seen Jap Zeros and ack-ack bursting around my plane. A Jap Zero was a term for a Japanese fighter jet, a very agile plane that we were very concerned with. And then ack-ack is slang for anti-aircraft, so probably from
55:36
Unknown
the ground or enemy ships. But it was a very vivid letter. The envelope itself is an interesting artifact. So he's from the Fleet Post Office, San Francisco, so he's probably a Navy aviator in the Pacific Theater, maybe on an aircraft carrier or a naval air station, Midway or Hawaii perhaps. So the mail's free. He simply wrote the word free where the stamp would normally go, and he could send letters. Service members had that ability.
56:08
Moderator
And then it was passed by naval censors as well, so there was operational security protocol of some kind. So until now, most of the letters have shown Clarence through the eyes of AA members, but Dorothy gives us something different. In a nine-page letter to Clarence from his ex-wife Dorothy, she talks about their son, fear, faith, the wartime experience from her perspective at home, and they just seem to remain friends and co-parents and supported each other in their spiritual journey, because she talks—she's back east, so she writes on Hotel New Yorker letterhead.
56:45
Unknown
She was visiting her sister Connie, her nickname for Carolyn, Hank's wife. She opened up that she wished the pen were not so scratchy because she wanted to write a long letter. She said hotel pens are one step above post office pens. The first topic was Charles Richard Snyder, their son. She always referred to him as Dick, and Clarence always called him Charles or Charlie. So Dick attended a military academy.
57:13
Unknown
She wanted Clarence to commit to attending his review. She felt so strongly that she'd spend the money to come back from New York to attend if he couldn't. She shared very personally about her self-pity and negativity, and she said she was thinking about doing something very foolish. And later context, that may have meant that she was obsessed with marrying somebody so that Dick would have a good home. Then she concluded that that would be nuts.
57:45
Moderator
She praised her sister Connie for helping her through the hard time, and she said she was getting a lot better. She shared that Dick would like to go back to Nazareth Hall, the prep school in the fall. She talked about summer plans and that Bobby, Hank's son, would be there, and they'd be about the same age and they could hang out together. She reassured Clarence that Dick would not be alone because Connie was working nights, Dorothy was going to work day shift, six days a week for fifty cents an hour.
58:22
Unknown
She reported that Hank was fine, working in Connecticut, that she had never seen him so normal and so happy, and that he and Connie were really making a go of it at the moment of this letter, anyway. So the letter closed with a description of New York City during World War II, and she said one really feels the war here. New York at night is like walking in a deep cavern or valley. The tall, dark buildings on either side are awesome.
58:54
Unknown
Street lights aren't on. The traffic lights are a mere line. They have a total blackout test about once a week, which is not heralded and it's very frightening. She shared about soldiers and sailors of all nations roaming the street. And so Dorothy continued to ... blackout and highly successful. Makes my knees turn to water. So Ed Hughes, also Marty Mann. So his ex-wife, her closing really showed the principles at work.
59:23
Unknown
She said, Hope everything is going along smoothly and happily for you. You deserve it. Best wishes. Sincerely, Dorothy. And then here's just a hasty letter that she wrote, like whatever paper I could find, so she wrote it on an envelope. She says she's, the reason she has not written Dick but once this week is a sprained wrist, and she wrote this hasty letter off to him. And then really quickly after the war, Clarence is notified that he will not be recalled in July of 1943 by the Selective Service. Clayton Bull did not become an officer, but after prayer, he decided to stay in service as a non-commissioned officer.
60:07
Moderator
And he wrote here in this letter, With God's help, I'm still going strong. With God's help, I'm still going strong. In fact, before I signed in to stay, I spent some time talking it over with Him, and I feel that He guided me to the right path. Clarence wrote a letter of recommendation for Private William Chisholm
60:32
Unknown
to become a flying cadet in the U.S. Army Air Forces. I had the privilege of close association with Private Chisholm and his family and known to be a young man of unusual ability and excellent character. Corporal Spencer Powell wrote from the Army Air Corps in Arkansas thanking him for a Christmas gift. And here's a postcard from Homer Simpson. Truthfully, that's his name, aboard the USS Kason in the Pacific.
61:01
Moderator
He thanked Clarence for cigarettes and sharing about his first ship being shot out from under him. And then by 1944, he's deeply back in carrying the message. He's involved in something what we would call CPC work, supporting AA, which is helping returning veterans in the local Crile Hospital, which is a prominent military hospital in Cleveland of the time. He applies for GI Bill benefits when they're approved by President Roosevelt. You saw that.
61:32
Unknown
And by 1945, the war is over. Alcoholism is still a problem, and Clarence and a bunch of other AA members are all focused on carrying the AA message wherever they can. So this is a symposium that was held, a lot of speakers that you might recognize there. And so World War II is the setting. The letters are the primary source that give us a little glimpse, but the people are, you know, Clarence and all the other people are the story to me.
62:04
Moderator
And I'm just really grateful that this history is preserved, and I'm honored to get to share a little bit of it with you. And thank you very much. Thanks so much, Roger. Great job. And now we have some time for questions. If anyone has a question for Roger, please raise your hand and I will ask you to unmute. No questions, huh? All right. Well, I'll open it up for everyone to thank Roger, and thank you all for being here, and join us again next week for a presentation on Ebby.
62:41
Unknown
Yeah, that'd be great. Yeah. And everyone should be able to unmute. So thorough, there are no questions. Right. I don't know if I've seen that before. Or everybody's asleep. I don't know. Thank you, Roger. Thank you.
The following is an AI-generated transcript. Minor errors may occur. The audio is the authoritative source.